Tommyneu Phantom Draft 2007.

[Tommyneu]

Round 1

(P.P) Pick 1 > Carlton - Matthew Kreuzer - 199cm 91kgs - Northern Knights (Ruck)

Pick 2 > Richmond - Cale Morton - 192cm 75kgs - Claremont (Utility)
Pick 3 > West Coast - Trent Cotchin - 184cm - 81kgs - Northern Knights (Mid)
Pick 4 > Melbourne - Chris Masten - 179cm 80kgs - East Fremantle (Mid)
Pick 5 > Bulldogs - Lachie Henderson - 196cm 90kgs - Geelong Falcons (Key Fwd)
Pick 6 > Essendon - Brad Ebert - 187cm 86kg - Port Magpies (Mid)
Pick 7 > Fremantle - Rhys Palmer - 180cm 76kgs - East Fremantle (Mid)
Pick 8 > Brisbane - Alex Rance - 194cm 87kgs - Swan Districts (Key Back)
Pick 9 > StKilda - Cyril Rioli - 178cm - 74kgs - *** Marys (Mid)
Pick 10 > Adelaide - David Myers - 190cm 85kgs - Perth (Utility)
Pick 11 > Sydney - Jack Grimes - 187cm 76kgs - Northern Knights (Mid)
Pick 12 > Hawthorn - Tom Collier - 192cm 86kgs - Tasmania (Key Back)
Pick 13 > West Coast - David Gourdis - 193cm 88kgs - Subiaco (Key Fwd)
Pick 14 > Melbourne - Ben McEvoy - 199cm 90kgs - Murray Bushrangers (Ruck)
Pick 15 > Kangaroos - Pat Veszpremi - 183cm 83kgs - Northern Knights (Mid)
Pick 16 > Port Adelaide - Levi Greenwood - 181cm 91kgs - Port Magpies (Mid)
Pick 17 > Geelong - Tayte Pears - 192cm 90kgs - East Perth (Key Back)

(P.P) Pick 18 > Richmond - Scott Selwood - 184cm 81kgs - Bendigo Pioneers (Mid)

Round 2

Pick 19 > Bulldogs - Tom Bellchambers - 199cm 91kgs - Tasmania (Ruck)
Pick 20 > West Coast - Addam Maric - Blah Blah - Blah Blah (Sml Fwd, Mid)
Pick 21 > Melbourne - Scott Simpson - 194cm 91kgs - Dandenong (Key Fwd)
Pick 22 > West Coast - Tony Notte - 194cm 70kgs - Swan Districts (Utility)
Pick 23 > Essendon - Patrick McGinnity - 182cm 75kgs - Claremont (Mid)
Pick 24 > Fremantle - Steven Gaertner - 196cm 83kg - Dandenong (Key Back)
Pick 25 > Brisbane - Robbie Tarrant - 196cm 92kgs - Bendigo Pioneers (Key Fwd)
Pick 26 > Sydney - Patrick Dangerfield - 188cm 80kgs - Geelong Falcons (Mid)
Pick 27 > Adelaide - Jarrod Grant - 191cm, 77kgs- Dandenong Stingrays (Key Fwd)
Pick 28 > Port Adelaide - Marlon Motlop - 181cm 76kgs - North Adelaide (Sml Fwd)
Pick 29 > Hawthorn - Callan Ward - 183cm 71kg - Western Jets (Mid)
Pick 30 > West Coast - Steven Browne - 181cm 74kg - West Perth (Mid)
Pick 31 > Collingwood - Dawson Simpson - 207cm 97kgs - Murray (Ruck)
Pick 32 > Kangaroos - Andy Otten - 192cm 86kgs - Oakleigh Chargers (Utility)
Pick 33 > Port Adelaide - Chris Kangars - 193cm 84kgs - Geelong Falcons (Utility)
Pick 34 > Geelong - Ashley Arrowsmith - 188cm 82kgs - Calder Cannons (Utility)

