The Robert Harvey XVIII

[Oh When the Saints]

Nominate your best 22 that Robert Harvey has played with.

Banger started in 1988, so anyone who played from 1988-2007 can be in the side.

Most of the players are pretty obvious, but I think there is only one player in this team who wasn't an All-Australian at some stage (Frankie)


B: David Grant, Danny Frawley (VC), Max Hudghton
HB: Trevor Barker, Robert Elphinstone, Aussie Jones
C: Andrew Thompson, Lenny Hayes (VC), Geoff Cunningham
HF: Nick Riewoldt, Stewart Loewe, Nicky Winmar
F: Fraser Gehrig, Tony Lockett, Nick Dal Santo
Foll: Peter Everitt, Robert Harvey (C), Nathan Burke,
Interchange: Barry Hall, Justin Peckett, Dean Rice, Luke Ball

Em: Steven Baker, Geoff Burns, S. Wakelin

Coach: Stan Alves


Pretty decent football side ... look at that forwardline

Plugger ... 4 Coleman's
Gehrig ... 2 Coleman's
Riewoldt ... 3 AA's
Winmar ... 2 AA's
Dal Santo ... 2 AA's
Loewe ... 4 AA's


He's played with some champions, but Robert Harvey is the biggest champion of them all.

 

[Big Member]

He's played with some champions, but Robert Harvey is the biggest champion of them all.

Big call with Lockett in the picture, but I still agree with you!

 

[The Punter]

Grant Frawley Hudghton
Barker Maguire A Jones
Winmar Hayes G Cunningham
Riewoldt Loewe Ball
Gehrig Lockett Milne
Everitt Harvey Burke
Peckett Thompson Baker Dal Santo

 

[NeXus_Helen]

HF: Nick Riewoldt, Stewart Loewe, Nicky Winmar

Interesting Half Forward line. I would have to say that we would not win a single game with both Riewoldt and Lowe in our forward line.

They would be the 2 worst kick for goals that St.kilda have ever had. Although I must give credit to Loewe, he did improve a fair bit over the years. Rooey on the other hand, at this stage, is going from bad to worse.

I think with those 2 in the forward line, Hawthorn's record of 41 points in one game, (against us incidently), would be under threat.

 

[paul55]

wouldn't win a finals match with Buckets in the team, never played well when it countered!

 

[NeXus_Helen]

wouldn't win a finals match with Buckets in the team, never played well when it countered!

Hey Paul55, I really think you should be banned from this forum. Someone else already told you but I will spell it out for you. His sister commited suicide the week leading up to the Grand Final. So..........shut up!!!!!!!!

Did you also know that Winmar's dad died the night before the GF?

Paul55 = MORON = BANNED.

 

[St DAC]

wouldn't win a finals match with Buckets in the team, never played well when it countered!

He played a blinder in the 1997 PF. Short memory perhaps?

 

[Persevering Saint]

Is there any room in the side for Robbie Muir?

 

[sauce_head]

wouldn't win a finals match with Buckets in the team, never played well when it countered!

Do you remember the first final in 1997, when he moved into the ruck and single handedly won us the match against Brisbane after being down at half time?

Without that effort we wold never have played the 1997 grand final and you might have a proper perspective.

We are all dissapointed that we lost that GF, I was there and hated it. But some of us have move on after 10 years. It does not mean that we do not wish we had of won, but it does mean we are looking forward, not backwards.

 

[Kildonan]

Paul55 is della - a Geelong fan stirring Sainters on their own board.

I have cancelled Paul55's account altogether and given della a temporary ban.