Settle an argument Essendon or Carlton

[gaelictiogar]

Settle an afgument at work lads

Clearly most of us regard Collingwood and enemy number one with the Blues and Bums as the other 2

Leaving form aside which of the two do you regard as bigger rivals?

 

[Radz]

Carlton, for sure.

 

[Rodgerramjet]

1. Carlton are the biggest c***s in the game
2. Collingwood
3. Essendon

 

[gaelictiogar]

Carlton, for sure.

Agreed. Collingwood are the big scalp but Carlton are the ones I like to beat even now when theya re worse than useless.

 

[Big Punt]

Carlton, for sure.

Agree

 

[UpTheGuts]

Hmmm, hard to say. When Lloyd kicked his 100th in the first final of 2001 against us to put them a lazy 60 odd points up and the entire essendon cheer squad turned around to have a go I must confess to having some pretty agressive thoughts.

That said, I do recall a few Carlton fans calling us f-ing tin rattlers at a few games. Hope I run into them again one day soon.

For mine, I hate Dons, then Pies, then Blues... but then again I'm really not a fan of hawks, cats, north. the 80's and 90's will take a fair while to forget...

 

[Darth_Tiger]

carlton by a whisker
then collingwood
then essendon

 

[cherryripe]

Essendon - arrogant, think they're better than what they are
Carlton - ditto, sense of entitlement
Collingwood - the filth but I really enjoy the rivalry with them

 

[Bojangles17]

Good question...

No 1 simply Hate collingwood's guts ..reasons have been well documented

No 2 Essendon's arrogance has to be seen to be believed

No 3 Hawthorn, refer above, simply refuse to believe how bad they really are!

## Id honestly prefer Carlton to be in a more competitive position than they are.

Footys all about the Big traditional rivalry, 60k at the "G" v the Blues is as good as it gets...if all footy amounted to was 22 games of Bulldog or freo type games , id be a much better golfer than what I am

 

[craz619]

1. Collingwood - everyone knows why.

2. Essendon - one song, you only got one song! - anyone that stands at the back will know what im talking about and plus everyone of there fans think they will win the flag each year. C**ts.

3. Hawthorn - we always seem to be in the same boat performance wise with them.

4. Carlton - Pack a ****ers.

 

[sante]

1. Bombers
2. Pies
3. Blues

All very close and if I were to answer this tomorrow the order would be different

 

[cairo tiger]

depends on the era, if you are talking jack dyers reign it was the scum, But i grew up hating th blue baggers and i still do, it was a Kevin Sheedy, Tommy Hafey thing.....Essendon everyone dislikes for me, blues, pies, bummers

 

[DyerBolical]

Collingwog and Carlscum equally hated, followed by Whorethorn (hate their public dunny colours).
While i enjoy beating Essendon I dont hate them, I see them as our sash brothers and have respect for their players and club, working class people who love their footy.

 

[froars]

Carlton is the club's arch enemy of late - probably before the '60s/70s, the Pies.
My personal hate is the Kangas

 

[Khan]

Carlton (just because), Essendon (arrogance) then the pies (stupidity)

Other contenders Geelong (the 80's), Doggies(Knighter) and Melbourne (the MCC)

Khan