Round 3

Pick 35 > Bulldogs - Dan McKenna - 194cm - 82kgs - Gippsland Power (Key Back)
Pick 36 > Carlton - Haelan Kay - 186cm 75kgs - Gippsland Power (Utility)
Pick 37 > Kangaroos - Matthew Westhoff - 197cm 83kg- Central District (Key Fwd)
Pick 38 > Adelaide - Matthew De Boer - 185cm 81kgs - Claremont (Mid)
Pick 39 > Essendon - Darcy Daniher (F/S) -192cm 89kgs - Calder Cannons (Key F)
Pick 40 > Fremantle - Trent Dennis-Lane - 182cm - Subiaco (Sml Fwd)
Pick 41 > Brisbane - Sam Reid - 185cm 75kg - Queensland
Pick 42 > StKilda - Andrew Renton - 202cm 94kgs - Eastern Ranges (Ruck)
Pick 43 > Bulldogs - Zane Murphy - 182cm 85kgs - Queensland (Mid)
Pick 44 > Geelong - Brendan Whitecross 182cm 79kgs - Queensland (Mid)
Pick 45 > Hawthorn - David Zahakaris - Northern Knights - 180cm, 70kgs (Mid)
Pick 46 > Carlton - Ashley Hockey - 181cm 78kg – Murray (Sml Def, Mid)
Pick 47 > Collingwood - Craig Bird - 178cm 76kgs - NSW/ACT Rams (Mid)
Pick 48 > Bulldogs - Aaron Joseph - 178cm 75kgs - Tasmania (Mid)
Pick 49 > Port Adelaide - Lachie Hill - 189cm 83kg - Oakleigh Chargers (Utility)
Pick 50 > Geelong - Mitch Farmer - 179cm 79kgs - Calder (Sml Def, Mid)

Round 4

Pick 51 > Richmond - Brad Gilder - 183cm 84kg - Sandringham Dragons (Mid)
Pick 52 > Brisbane - James Mulligan - 201cm 96kgs - Southport (Ruck, Key Fwd)
Pick 53 > Melbourne - Travis Dulic - 192cm 90kg - Calder Cannons (Key Def)
Pick 55 > Essendon - Jay Bowden - 184cm 74kg - Tasmania (Med Fwd, Wing)
Pick 56 > Fremantle - Jarrhan Jacky - 180cm 71kg - Subiaco (Sml Fwd)
Pick 57 > Brisbane - Joseph Daye - 194cm 79kg - Queensland (Utility)
Pick 58 > StKilda - Mitch Enright - 179cm 74kg - Queensland (Mid)
Pick 59 > Adelaide - Matthew Wright - 176cm 76kg - North Adelaide (Sml Fwd, Mid)
Pick 60 > Sydney - Luke Potts - 177cm 68kg - Dandenong (Sml Fwd)
Pick 61 > Hawthorn - Rhyce Prismall - 189cm 86kg – Western Jets (Mid, Wing)
Pick 62 > Geelong - Michael Rockefeller - 177cm 77kg - Werribee (Mid)
Pick 63 > Collingwood - Brad Jones - 184cm 75kg - Eastern Ranges (Mid)
Pick 64 > Kangaroos - Matthew Davis - 187cm 74kg - Mt. Gravatt (Mid)
Pick 65 > Port Adelaide - Casey Carr - 184cm 79kg - Port Magpies (Sml Fwd, Mid)
Pick 66 > Bulldogs - Sam Fairclough - 179cm 80kg - Woodville-West Torrens (Mid)

Round 5

Pick 67 > Richmond - Daniel Brittain - 178cm 77kg - Southport (Awesome Mid!)
Pick 68 > Carlton - Joel Smouha 196cm 80kg - Mt. Gravatt (Ruck)
Pick 69 (Lovely) > Melbourne - Guy O'Keefe - 184cm 76kg - Geelong Falcons (Mid)
Pick 70 > Bulldogs - Clayton Collard - 182cm 90kg - Sth Fremantle/Fremantle (Mid)
Pick 71 > Essendon - Luke Stanton - 191cm 79kg - Northern Knights (Key Fwd)
Pick 72 > Fremantle - Kepler Bradley - 199cm 100kg - Essendon (Key Back)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

After Pick 72, it's pretty hard to judge so that will have to do for me. Tommyneu.

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

Well i hope that doesnt happen. That being Masten. McEvoy and Simpson would be steals at those numbers

 

[dutchy12]

Pick 4: Option from Cotchin > Erbert > Henderson > Palmer. (Not Masten)
Hopefully its Cotchin. If not would look at Erbert next. Don't mind Henderson and Palmer, however, Henderson's injury is a concern and Palmer, might wanting to return WA sooner or later.

