Sampi Or Bartel?

[linga_is_no1]

My mate and I had an argument over this. Who do you think is better Sampi or Bartel?

 

[zero]

hmmm, it seems you spend your entire life in arguments against west coast

this argument will be that once in 10 that you are correct: bartel is better

 

[aggotwang]

bartel by the length of the straight.
so so much better

 

[Tweak Talent]

Bartel by a mile

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

Jimmy

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Bartel by a country mile. Sampi is too inconsistent. Don't get me wrong, he's a star but much too inconsistent.

 

[celtic_pride]

bartel easily

 

[synista]

ok next poll,

Pavlich v Daniel Schell anybody?

 

[Nightwolf]

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Seriously, what fool would vote for Sampi....

Its probably a better idea to set a poll up: Sampi v Henneman v Guerra...

 

[DBAH0]

But I thought Ashley Sampi was better than Gary Ablett right?

 

[jmain14]

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Seriously, what fool would vote for Sampi....

Its probably a better idea to set a poll up: Sampi v Henneman v Guerra...

ha ha nightwolf - I too would say that dougy scott would give sampi a run for his money.

honestly though linga, obviously the mate you were debating with is an eagles fan going on some of these responses.

 

[thehoff]

Worst poll ever...

Sampi is a hack when compared to the hardness and ball collecting abilites of THE JIM!

GO CATS 2006

 

[RiCHii]

this is a stupid poll ovcourse bartel is 1000 times better and always will be

 

[Bestbird]

Bit of an unfair comparision at the moment

Your trying to compare a HFF to a midfielder

 

[trashos mob]

Bit of an unfair comparision at the moment

Your trying to compare a HFF to a midfielder

true, but bartel stands up more, is better for his team, more important and has proved himself more so at this stage then sampi. sampi is far too inconsistent

 

[Bestbird]

true, but bartel stands up more, is better for his team, more important and has proved himself more so at this stage then sampi. sampi is far too inconsistent

I will not disagree with the above, but playing as a small forward or any forward for that matter when your not the "Go to man" in the structure makes it very difficult to be consistent as oppossed to playing on the ball where your expected to get on average at least 20 possesions a game.

Playing the small forward crumbing role has also become more and more difficult as teams this year were dropping numbers back more and more, even G Ablett junior struggled to have an impact as much this year for this reason.

 

[linga_is_no1]

I will not disagree with the above, but playing as a small forward or any forward for that matter when your not the "Go to man" in the structure makes it very difficult to be consistent as oppossed to playing on the ball where your expected to get on average at least 20 possesions a game.

Playing the small forward crumbing role has also become more and more difficult as teams this year were dropping numbers back more and more, even G Ablett junior struggled to have an impact as much this year for this reason.

Gazza had a good year he was just being switched to the midfield more often than last year so you didnt see him up foward as much and a good small fwd/mid like chapman can still kick goals even with teams sending numbers back. Face it Sampi is crap pure and simple.

 

[pav_is_god]

A carbon rod would get more votes than Sampi in this poll.

 

[JeNnO_powerfreak_21]

Chris Judd or Nick Stone???? Got to be Stoney.

 

[Roughie]

are you taking the ********????? of course its bartell

 

[Mutant]

A carbon rod would get more votes than Sampi in this poll.

A carbon rod would get more votes than the whole mediocre Fremantle side.

Pathetic team, Pathetic Coach, Great List - on paper (what do you do with paper - wipe your ar**)

 

[linga_is_no1]

A carbon rod would get more votes than the whole mediocre Fremantle side.

Pathetic team, Pathetic Coach, Great List - on paper (what do you do with paper - wipe your ar**)

Well in this hole called Willetton they use paper for shelter.