The North BF Board Phantom

[Le Grille]

Hi guys, we at the north board did a phantom up to pick 79. See what you think.

Here's the link for some limited explanations of reasoning

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/the-official-nmbf-phantom-draft.1152456/


Pick 1 (ESS): McCluggage
Pick 2 (GWS): McGrath
Pick 3 (GCS): Bowes (matched bid)
Pick 4 (BL): Petrevski-Seton
Pick 5 (CARL): Taranto
Pick 6 (GWS): Setterfield (matched bid)
Pick 7 (GCS): Ainsworth
Pick 8 (FREM): English
Pick 9 (GCS): Scrimshaw
Pick 10 (SYD): Simpkin
Pick 11 (GCS): Logue
Pick 12 (NM): Brodie
Pick 13 (GWS): Perryman (matched bid)
Pick 14 (WCE): Venables
Pick 15 (ADEL): Berry
Pick 16 (PORT): Galucci
Pick 17 (BL): Florent
Pick 18 (PORT): C Cox
Pick 19 (WB): Hayward
Pick 20 : (SYD): Bolton
Pick 21 : (ESS): Marshall
Pick 22 (BL): Powell-Pepper
Pick 23 (BL): B Cox
Pick 24 (STK): Rotham
PIck 25 (GEE): Battle
Pick 26 (CARL): Mutch
Pick 27 (WB): Ridley
Pick 28 (RICH): Kerr
Pick 29 (COLL): Cumming
Pick 30 (ESS): Ryan
Pick 31 (PORT) Begley
Pick 32 (PORT) Poholke
Pick 33 (NTH) Williams
Pick 34 (NTH) Witherden
Pick 35 (WCE) Clarke
Pick 36 (FRE) Maibaum
Pick 37 (STK) Drew
Pick 38 (GEE) Atley
Pick 39 (FRE) Graham
Pick 40 (WCE) Waterman (M)
Pick 41 GC Scheer (M)
Pick 42 (ESS) Daicos
Pick 43 (GEE) Brayshaw
Pick 44 (ADL) Lipinski
Pick 45 (GWS) McCreadie
Pick 46 (COLL) Garthwaite
Pick 47 (SYD) Z Fisher
Pick 48 (MEL) Parfitt
Pick 49 (CARL) Tiziani
Pick 50 (SYD) Sproule
Pick 51 (WB) Scharenberg
Pick 52 (COLL) Himmleberg
Pick 53 (BL) Allison
Pick 53 (ADE) Young
Pick 54 (COLL) Brown (m)
Pick 55. (RICH) Rorke
Pick 56. (GWS) Morrison
Pick 57(GWS) Olango
Pick 58 (STK) Ratagolea
Pick 59 (CARL) Romeneski
Pick 60 (GEE) McCarthy
Pick 61 (COLL) Keitel
Pick 62 (CARL) Eddy
Pick 63 (ADE) LeBois
Pick 64 (ESS) Villis
Pick 65 (MEL) Jarman
Pick 66 (CARL) Narkle
Pick 67 (FRE) Rioli
Pick 68 (GEE) Darcy
Pick Zondor (GEEL) Walker
Pick 70 (WB) Baker
Pick 71 (BL) Long
Pick 72 (BL) Stengle
Pick 73 (FRE) Cavarra
Pick 74 (RICH) Hanson
Pick 75 (PORT) Duman
Pick 76 (NTH) Davis
Pick 77 (HAW) Watson
Pick 78 (ADE) Mihocek
Pick 79 (HAW) Williamson

 

[PhoenixBonez]

Please don't label Essendon as an asterisk on the drafts and trade board. It's unnecessary and inflammatory and will take away from your draft.

 

[Harvey Manfrenjensenden]

Carlton did very well on this one

 

[Le Grille]

Please don't label Essendon as an asterisk on the drafts and trade board. It's unnecessary and inflammatory and will take away from your draft.

Apologies, it was intended as a joke on the Nth board I forgot to change it. Adjusted it now.

 

[Hutchy Jnr]

How you have Simpkin ahead of Brodie is outlandish?? Simpkin hasn't touched the pill all year.
He is a last pick of the first round quality. Brodie will be snapped up in top 10, talks he will slide is crazy, a player of his kind wont slide just because he didn't test at the combine. Fremantle and Gold Coast will pounce for sure

 

[Le Grille]

How you have Simpkin ahead of Brodie is outlandish?? Simpkin hasn't touched the pill all year.
He is a last pick of the first round quality. Brodie will be snapped up in top 10, talks he will slide is crazy, a player of his kind wont slide just because he didn't test at the combine. Fremantle and Gold Coast will pounce for sure

I think there is a bit on the original thread on this, there were different people picking for different clubs. That said I have heard a bit of a buzz of simpkin going early.

One thing I learned watching this draft is that there are players you will be picked up for bargain picks.

 

[winalotroos]

No way will Brodie will drop to pick 11

 

[Apex36]

Collingwood won't pass on Daicos at any point after their first pick.

 

[bmaurizio]

Very happy with the Baggers selections, well done guys.

 

[Le Grille]

Collingwood won't pass on Daicos at any point after their first pick.

Wouldn't have though so, that's why I bid on him


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mofra]

Ben Long?
In the mix for our second pick, certainly won't last after our third pick.

 

[CotchNCo]

Would love to see Ben Cavarra get picked up.

 

[2006_Eagles]

Nailed WCE 1st