Shall we do the players ratings???

[_RT_]

Who got the others???

IMO it should have been Petts with the 3!

Schulzt got the 3 votes Burton 2 Pettifer 1.

 

[HBK619]

Schulzt got the 3 votes Burton 2 Pettifer 1.

Pretty right, Schulz was definetly worse than Petts, and Burton was crap too.

 

[lookkg386]

Newman - 7
Bowden - 7
King - 9
Raines - 7
Polak - 6.5
Jackson - 6
Polo - 6
Johnson - 5 (Sorry, time to go too many free kicks that cost us)
Howat - 8
Pettifer - 7.5
Richardson - 8
Tambling - 6.5
Schulz - 4 (Did he play?)
Deledio - 6.5
Pattison - 6
Tuck - 5.5 (dispaosals son!!)
Foley - 9
Tivendale - 7
Meyer - 6
Thursfield - 6
Edwards - 8
Krakouer - 7

Thought Johnson was a 8 until half time, Krak also very good, Richo still the MAN, was the one who could of won it for us, plenty who lost it for us, patto/Deledio/Thursfield solid.

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Newman - 7
Bowden - 7
King - 9
Raines - 7
Polak - 6.5
Jackson - 6
Polo - 6
Johnson - 5 (Sorry, time to go too many free kicks that cost us)
Howat - 8
Pettifer - 7.5
Richardson - 8
Tambling - 6.5
Schulz - 4 (Did he play?)
Deledio - 6.5
Pattison - 6
Tuck - 5.5 (dispaosals son!!)
Foley - 9
Tivendale - 7
Meyer - 6
Thursfield - 6
Edwards - 8
Krakouer - 7

Couple of observations.Never ever thought King would play that well.He may have played like a hack the other games and still is a dead ringer for an oompa loompa,but credit due.Patto was good,but krakouer would win more hit outs.Deledio has developed a nasty handball habit,particlarly his signature one to a bloke standing still,needs to kick it more.Edwards was the standout I thought,Tambling was below 5,showed no intensity.Good team effort was the main thing.
Best not to mention the captain and his trusty mate Shane shit truck.I wonder if Kane knows Darren Gaspar and Andy Kellaway.Time they were introduced and spent some weekends together.

 

[Truetiger]

How did Tambling get 6.5 More like 3 or 4

 

[big bruno]

How did Tambling get 6.5 More like 3 or 4

Obviuosly we were watching different games... He delivered the ball well and didn't waste any posessions..

I must admit i was harsh on Pattison, and watching the replay he should get a 7.

Will not move on Tuck, Shultz and Johnson though... sorry they were all very ordinary.

Petts scored a great goal and played out of position... I think he deserved his 6.5.

Richo was awesome and presented well. The guy is without doubt the best marking forward in the game... sorry, no ifs buts or maybes...

 

[blaisee]

pettifer had a good solid game and did well in contested ball.

p!ss of krusty you hawthorn troll!

 

[David3030]

Newman - 7
Bowden - 7
King - 9
Raines - 7
Polak - 6.5
Jackson - 6
Polo - 6
Johnson - 5 (Sorry, time to go too many free kicks that cost us)
Howat - 8
Pettifer - 7.5
Richardson - 8
Tambling - 6.5
Schulz - 4 (Did he play?)
Deledio - 6.5
Pattison - 6
Tuck - 5.5 (dispaosals son!!)
Foley - 9
Tivendale - 7
Meyer - 6
Thursfield - 6
Edwards - 8
Krakouer - 7

Agreed with most of the ratings.

Sarge a 4? No he was less than that last night 2 would be closer.
Johnson 5. He was better than thata 6.5 is more realistic.
Pettifer 7.5. More a 6.
King / Edwards. Both had great games. Similar impact so either 8 each or 9 each.