The reports

[The Dr]

Anyone see the Davey, Petterd reports? And apparently Sylvia is also a chance to get reported?

Anything to worry about?

 

[Dez!]

Davey - "Striking" by pushing to the chin, should be thrown out instantly.

Petterd - Truthfully telling the umpire he was shit, a fine for the truth.

 

[00Stinger]

i was right in front when Pettard got rerported. One of the west coast KPB was holding him and smashing him to the ground. Right after every little fight resulted in a West Coast free. So I reckon Pettard has told him about it and got reported.

That bald bastard of an umpire was West Coast's best player

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

Was watching the Davey report - weird thing was that at least 6 eagles did give him a working over (no free kick or watch), Davey ramps back almost identically and he gets reported. Farcical.

 

[melbournemartin]

Sylvia was just a push with the forearm that slid up and brushed the face. I don't know what points he's on but he should get many, if any at all.

Petterd should only get a fine.

 

[Capt_Concussion]

Was watching the Davey report - weird thing was that at least 6 eagles did give him a working over (no free kick or watch), Davey ramps back almost identically and he gets reported. Farcical.

It's because he's black...

 

[Deepthroat]

Sylvia would seem the most in trouble for mine.

It looked to be a classic right hook well off the ball.

If he doesn't get sighted the tribunal is a joke.

 

[saj_21]

Sylvia would seem the most in trouble for mine.

It looked to be a classic right hook well off the ball.

If he doesn't get sighted the tribunal is a joke.

Looks may be deciving, wasn't much in it and the player he "hit" barely moved wen contact was made. The only worry is i believe sylvia has points hanging over from earlier this year (he did a similar push to Josh Carr's head).

 

[Demon 86]

Looks may be deciving, wasn't much in it and the player he "hit" barely moved wen contact was made. The only worry is i believe sylvia has points hanging over from earlier this year (he did a similar push to Josh Carr's head).[/quote]

should get points removed and a medal for anything realted to hitting Carr!

 

[Tulip]

i was right in front when Pettard got rerported. One of the west coast KPB was holding him and smashing him to the ground. Right after every little fight resulted in a West Coast free. So I reckon Pettard has told him about it and got reported.

That bald bastard of an umpire was West Coast's best player

Pretty sure that was Nicholls F*cki*g Maggot

 

[w00dy]

Pretty sure that was Nicholls F*cki*g Maggot

It was, the other umpires were okay... But that was the single worst game I've seen from an umpire in a long time from Matthew Nicholls.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Demonology reporting Col got 3 weeks, surely not? Just when everything was rosy.

Davey thrown out apparently.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/80124/default.aspx

Yeah BC says it all here..

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

and here http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/80126/default.aspx

 

[Bartram_Class]

Lynden Dunn, come on down.

 

[w00dy]

From what I saw on the news, I think Col should fight this... The replay was far from conclusive, and he wasn't reported by an umpire on the day...

 

[00Stinger]

One question. If the AFL are trying to rub out anyone who makes head high contact then should Wirrapunda be looked at for his head high hit on Jones??

Im not saying that he should be rubbed out but it was intentional and head high

 

[kv_baby]

Guys, Its a completely different incident to what your are talking about.

Sylvia was shepparding the ball and instead of using a fair bump, he wound up a strike to the face of Scott Selwood.

From the vision on foxsports theres no way he would fight the charge.

 

[purple hater]

One question. If the AFL are trying to rub out anyone who makes head high contact then should Wirrapunda be looked at for his head high hit on Jones??

Im not saying that he should be rubbed out but it was intentional and head high

It was in a marking contest, and Wirra took the mark. The players came in from opposite directions and Jones got collected, how is that reportable?

 

[Pjkimber]

Jarred Brennan is the luckiest man in footy if Sylvia gets 3 weeks and he only gets 1!! Hopefully we call up Lyden Dunn to replace sylvia.

 

[Demon Revival]

Guys, Its a completely different incident to what your are talking about.

Sylvia was shepparding the ball and instead of using a fair bump, he wound up a strike to the face of Scott Selwood.

From the vision on foxsports theres no way he would fight the charge.

He was sticking up for Cale, he was giving Cale a good working over. A few other blokes should of cleaned up the Selwood scum aswell..

 

[melbournemartin]

In even better news, I hear that Jack Grimes has swine flu.

 

[Dez!]

In even better news, I hear that Jack Grimes has swine flu.

Not a funny joke.

 

[00Stinger]

It was in a marking contest, and Wirra took the mark. The players came in from opposite directions and Jones got collected, how is that reportable?

For head high contact.
Maxwell got done for doing nothing deliberate other than make accidental head high contact

 

[Mattman93]

He was sticking up for Cale, he was giving Cale a good working over. A few other blokes should of cleaned up the Selwood scum aswell..

Luckily Scooter is tough nut who was able to give Cale a 'good working over' within the rules, unlike Sylvia who is simply a dog for attacking a second year player.

One question. If the AFL are trying to rub out anyone who makes head high contact then should Wirrapunda be looked at for his head high hit on Jones?

I don't know what sport you follow but in the AFL a player is allowed to try and mark the ball, and a player who runs back with the flight of the ball may also occasionally cop a hard hit.
Wirra had his eyes on the ball the whole time, jumped for it, marked it and ran off. How is that an intentional, head high hit?