Sunday Mail (SA) phantom draft

[Ford Fairlane]

By Chris McDermott and Jesper Fjeldstad. I'm just the messenger.

1. Deledio
2. Tambling
3. Roughead
4. Franklin
5. Griffin
6. Monfries
7. Meeson
8. Wood
9. Deluca
10. Meyer
11. Lewis
12. Williams
13. Kirkby
14. Sharp
15. Grundy
16. Eckerman
17. Willitts
18. Murphy
19. Russell
20. Bate
21. Jackson
22. Gibson
23. McQualter
24. Pearce
25. Egan
26. Hartlett
27. Becker
28. Van Berlo
29. Wilkes
30. Bain
31. E Shaw
32. Young
33. J Toovey
34. McMahon
35. Maric
36. Rosa
37. Le Cras
38. Sherman
39. T Cloke
40. Redden
41. Blackwell
42. J W Smith
43. Polo
44. Morton
45. Newton
46. Blumfield
47. Ackland
48. N Ablett
49. Dunn
50. Little
51. Forster-Knight
52. Murphy
53. Thomas (Centrals)
54. Pattison
55. Wells
56. Griffin
57. Swallow
58. Egan
59. Prismall
60. Caracella
61. Garner
62. Caracella (yes, twice, their error)
63. Attard
64. Lee
65. Mark Graham
66. Pass
67. Delmenico
68. Hulme
69. Thornton
70. Pass
71. O’Hara (WWT Eagles)
72. Pass
73. Spriggs
74. Juniper
75. Richardson
76. Pass
77. McGough
78. Porter

 

[Lenny*]

Doubt griffen will fall to five/ tigers will take if available

 

[irel]

Is Caracella nominating for the National Draft?
Pick 18 Brisbane. Murphy who?

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Is Caracella nominating for the National Draft?
Pick 18 Brisbane. Murphy who?

Thomas Murphy (Sandringham). 190cm 84kg key forward.

 

[Andrew Lovett]

Adam Pattison will go alot earlier than everyone thinks Top 20

 

[irel]

Thomas Murphy (Sandringham). 190cm 84kg key forward.

Thanx
There are several Murphys in this draft.

 

[Kildonan]

Priority
1. Richmond 1. Deledio
2. Hawthorn 2. Tambling
3. W/Bulldogs 3. Roughead
Round 1
4. Richmond 4. Franklin
5. Hawthorn 5. Griffin
6. W/Bulldogs 6. Monfries
7. Hawthorn 7. Meeson
8. Adelaide 8. Wood
9. Carlton 9. Deluca
10. Collingwood 10. Meyer
11. Port Adelaide 11. Lewis
12. Richmond 12. Williams
13. Melbourne 13. Kirkby
14. Essendon 14. Sharp
15. Melbourne 15. Grundy
16. Richmond 16. Eckerman
17. St Kilda 17. Willitts
18. Brisbane Lions 18. Murphy
19. Port Adelaide 19. Russell
Round 2
20. Richmond 20. Bate
21. Hawthorn 21. Jackson
22. W/Bulldogs 22. Gibson
23. Collingwood 23. McQualter
24. Adelaide 24. Pearce
25. Carlton 25. Egan
26. Hawthorn 26. Hartlett
27. Brisbane Lions 27. Becker
28. Adelaide 28. Van Berlo
29. West Coast 29. Wilkes
30. Essendon 30. Bain
31. Sydney 31. E Shaw
32. Geelong 32. Young
33. St Kilda 33. J Toovey
34. Port Adelaide 34. McMahon
35. Port Adelaide 35. Maric
Round 3
36. Richmond 36. Rosa
37. West Coast 37. Le Cras
38. W/Bulldogs 38. Sherman
39. Collingwood (Cloke) 39. T Cloke
40. Adelaide 40. Redden
41. Carlton (Blackwell) 41. Blackwell
42. Kangaroos (Smith) 42. J W Smith
43. Melbourne 43. Polo
44. West Coast (Morton) 44. Morton
45. Brisbane Lions 45. Newton
46. Essendon 46. Blumfield
47. Sydney 47. Ackland
48. Geelong (Ablett) 48. N Ablett
49. St Kilda 49. Dunn
50. Brisbane Lions 50. Little
51. Port Adelaide 51. Forster-Knight
Round 4
52. Richmond 52. Murphy
53. Hawthorn 53. Thomas (Centrals)
54. W/Bulldogs 54. Pattison
55. Collingwood 55. Wells
56. Adelaide 56. Griffin
57. West Coast 57. Swallow
58. Kangaroos 58. Egan
59. Fremantle 59. Prismall
60. Essendon 60. Caracella
61. Sydney 61. Garner
62. Geelong 62. Caracella (yes, twice, their error)
63. St Kilda 63. Attard
64. Brisbane Lions 64. Lee
Round 5
65. Richmond 65. Mark Graham
66. Collingwood 66. Pass
67. Fremantle 67. Delmenico
68. Kangaroos 68. Hulme
69. Fremantle 69. Thornton
70. Essendon 70. Pass
71. St Kilda 71. O’Hara (WWT Eagles)
Round 6
72. Richmond 72. Pass
73. Carlton 73. Spriggs
74. Kangaroos 74. Juniper
75. Fremantle 75. Richardson
76. St Kilda 76. Pass
Round 7
77. Carlton 77. McGough
Round 8
78. Carlton 78. Porter

