sack time here's my list

[Croat tiger]

Tivendale-useless
chaffey-moron
petticoat-soft as butter
graham-too old, too slow
campbell-too old,too slow
stafford-too old,too slow
newman-getting belted by no names now
kellaway-times nearly up but has been a good defender

 

[Thrice3]

I'd keep Pettifer, Kellaway and Newman out of that list.
The rest will be delisted or retire.
Hilton would be an obvious inclusion to that list also.

 

[Croat tiger]

I'd keep Pettifer, Kellaway and Newman out of that list.
The rest will be delisted or retire.
Hilton would be an obvious inclusion to that list also.

the only one that could be if that list is newman but i don't think petticoat can cut it afl level and kellaway is getting too old now.

 

[Whisky_McKay]

the only one that could be if that list is newman but i don't think petticoat can cut it afl level and kellaway is getting too old now.

Why the long face guys

 

[beaver's army]

its no wonder they say we eat our own.
its round 12 give them till the end of the season

 

[Croat tiger]

its no wonder they say we eat our own.
its round 12 give them till the end of the season

i want the cancer stopped now so i say drop the hacks now then turf them out at the end of the season.

 

[beaver's army]

i want the cancer stopped now so i say drop the hacks now then turf them out at the end of the season.

it takes time to get rid of cancer. pettifer is averaging over a goal a game stafford has kicked 10 goals from 8 games
newman had 26 tackles to his name before the start of the game
graham and campbell will be gone at the end of the season
AK had a poor game today but has played good footy for the year
chaffey can go bring in someone who has the passion for the club.

 

[Tambo]

wheres morrison?

 

[Croat tiger]

wheres morrison?

he's on the extended list so is hilton.

 

[froars]

Fickle Ferals

kellaway-times nearly up but has been a good defender

Kellaway was one of our best players last week - this week on the culling list

 

[Croat tiger]

Re: Fickle Ferals

Kellaway was one of our best players last week - this week on the culling list

only because of his age,he's not young anymore and this is a young man's game.even richo can't have more than a year or two left in him.

 

[Truetiger]

Tivendale-useless
chaffey-moron
petticoat-soft as butter Just like you
graham-too old, too slow
campbell-too old,too slow
stafford-too old,too slow
newman-getting belted by no names now
kellaway-times nearly up but has been a good defender

Pettifer has shown enough. he is kicking goals which is what he is paid for.
You call him soft as butter take a look at urself. He is out there ur not.

Newman while your at it you might as well name other good players.
kellaway still going fine so leave him out of it.

Shows you dont have much clue at all.

 

[Go BlUez!!]

I disagree with you. For one, you guys won the spoon last year, and now look where you are. You have really come a long way. I wouldnt drop any of the the players on the list, (maybe kellaway or campbell) because they have done well this year. Maybe low on confidence, however they will come good and are useful players. If your supporters are getting frustrated in the way you play, being a Carlton supporter isnt too much better. Good example is when whitnall was playing ********house at the start of the season, but his come good the last 2 weeks. It will turn around!!

 

[Croat tiger]

Pettifer has shown enough. he is kicking goals which is what he is paid for.
You call him soft as butter take a look at urself. He is out there ur not.Newman while your at it you might as well name other good players.
kellaway still going fine so leave him out of it.

Shows you dont have much clue at all.

what's this got to do with me he's out there because he's getting paid isn't he
and as a paid up richmond member i have a right to my opinion wether you like it or not because a part of my money is paying his wages isn't it

 

[sante]

Riduculous thread.


Graham will go.

 

[IDGAF]

what's this got to do with me he's out there because he's getting paid isn't he
and as a paid up richmond member i have a right to my opinion wether you like it or not because a part of my money is paying his wages isn't it

Just goes to show what a fu.kcen moron you are .... you have all those blokes out the door before Morrison and he is no where near even getting a game .

Pettifer.......FFS , been one of our better performed players this year .

