The "take it outside" thread

[Spirit Level]

Dockernut you've created a monster

 

[apparentlydead]

Good to see you refused to click the link proving you wrong, don't ever change.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/the-take-it-outside-thread.1115334/page-31#post-41798002

Again...your link is utterly irrelevant.

ANY fish when subjected to the type of fishing that you and your dickhead mates subject them to will suffer various forms of barotrauma .

Your own link confirmed that, you spanker!

How many live by catch fish do you see thrown off a long-liner?

You are a compulsive liar and an ignoramus.

 

[ydraw]

Again...your link is utterly irrelevant.

ANY fish when subjected to the type of fishing that you and your dickhead mates subject them to will suffer various forms of barotrauma .

Your own link confirmed that, you spanker!

How many live by catch fish do you see thrown off a long-liner?

You are a compulsive liar and an ignoramus.

Did you read the link or not?

"Bight redfish live at depths from roughly 30 to over 300 metres. When released they have a remarkable ability to swim straight to the bottom, showing few signs of barotrauma. This is unusual for a species living at these depths, making them a good candidate for tagging."

 

[apparentlydead]

Very rarely see an undersized one in 60m of water.

Again...WUT!?

 

[Clems Knee]

I linked above to an article from fisheries WA discussing Red Snapper and how them being unaffected by barotrauma makes them a good candidate for catch + release tagging.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/the-take-it-outside-thread.1115334/page-31#post-41798002

I read that. Also found sites which aren't worth posting as they clearly have an axe to grind.
But I'm a bit confused
Nannygai are red snapper? Same as bight redfish? Which according to your reference aren't snapper or nannygai?
****ing colloquial names: give me a scientific name any day.

 

[ydraw]

Again...WUT!?

Baby snapper live in Estuaries and Bays. You really are learning a lot today.

 

[apparentlydead]

Did you read the link or not?

"Bight redfish live at depths from roughly 30 to over 300 metres. When released they have a remarkable ability to swim straight to the bottom, showing few signs of barotrauma. This is unusual for a species living at these depths, making them a good candidate for tagging."

"showing few signs of barotrauma"

That bit seems to be way beyond your comprehension.

It doesn't mean that they DON'T suffer from it.

Especially when you fish like you melon heads.



Idiots, idiots, idiots everywhere!

 

[Mudd]

you are all a bunch of karmichael rex hunt's

 

[apparentlydead]

Baby snapper live in Estuaries and Bays. You really are learning a lot today.

So now they're only baby snapper...not just undersized snapper like you initially claimed.

Full of shit much?

 

[ydraw]

I read that. Also found sites which aren't worth posting as they clearly have an axe to grind.
But I'm a bit confused
Nannygai are red snapper? Same as bight redfish? Which according to your reference aren't snapper or nannygai?
******* colloquial names: give me a scientific name any day.

Nannygai/Red Snapper/Bight Redfish are all different names for the same fish. They are not really a snapper.

The link you posted is a Snapper (commonly called a Pink Snapper in WA). Totally different fish.

In this photo, the pink ones at the top are Pink Snapper. The Red ones below are Bight Redfish/Nannygai. The brown ones on the lower right are Breaksea Cod. All 3 species are highly sought after eating fish so typically only undersized ones would get released.

 

[Clems Knee]

Not all species of fish suffer from barotrauma. And larger fish like queen snapper typically don't suffer from it that badly because they are quite good fighters and it's difficult to bring them to top that quickly.

Queen snapper? Is that different to a pink snapper, or the snapper I referenced? Which showed extensive signs of barotrauma?

I'm out, cos I'm out of my depth.
You never answered how many animals you threw back in the water to achieve those catches.

 

[ydraw]

Queen snapper? Is that different to a pink snapper, or the snapper I referenced? Which showed extensive signs of barotrauma?

This is a Queen Snapper. They are quite good to eat, but have a larger than normal rib cage which means you don't get as much meat off them as other fish of the same size. They also have some red meat which has to be cut away from the white meat. For those reasons we typically release them if possible.

This one isn't particularly big for a Queen Snapper. Around average size you'd get on the South Coast. Which is why they aren't typically too affected, because you can't just winch in a fish that size, you'll have to fight it all the way.

 

[AAACockburn]

If it is red it is dead.
Fillet and release.

 

[Clems Knee]

Why can't you bastards think of a better name than snapper for all these different fish?

 

[DudleyDocker]

Why can't you bastards think of a better name than snapper for all these different fish?

Yes, that's bloody confusing. We should call them all bream, that will clear it up.

 

[AAACockburn]

Why can't you bastards think of a better name than snapper for all these different fish?

It is a Dusky Morwong.

 

[ydraw]

Why can't you bastards think of a better name than snapper for all these different fish?

Haha. Good point. Fish naming has always been a problem. Doesn't help that fish and chip shops have been famous for making up names to make the shit they are selling sound better.

The official names are:

Australian Snapper
Queen Snapper
Bight Redfish

We call them...

Pinkies
Queenies
Nannygai

So we know which one we are talking about.

 

[apparentlydead]

Nannygai/Red Snapper/Bight Redfish are all different names for the same fish. They are not really a snapper.

The link you posted is a Snapper (commonly called a Pink Snapper in WA). Totally different fish.

In this photo, the pink ones at the top are Pink Snapper. The Red ones below are Bight Redfish/Nannygai. The brown ones on the lower right are Breaksea Cod. All 3 species are highly sought after eating fish so typically only undersized ones would get released.

Really, really disgusting pic in this day and age.

Truly reminiscent of the north not so many years ago.

We eventually got rid of the dickheads who ruined it for us up there.

Seems that they have moved, or originally came from down south.

Please don't call yourselves fishermen.

You're just shit.

 

[ydraw]

It is a Dusky Morwong.

Dusky Morwong is a closely related but separate species.

There is also a blue morwong, which looks nearly identical to a Queen Snapper but is a different species.

 

[Keys]

This is a Queen Snapper. They are quite good to eat, but have a larger than normal rib cage which means you don't get as much meat off them as other fish of the same size. They also have some red meat which has to be cut away from the white meat. For those reasons we typically release them if possible.

This one isn't particularly big for a Queen Snapper. Around average size you'd get on the South Coast. Which is why they aren't typically too affected, because you can't just winch in a fish that size, you'll have to fight it all the way.

Looks close to what we called spangled emperor or nor west snapper in Broome only they didn't get that big

 

[AAACockburn]

Dusky Morwong is a closely related but separate species.

There is also a blue morwong, which looks nearly identical to a Queen Snapper but is a different species.

Wow never knew that. I always called them Queenies.

 

[ydraw]

Wow never knew that. I always called them Queenies.

Typically won't see many Dusky Morwongs, they are vegetarians so are only ever caught by accident.

 

[Clems Knee]

Looks close to what we called spangled emperor or nor west snapper in Broome only they didn't get that big

And there's another bloody snapper which isn't. Don't they have blue markings around the mouth? Beautiful fish. I never saw one as big as in that photo though.

 

[ydraw]

And there's another bloody snapper which isn't. Don't they have blue markings around the mouth? Beautiful fish. I never saw one as big as in that photo though.

This one is bigger again. And yeah, very nice looking fish.

 

[AAACockburn]

This one is bigger again. And yeah, very nice looking fish.

Is that you?