Selections this week

Remove this Banner Ad

The Spornstar

Premiership Player
Apr 8, 2002
3,323
7
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Carlton
In:

Fletcher
Franchina
Fevola
Eccles
Christou

Out:

Hulme
Hickmott
Camporeale
Smith
Livingston


I'm pretty pissed off with these conservative, pretty much gutless selections. Dropping Smith? What for? Playing a player for less than half a game isn't giving them a chance. All I can think of is that he will be a late replacement for McKernan. As for Livingston, yes he has been beaten in his first two games but against Tredrea he was as good as he could have been and last week Rocca beat him soundly but didn't do that much damage. He's been playing on players who are out of his league after two games - why not pick him this week and play him on either a bulldog youngster (Saunders?) or hack (Bartlett?)?

I really wanted to see Justin Davies in the side - Instead we see 5 players who may mean we are a bit closer at the end of the night but may also mean that we are further away in the long term scheme of things. What's more we drop two youngsters. What the hell is going on?
 
Selections Rnd 6...

Would have to agree with u...why aren't they giving Beasy a crack yet???
4 goals last week...stick fevola on a hbflank and let merro and beasy run rampant in the fwd line...it's only the dogs...

i've waited a long time for this...10 yrs...but for once i see the pies light yrs in front of th blues re the future...good luck...with brittain, ypu'll need it...
:D :cool: :p :eek:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top