Go back to the main board with your ridiculous statements

 

[Croat tiger]

Just goes to show what a fu.kcen moron you are .... you have all those blokes out the door before Morrison and he is no where near even getting a game .
Pettifer.......FFS , been one of our better performed players this year .

Go back to the main board with your ridiculous statements

now your putting words into my mouth now get in line you dumb moronic groupie!

 

[The Dice Man]

Pettifer soft as butter? I wouldn't ever call him a strongarm, and he has flinched on quite a few occasions in the past but he has stepped up this year and if you want some evidence get out the last quarter of the game in Brisbane.

He was put under pressure in contested situations at least 4 times and he did the right thing on each occasion, and his passes hit the mark. He is only just starting to get near the potential he has had for years and he is doing ok at the minute IMO.

Pettifer along with Tuck would be our most improved this year. He stays!

As do AK and Newman.

 

[Briedis]

Tivendale-useless Agree with you
chaffey-moron Bit Harsh - he's OK. Good depth player these days
petticoat-soft as butter Big improver I think. Looks to have bulked up a bit
graham-too old, too slow Was never going to be a long term prospect anyway
campbell-too old,too slow Should be his last season
stafford-too old,too slow He has been good for you I think
newman-getting belted by no names now Don't rate him at all
kellaway-times nearly up but has been a good defender Would keep him for sure

 

[Croat tiger]

Pettifer soft as butter? I wouldn't ever call him a strongarm, and he has flinched on quite a few occasions in the past but he has stepped up this year and if you want some evidence get out the last quarter of the game in Brisbane.

He was put under pressure in contested situations at least 4 times and he did the right thing on each occasion, and his passes hit the mark. He is only just starting to get near the potential he has had for years and he is doing ok at the minute IMO.

Pettifer along with Tuck would be our most improved this year. He stays!

As do AK and Newman.

diceman, pettifer is cunning little sod and watch him very carefully when he is put under the hammer by the other players he tends to crack like a wallnut.
he won't put his body on the line like cogs or tuck and that's why i call him soft.all he can do is finish when he's got an easy passage to goal but rarely will he put the hard yards in for his team.that's the reason why i have no time for him as do a lot of supporters,all i heard today from supporters around me at the dome was "pitifull" which is his nickname when he's playing bad.

 

[The Dice Man]

I know that is how he used to play Tigerboyz, but I see him as someone who has only become serious about his football this year and it's slowly paying off. He'll never be an intimidator, although he has tried a couple of times this season, but he has finally began to grow as a player and is not the same soft petticoat he has been in seasons past.

 

[Croat tiger]

I know that is how he used to play Tigerboyz, but I see him as someone who has only become serious about his football this year and it's slowly paying off. He'll never be an intimidator, although he has tried a couple of times this season, but he has finally began to grow as a player and is not the same soft petticoat he has been in seasons past.

that's yet to be decided diceman because he has to step up now brown is out
and today he didn't but in his defence last week in the last half he did.what i'm asking for is consistentcy and that's all,i'm not asking for the world.
he's averaging 1 and half goals a game atm which is not great for a half forward flanker,if he can get that up to 3 then you won't hear a peep out of me but i think he's not in that class.

 

[Rockridge]

Turnover Tivendale really has to go, no league footballer should make the same basic skill errors as he does time and time again.

 

[Tigerland]

Chaffey was good yesterday - one of our best. Pettifer is also a keeper.

 

[jackson_rules]

PETTIFER BEAT ARCHER HOW THE FU CK DO YOU CALL THAT SOFT AS BUTTER, chaffey played well, our backline atm will suck without kellaway as we have noone to replace him there, tivva has to go, newman is a better forwad then defender as we saw on the weekend, staff is probably our only forwad who can hold onto grabs atm just the ball isnt going to him, and campbell does good things with the ball, comeone tigerboyz you didnt to well with this thread