Think Tank The BIG 4 - Revised...

[SterlingArcher]

Collingwood, Richmond, Hawthorn, West Coast and Adelaide the biggest clubs.

Apart from Pies/Eagles who are in every year, the other 3 are probably year-by-year to see which other 2 are 'big 4'.

 

[Josh_hawk]

We're the clear next choice from Victoria to take over from Carlton or Essendon. A regional club with the greatest dynasty of the modern era, it's really about time that these so-called 'big' Melbourne clubs start to get their shit together.

Lingy doesn't agree with you about the dynasty thing

He reckons someone outside the Big 4 has a better one

 

[Josh_hawk]

Isn't it owned by the Council?

Privately owned by the council

 

[Josh_hawk]

Sorry mate im sure you have some valid points to make but only clubs with a proven & dedicated supporter contingent and solid home base should really apply.

Quick question.

Is a dedicated supporter contingent referring to paid members?

 

[Geelong Dynasty]

Good thread chefmeister, those insecure Maybloomers can't hold their insecurities back.

 

[hawkman]

Good thread chefmeister, those insecure Maybloomers can't hold their insecurities back.

Except this time we haven't taken the bait. Haven't even seen a statistical breakdown yet

 

[chefmeister]

Quick question.

Is a dedicated supporter contingent referring to paid members?

Well it certainly wouldn't be directed at members who have a happy history of trying to vote their club into thin air now would it...

Good thread chefmeister, those insecure Maybloomers can't hold their insecurities back.

I don't expect them to come in here.
Mention BIG4 anywhere near them and they suddenly start puckering up with twitchy bum syndrome.

 

[Marley10]

Lel.

Despite being at our lowest point in history, we have more memberships than the Geelong "an extra 10,000 signed for Dangerfield" Cats.

That's what makes a true big 4

 

[bombersfan4000]

Except this time we haven't taken the bait. Haven't even seen a statistical breakdown yet

you buddy whorkk is always coming up with pointless stats

 

[bombersfan4000]

Collingwood, Richmond, Hawthorn, West Coast and Adelaide the biggest clubs.

Apart from Pies/Eagles who are in every year, the other 3 are probably year-by-year to see which other 2 are 'big 4'.

the eagles yes, the pies essentially have been a top 4 team for the last 15 years, give them a few years, with nafan steering the ship down to the bottom end of the ladder and see how the crowds hold up. the whorks at the moment yes thanks to several GF appearances but again in a few years it will be back to merger talks as all of their band wagon fans will have jumped ship

 

[chefmeister]

Lel.

Despite being at our lowest point in history, we have more memberships than the Geelong "an extra 10,000 signed for Dangerfield" Cats.

That's what makes a true big 4

Yes but cheats will never be part of a group chosen in these days of expansion for it's gentlemanly conduct in upholding the values of the game and spirit of the sport.

Like it or not, no matter how many fools who think cheating is the only way to win continue to follow you down your rodent hole it still means you are shit outta luck.

 

[captain blood 17]

Tigers back in. Thread need more Hawks. STAT!!!!