Sheehan's Top 50

[BACCS]

Just been released, no top ten yet though.... Anyway 3 Crow boys in there:
Porplyzia-44
Vince-27
Goody-25

Here's a link if you want to have a look.
http://media.heraldsun.com.au/multi...raldsun_interactive_mike_sheahanss_top50.html
He's decided to go with a flash thing this year, its a little weird, and annoying.
That seems to be a fair few from Adelaide this year, is this the best we've done in the top 50 concept?

 

[Gets!]

If he leaves Tippett out he has absolutely no ****ing idea.

 

[ams4crows]

everyone knows he's got no ****ing idea he's got Buddy Franklin at 47 and he kicked bloody 70 goals this year! The Man knows nothing!

 

[BACCS]

If he leaves Tippett out he has absolutely no ****ing idea.

Can't see him making the top ten either, it is a joke, but we all know what little knowledge he has of Adelaide's players.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

If he leaves Tippett out he has absolutely no ****ing idea.

It is Mike Sheehan that's obvious isn't it?

 

[pjcrows]

Ryan Hargrave > Kurt Tippett.

Easily.

 

[Mark Dreher]

Can't see him making the top ten either, it is a joke, but we all know what little knowledge he has of Adelaide's players.

Pull the Reigns Baccs i know it is a very good day for the club and its future. He is not in the Top Ten of the league "YET"

 

[NikkiNoo]

Sheehan is the man who late this year stated on the couch that Tippett didn't have a lot of agility....

Which just proves that he hasn't really watched any of our players play at all.

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

Nathan Bock is the best CHB in the league by a mile. Surely he has to make a top 50 list? What a joke! Also, Clinton Jones come on, great tagger but seriously top 50 you have got to be kidding!

 

[aNty]

Heath Shaw > Goodes

Wait what?

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

When will we realise that Sheahan knows sweet fa about football. No Bock, no Thompson - what a joke. Who are Clinton Jones/Ryan hargraves?

 

[DangerRoo]

Who gives a s**t what Mike Sheahan thinks. Mine or anybody elses top 50 has just as much credibility. I mean this guys just writes things for the sake of earning a wage.

 

[BACCS]

Pull the Reigns Baccs i know it is a very good day for the club and its future. He is not in the Top Ten of the league "YET"

Not calling him a top ten yet, just saying he should easily be in the 50 ahead of the some the guys who got in, I mean how the hell was Heath Shaw so high?????

 

[Mark Dreher]

Not calling him a top ten yet, just saying he should easily be in the 50 ahead of the some the guys who got in, I mean how the hell was Heath Shaw so high?????

To quote a once great philosopher "the man is a arseclown". Being honest have not and will not read it because he is Melbourne version of Rucci and follows the print media guide to easy writing. Create some controversy wait till some one reacts and then the next 2 weeks articles write themselves . Continue to stir the pot to make his job easier and gets people reading his articles.
Sorry BACCS miss read your previous comment. Although Heath Shaw is important to the Collingwood back lines , who has a large supporter base where this clown's paper is pitched. Hence keep them interested therefore more papers sold and he keeps his job with a tidy pay packet.

 

[WALL-e]

Mike Sheahan is a cancer on the sport.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Tippy and Bock

 

[PortlandChris]

The guy is clueless....to have Nick Dal Santo in the top 10 in front of Jimmy Bartell shows that he really hasn't an idea of the game what so ever....I will keep going........Enright a good player but only got a top 10 gig due to joining "the golden child who covets individual awards" as Geelong BF, A Mackie at 30 before Ling at 40......Dustin Fletcher (backmen would need to play on the oppositions best forwards before they need be considered at all), Franklin-47 (what the???) and he had to get 3 extras from the top 4 in the last 3....Clinton Jones....to quote The Ox-Mike you Muppett.....

 

[Alex99]

Who gives a s**t what Mike Sheahan thinks. Mine or anybody elses top 50 has just as much credibility. I mean this guys just writes things for the sake of earning a wage.

Correct. I will go with this comment, who gives a rat’s toss bag that douche thinks.

We don’t need him to say our players are the best do we?

We don’t need his acceptance to feel worthy.

Mike Sheahan – who cares what you say.

 

[smoovy]

It is simply one man's opinion. His opinion is no better qualified than most posters on bigfooty. I would like to see a top 50 from a Buckley or a Lyon.

That said he has got out of it excatly what he and the Herald Sun wants - people talking about it.

 

[Huntercrow]

She-han the big girl, doesn`t make my top 500 journos

 

[birdmanptr]

Just been released, no top ten yet though.... Anyway 3 Crow boys in there:
Porplyzia-44
Vince-27
Goody-25

Here's a link if you want to have a look.
http://media.heraldsun.com.au/multi...raldsun_interactive_mike_sheahanss_top50.html
He's decided to go with a flash thing this year, its a little weird, and annoying.
That seems to be a fair few from Adelaide this year, is this the best we've done in the top 50 concept?

Not that i care about this wannabe but i remember Healy asked him after the 97 season no McLeod in top 10 maybe even top 5 testing memory a bit. His response was he judges players on how they preform in finals next year after back to back Norms still not in top 5 but had Buckley ahead of him who at that stage had not played finals Healy asked him again and he answered by changing the subject.

I also remember when rooch done his once and Tony Leonard asked him when he was doing the roast and they crossed to him Leonard said top 50 so whos the other 8 after ports 42

 

[Kid A]

I refuse to visit the Hun's site or to give Mike Sheehan the time of day, but let's just say that Mike would be #51 on my list of top football pundits, right behind Saddam Hussein and Kevin Rudd.

If punditry were a prostitution service then Sheehan would be the hooker inserting coconuts to make a bit of sympathy money. He's an oxygen thief of the order of Stan Zemanek.

 

[Crow Chick]

IMO, Matthew Scarlett is one of the most over rated players of this decade!!! Don't get be wrong, he is a very good player and pretty consistant, but it seems like people feel like they have to say he is the best full back just because others say he is.

 

[DirrtyBee]

Ha no Kurt in the Top 50 I'm not surprised. However I couldn't give a crap what he thinks. Sheenan is a tosser anyway.

 

[Geoffa32]

Just been released, no top ten yet though.... Anyway 3 Crow boys in there:
Porplyzia-44
Vince-27
Goody-25

Here's a link if you want to have a look.
http://media.heraldsun.com.au/multi...raldsun_interactive_mike_sheahanss_top50.html
He's decided to go with a flash thing this year, its a little weird, and annoying.
That seems to be a fair few from Adelaide this year, is this the best we've done in the top 50 concept?

Sheehan's thought process for our top three.

Goodwin, ah yes the Crows are an aging side. Simon Goodwin captain, he is their best player.

Vince. Hmmm blonde hair about 6 foot. Lets look at some tape, (Comes back after a couple of hours). He must be good to get 60 possesions and be everywhere.

Porps. WHo is that bloke with the dodgy shoulders?? Gerard Healy suggests Porplyzia, ah yes that is him.


They have some tall bloke who kicks goals rucks. Better leave him out though.