 

[eastaugh36]

I can't see us taking both Blumfield AND Caracella. Just the 1 and if we do it will be in the pre-season draft not the National draft.

 

[OldSchool]

Some of the Doggies fans wouldn't mind those selections.

 

[theorangeapple]

wont happen but a pretty good effort for the rought region a player might go. they have the eagles taking all west aussies. going by the last few years i would say this would be highly unlikely.

i will be shocked if sharp went 14. i think he could be a slider.

if juniper gets past the crows and eagles i cant see the dockers missing out on him at one of their poor selections if he's available.

would these guys have any 'inside' knowledge or are they blind to a clubs wants like the rest of us?

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

I can't see us taking both Blumfield AND Caracella. Just the 1 and if we do it will be in the pre-season draft not the National draft.

and we'd pick Carracella before Blumfield, he would be gone before pick 60 too if he nominated

 

[eastaugh36]

and we'd pick Carracella before Blumfield, he would be gone before pick 60 too if he nominated

I would prefer Blumfield. He would be on minimum wage wouldnt he and is a similar pickup to Murphy last year.We wouldn't have to use a high draft pick to get him unlike Blake. If he fails we haven't lost anything and if it works then it is a good addition to our team.

 

[Snickers]

Priority
1. Richmond 1. Deledio
2. Hawthorn 2. Tambling
3. W/Bulldogs 3. Roughead
Round 1
4. Richmond 4. Franklin
5. Hawthorn 5. Griffin
6. W/Bulldogs 6. Monfries
7. Hawthorn 7. Meeson
8. Adelaide 8. Wood
9. Carlton 9. Deluca
10. Collingwood 10. Meyer
11. Port Adelaide 11. Lewis
12. Richmond 12. Williams
13. Melbourne 13. Kirkby
14. Essendon 14. Sharp
15. Melbourne 15. Grundy
16. Richmond 16. Eckerman
17. St Kilda 17. Willitts
18. Brisbane Lions 18. Murphy
19. Port Adelaide 19. Russell
Round 2
20. Richmond 20. Bate
21. Hawthorn 21. Jackson
22. W/Bulldogs 22. Gibson
23. Collingwood 23. McQualter
24. Adelaide 24. Pearce
25. Carlton 25. Egan
26. Hawthorn 26. Hartlett
27. Brisbane Lions 27. Becker
28. Adelaide 28. Van Berlo
29. West Coast 29. Wilkes
30. Essendon 30. Bain
31. Sydney 31. E Shaw
32. Geelong 32. Young
33. St Kilda 33. J Toovey
34. Port Adelaide 34. McMahon
35. Port Adelaide 35. Maric
Round 3
36. Richmond 36. Rosa
37. West Coast 37. Le Cras
38. W/Bulldogs 38. Sherman
39. Collingwood (Cloke) 39. T Cloke
40. Adelaide 40. Redden
41. Carlton (Blackwell) 41. Blackwell
42. Kangaroos (Smith) 42. J W Smith
43. Melbourne 43. Polo
44. West Coast (Morton) 44. Morton
45. Brisbane Lions 45. Newton
46. Essendon 46. Blumfield
47. Sydney 47. Ackland
48. Geelong (Ablett) 48. N Ablett
49. St Kilda 49. Dunn
50. Brisbane Lions 50. Little
51. Port Adelaide 51. Forster-Knight
Round 4
52. Richmond 52. Murphy
53. Hawthorn 53. Thomas (Centrals)
54. W/Bulldogs 54. Pattison
55. Collingwood 55. Wells
56. Adelaide 56. Griffin
57. West Coast 57. Swallow
58. Kangaroos 58. Egan
59. Fremantle 59. Prismall
60. Essendon 60. Caracella
61. Sydney 61. Garner
62. Geelong 62. Caracella (yes, twice, their error)
63. St Kilda 63. Attard
64. Brisbane Lions 64. Lee
Round 5
65. Richmond 65. Mark Graham
66. Collingwood 66. Pass
67. Fremantle 67. Delmenico
68. Kangaroos 68. Hulme
69. Fremantle 69. Thornton
70. Essendon 70. Pass
71. St Kilda 71. O’Hara (WWT Eagles)
Round 6
72. Richmond 72. Pass
73. Carlton 73. Spriggs
74. Kangaroos 74. Juniper
75. Fremantle 75. Richardson
76. St Kilda 76. Pass
Round 7
77. Carlton 77. McGough
Round 8
78. Carlton 78. Porter

