Opinion The Dons 8 Chances Broken Down

What will happen in the final games?


  • Total voters
    70
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

bomberswarm2

Club Legend
Nov 19, 2011
1,203
239
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
West Coast, University
After the loss to the Crows, we are in big trouble. I have broken down what we have to-do from here to make the 8.

The Run Home:
Round 20 - North Melbourne
Round 21 - Carlton
Round 22 - Richmond
Round 23 - Collingwood

Some Situations:
Win 4 Lose 0 - We are in the 8, maybe 7th or even 6th
Win 3 Lose 1 - We are in the 8
Win 2 Loose 2 - Hinges on margins and other results
Win 1 Loose 3 - Requires Draws and other extraordinary circumstances
Win 0 Loose 4 - Not a hope, look to 2013

Most Likely Scenario:
Round 20 - North Melbourne (Loss)
No severe need to win this game, but if North Win it they are practically in the 8. They have an easier draw, and this is going to be a tough game. Must not loose this game by more than 12-18 points.
Round 21 - Carlton (Win)
Must win game, no matter what happens in round 20. We loose this and we are practically gone. Carlton's season is next to over, and if we loose this our season will be like theirs. Howver, no use in winning this game by 1 point. We must thrash the Blues.
Winning Margin:
1-10 = Were in big trouble
11-30 = Need a big game next week
31-60 = Eases the pressure, still need big win next week
61-90 = Even though this is unlikely, we would still need a sizable win against Richmond.
91+ = Beat Richmond, by 20+, and we'll have a huge chance
Round 22 - Richmond (Win)
Tigers would like nothing more than to kick us out of the September race, and a loss here means we would need to cream the Pies into a soup the next week for any chance of September glory.
Aggregate Winning Margin of above 3 games:
Negitave number - 60: Bye Bye Finals
61 - 100 = If we bet North, we're in (barring a thrashing from the pies). If we didn't, support Melbourne next week.
101 - 160 = Hanging on a knife's edge, once again comes down to Melbourne.
Once Saturday comes around however, there is a more important match if we win. North Melbourne vs Fremantle. This match may decide our season.
Possibilities:
North Win: It all comes down to %agE
Fremantle Win: We need 3 wins from the final 4 games.
Draw: We need 3 wins from the final 4 games, or else they'll both get in by 2 points and we'll have a higher %age than Freo. :(
Best Result there is North Win. ONE EXCEPTION! If we beat North in round 20, and beat Richmond and Carlton, then if Freo wins we'll be in the finals.
Round 23 - Collingwood (Loss)
Its the biggest, baddest round of them all.
We can't have:
  • Lost more than 1 game until here
  • Been thrashed by any of the above clubs
  • Not have an aggregate winning margin of at least 120 points
Now, we can loose to the Pies, but we cannot get thrashed by them. Other matches this round:
- Gold Coast vs North Melbourne
- Fremantle vs Melbourne
If everything above has gone to plan, Freo and North need to win by 100+ to take a spot. Looking at the opponents, should be no problem.
As you can see, massive problems. The better GC and Melbourne do, the better off we are.
Probably can't loose by more than about 3 goals. A win however, seals our spot.
If We Make the 8:
No real point in making the 8 really, other than just to make up the numbers. Depending on results, we'll play either:
- Hawthorn
- Collingwood
- Geelong
- West Coast at Subi
And it dossn't look too good.
What I think will happen:
Our season relies on us winning at least 2 out of 4, winning those by at least a combined 140 points, and not loosing by more than 5 goals total. Even if we somhow manage to get into the 8, we will probably be creamed up by our first round opponent, and if we make it through we play one of the 4 in the above list, plus through the Swans and the Crows into the mix. All that away, mind you.

Prediction:
Essendon will slip out of the 8. I always had us down for the flag in 2013 anyway.

Stray Points:
- A Draw is as good as a loss, except against North



Your Thoughts?
 
I'll tell you one thing. I have never been so disappointed with umpiring, ever. I've said it in heaps of threads but it will take a few days for me to get over it.

We won't make it.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Ref your prediction: I think teams need to be solid finals performers for a couple of years at least in order to win the flag.....

As for making it, well it depends on who is available and our form. That's about it.
 
Had pears taken what seemed a pretty easy mark with under 20 seconds to go at the end of the game against the Crows today things might be very different. (Nothing against Pears - just sayin!)
 
Injuries have ended our season. We're done. Even if we limp in we'll just get smashed by whichever top-4 quality team has to take the 5th spot, most likely West Coast @ Subi. In fact, whoever finishes 8th won't get past the first week.

Daniher next year, new training facility, and hopefully a modified training program. Can't wait.
 
Had pears taken what seemed a pretty easy mark with under 20 seconds to go at the end of the game against the Crows today things might be very different. (Nothing against Pears - just sayin!)

Crows player got a fist to it. Nothing Pears could do.
 
Ryder, Fletcher, Crameri, Stanton, Myres, Zaha, Hibberd all back before the carlton games =

Vs North - win by 32
Vs Carlron - win by 46
Vs Richmond - win by 17
VS collingwood - loss by 21

7th spot and we will play Geelong away. Bookmark it.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Had pears taken what seemed a pretty easy mark with under 20 seconds to go at the end of the game against the Crows today things might be very different. (Nothing against Pears - just sayin!)
Well if you watch a replay you will see a defender punch the ball before it gets to him.
Just sayin.
 
ONE EXCEPTION! If we beat North in round 20, and beat Richmond and Carlton, then if Freo beats North we'll be in the finals.
 
Ryder, Fletcher, Crameri, Stanton, Myres, Zaha, Hibberd all back before the carlton games =

Vs North - win by 32
Vs Carlron - win by 46
Vs Richmond - win by 17
VS collingwood - loss by 21

7th spot and we will play Geelong away. Bookmark it.

Agree. We're built some good form momentum tonight despite not getting the chocolates. As you say all those players are back this season and that will add to the side and the pressure for spots.
 
After the game tonight I went to the post game event where Zaha, Kav and Hamilton answered questions.
Zaka said he really wanted to be back for North, but was told he should wait another week.
He sounded confident he would be back for Carlton.
 
After the game tonight I went to the post game event where Zaha, Kav and Hamilton answered questions.
Zaka said he really wanted to be back for North, but was told he should wait another week.
He sounded confident he would be back for Carlton.
Any other injury news?
 
Any other injury news?
Howlett and Winderlich would be 2-3 week injuries.
Expect Fletch, Crameri, Monfries, Hibberd, Stanton + more back next week.
 
Back
Top