Pick 14: Scott Simpson
He is the man the club need to replace Neitz. Simpson is a gun.

Pick 21: Gaertner
Since Rance will be taken at top 10, a KPP FB is required. Gaernter is the one best available.

Pick 53: Thoolan
KPP FF. Handy player, similar to size to Ben Holland. Might worth develop this player as a backman as well.

Pick 69:
A midfielder with pace.

Pick 85:
Same as pick 69 or best recycle player available.

Doubt the club will draft a ruckman with the inclusion of Meeson. Having to add Meeson, there are 4 ruckman on list: White, P Johnson, Jamar & Meeson.

Must save one spot for PSD or 2 spots if Pick 85 is not used.

Thoughts?

Are u purely discounting Masten cause of a "go home factor" or is it somethign else injury? Most ppl are having him at 4

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Masten at 4 would be ok although he seems like another McLean and Jones type player... do we need another?

Not keen on McEvoy at all, and if this Simpson bloke is as good as everyone suggests then why the hell is he falling through to pick #21?

 

[goDees22]

Masten apparently has OP.

Cotchin is definitely the man we want with 4, won't get there unless richmond do something richmondlike and pick some random dud and west coast go with morton

 

[Junior55]

Masten apparently has OP.

Cotchin is definitely the man we want with 4, won't get there unless richmond do something richmondlike and pick some random dud and west coast go with morton

Wont happen, WCE will take Cotchin even if Morton is available.

 

[dutchy12]

Wont happen, WCE will take Cotchin even if Morton is available.

btu he's not the pure midfielder u want to replace judd and cousins. it will take him 4-5 years to build up a fitness base, masten is your man

 

[Junior55]

btu he's not the pure midfielder u want to replace judd and cousins. it will take him 4-5 years to build up a fitness base, masten is your man

Nah, Cotchin has the ability to step straight into the side as a HFF/Mid.

After Woodhouse found out that Judd was leaving he said that we wanted to get Cotchin with our first pick and with the Cousins saga this will only enforce that thought.

Cotchin is the one midfielder that could turn into the next Judd (Elite Midfielder) and IMO is the best player in the draft.

While i would love to get Masten for other reasons (Has an amazing amount of links with the eagles). Cotchin is the one we will pick if he is available IMO.

 

[KTLK]

If West Coast has expressed their concerns on Judd factor leaving WA to Carlton directly to AFL. Would they want to repeat this (Judd's case) again in the next few years?

Well, 24th November will tell.

 

[Junior55]

If West Coast has expressed their concerns on Judd factor leaving WA to Carlton directly to AFL. Would they want to repeat this (Judd's case) again in the next few years?

Well, 24th November will tell.

No chance that they will take a lesser player from WA if there is a better player from Victoria available.

They have a very good record of keeping good players from interstate at the club. But yes like you said we will wait and see.

 

[BigBadCam]

Geelong will draft a ruckman with their 1st or 2nd pick.

 

[TURKEY92]

id much rather:
#4= Henderson
#14= Veszpremi
#21= S.Simpson

 

[Deenamite]

Well done Tommy. I would honestly be happy with that, if it was to happen but Pick 4's the big one.

 

[master bate]

Good effort to put something out there, I'm happy with what you've done because we get a midfielder, a key position player and a ruckmen. Which players we actually get doesn't bother me too much because we have no idea on whether they will actually be able to play, but getting a good spread with our top picks makes sense to me.

 

[QLDr that knows]

wat about dayne zorko captaind QLD, reads the ball like and absolute dream not to mention his great skills on both sides ????

 

[goDees22]

nah, don't trust his name

 

[QLDr that knows]

wat is it about names or is it about abilities ???

 

[goal sneak]

Valenti either with our last pick or first pick in the PSD

 

[Deenamite]

Valenti last pick in the draft.

 

[DemonErrol1964 - dees]

Victorian Forward All Australian Adem Maric dosen't rate in the top 72 phantom call WTF.

 

[Tommyneu]

Victorian Forward All Australian Adem Maric dosen't rate in the top 72 phantom call WTF.

Yeah completely forgot about him. Stress less, I've edited now.

 

[Ruanaidh]

Richmond taking 4 mids.....I think not.