You've got St.Kilda down as having pick numner 71?? Isn't that the last pick? And Carlton have it. Any way the Saints have pick 65, and reading on FootyDraft.com is someone you have down for the saints called Brett O'Hara. Sounds like a pretty good footballer. Any one from South Australia know him or of him. Or anyone that doesnt live in South Aus and have heard something. Im all ears.

 

[mattyc2422]

2. Tambling
5. Griffin
7. Meeson
21. Jackson
26. Hartlett
53. Thomas (Centrals)

I'd be pleased with that.

 

[eastaugh36]

You've got St.Kilda down as having pick numner 71?? Isn't that the last pick? And Carlton have it. Any way the Saints have pick 65, and reading on FootyDraft.com is someone you have down for the saints called Brett O'Hara. Sounds like a pretty good footballer. Any one from South Australia know him or of him. Or anyone that doesnt live in South Aus and have heard something. Im all ears.

O'Hara is a ruckman who dominated juniors in the sanfl 4 or 5 seasons back, winning at least 1 under age medal. He broke into senior football and found his way for a couple of years and had a breakout season this year to give himself a good chance of being drafted. Probably considered one of if not the leading ruckmen in the competition now.

 

[stmookeyj]

You've got St.Kilda down as having pick numner 71??

This takes into account the list changes between 1st and 2nd list lodgements, which ultimately determine the draft order.

 

[superstar]

Hawthorn do very well.

Not sure who this Thomas guy is though. Maybe Clarkson is a fan.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

I would prefer Blumfield. He would be on minimum wage wouldnt he and is a similar pickup to Murphy last year.We wouldn't have to use a high draft pick to get him unlike Blake. If he fails we haven't lost anything and if it works then it is a good addition to our team.

i'd take Carracella, Blumfields knee is dodgy

 

[Snickers]

This takes into account the list changes between 1st and 2nd list lodgements, which ultimately determine the draft order.

Thanks

 

[Snickers]

O'Hara is a ruckman who dominated juniors in the sanfl 4 or 5 seasons back, winning at least 1 under age medal. He broke into senior football and found his way for a couple of years and had a breakout season this year to give himself a good chance of being drafted. Probably considered one of if not the leading ruckmen in the competition now.

Thanks for that eastaugh36. Thats helpful. So the kid can play. He is only 22. Would be worth St.Kilda picking up.

 

[Stiffy_18]

I think their fisrt round is probably as good as I have seen. Ther rest is speculative but I think their first round is pretty good.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Thanks for that eastaugh36. Thats helpful. So the kid can play. He is only 22. Would be worth St.Kilda picking up.

IIRC he's only 194cm. Too short for AFL ruck. Did a pre-rookie listing a couple of years back with Port but was overlooked.

 

[liz]

Can't see Sydney adding both Shaw and Ackland to an existing ruck brigade of Ball, Doyle, Jolly, Erikson and Goodes.

 

[sante]

i hope Tiges get Eckerman along with Deledio of course.


my order for Richmond is:

1) Deledio
4) Roughead or Griffen
12) Wood if he gets there..if not Gibson or DeLuca
16) Lewis
20) Eckerman

 

[tashibatts]

Who is the Egan guy they have the Roos picking up at 58 or whatever it is? Is he that Geelong Fullback? (Seems a little late for picking up Chris Egan from the Bushrangers)

Hulme at 68 would worry me.

Go Roos