Remove this Banner Ad

Top 5 Players in the APS

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Kent Hater said:
Top 5 would have to be :

5. Monty "chabs magavin" wilson
4. Jack "rambo" macciolli
3. Chris "steam train" wischer
2. Elliot "diadora" haralambous
1. Lachie "dukes" Bennett
Click to expand...
are you drunk???
never herd of any of them or are u talking about another comp other than APS?
 
Couch Potato said:
Very different players, how can you compare them?

I would say for marking strength and presence - Ziebell

For disposal and flair - Cachia

Both have excellent competitive aspects to them - they would be amoungst the best Yr 11s no doubt with Scully, Hannebery and Watts.
Click to expand...
fair call.
 
back2back4dacat said:
i doubt shaw will get drafted he's to slow
Click to expand...
he got below 3 seconds for the 20m sprint last week - obviously not too slow. Doesn't care about tac footy, only school footy. Many players have been drafterd purely out of the APS. Is probs an outside chance, depends if he cares or not about making it. Clubs could be interested cos he is reasonable tall, fairly well built and could play midfield, forward or possibly even back.

Was tagged for about half the games last yr and still made the aps team, he is clearly one of the most valuable and influential players in the APS. Depends whether afl clubs see potential in him
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Richo is God said:
cachia would definatly not be top 5 in the APS hes a good player, dont get me wrong, but hes not top 5. jack ziebell would definatly be ahead of him
Click to expand...


good point !!!!
its hard to choose if its like an all star 5 u need sum versatitlite and there a plenty of good backman around
 
back2back4dacat said:
i doubt shaw will get drafted he's to slow
Click to expand...

Not sure - was thinking Ziebel is yr 12 (??)so while bottom age is a starter for this years draft...... even tho still only 17yo doesn't have the same tag as say Dangerfield????
 
the rotating forward said:
he got below 3 seconds for the 20m sprint last week - obviously not too slow. Doesn't care about tac footy, only school footy. Many players have been drafterd purely out of the APS. Is probs an outside chance, depends if he cares or not about making it. Clubs could be interested cos he is reasonable tall, fairly well built and could play midfield, forward or possibly even back.

Was tagged for about half the games last yr and still made the aps team, he is clearly one of the most valuable and influential players in the APS. Depends whether afl clubs see potential in him
Click to expand...

thats the same as lisle, except he was tagged every week and made the APS team
 
the few games ive seen of shaw... his nearlly as over rated as lisle.
plenty of excuses for the bloke, rarely gets the job dun though.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

over the top said:
1. Lynch
2. Scully
3. Ziebell
4. Vickery
5. Kennedy

Lynch and Scully are miles ahead of ziebell though. very big drop
Click to expand...

interesting comment ziebell is highly rated by a lot will be interesting where he goes in this years draft . Different player to scully but no doubt as influential on a game both have been selected in leadership group for ais/afl tour of st Africa as bottom agers where lynch hasnt so they must be rated high . Vickery and kennedy are as good also imo so while they might be a bit higher tough call to say big gap between the top 2 and the rest.
 
Hunch said:
interesting comment ziebell is highly rated by a lot will be interesting where he goes in this years draft . Different player to scully but no doubt as influential on a game both have been selected in leadership group for ais/afl tour of st Africa as bottom agers where lynch hasnt so they must be rated high . Vickery and kennedy are as good also imo so while they might be a bit higher tough call to say big gap between the top 2 and the rest.
Click to expand...

i agree there hunch ziebell scully vickery lynch are are all very good in different ways i compare them as you would ,hodge,brown ,delidio mooney , All different types but very effective not saying they are the the exact types i have given but all contast like the examples given . Scully is an outside player with phenominal endurance explosive pace and great ball use . Lynch is dynamic strong and versatile . Ziebell is hard ,huge kick,goodmark and very adaptable,vickery is talented stong attacking etc etc all different but all equally as damaging . You couldnt compare them as they are all different .
 
the rotating forward said:
he got below 3 seconds for the 20m sprint last week - obviously not too slow. Doesn't care about tac footy, only school footy. Many players have been drafterd purely out of the APS. Is probs an outside chance, depends if he cares or not about making it. Clubs could be interested cos he is reasonable tall, fairly well built and could play midfield, forward or possibly even back.

Was tagged for about half the games last yr and still made the aps team, he is clearly one of the most valuable and influential players in the APS. Depends whether afl clubs see potential in him
Click to expand...

This whole post seems like BS. i would be astounded if shaw ran under 3 seconds very few players did apparently and some clubs didn't have any players under 3 seconds. Also there isn't anyone who 'doesn't care' about TAC footy that just sounds like an excuse for the fact that shaw can't cope with the next level up and is happy to play well in a mediocre competition like the APS.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

danharris#4 said:
This whole post seems like BS. i would be astounded if shaw ran under 3 seconds very few players did apparently and some clubs didn't have any players under 3 seconds. Also there isn't anyone who 'doesn't care' about TAC footy that just sounds like an excuse for the fact that shaw can't cope with the next level up and is happy to play well in a mediocre competition like the APS.
Click to expand...
at gramma we had heaps under or around 3 seconds about 5 under and almost everyone else between 3-3.15
 
danharris#4 said:
This whole post seems like BS. i would be astounded if shaw ran under 3 seconds very few players did apparently and some clubs didn't have any players under 3 seconds. Also there isn't anyone who 'doesn't care' about TAC footy that just sounds like an excuse for the fact that shaw can't cope with the next level up and is happy to play well in a mediocre competition like the APS.
Click to expand...
Ben Hayes, Hamish Hurley, Alex Keath, Anthony Long, Charles Shaw, Hugh Vickers-Villis and James Vine all got under 3 seconds and some of our quickest people still haven't done it.
 
danharris#4 said:
This whole post seems like BS. i would be astounded if shaw ran under 3 seconds very few players did apparently and some clubs didn't have any players under 3 seconds. Also there isn't anyone who 'doesn't care' about TAC footy that just sounds like an excuse for the fact that shaw can't cope with the next level up and is happy to play well in a mediocre competition like the APS.
Click to expand...

An ignorant statement
 
This thread has just turned into another slinging match. So I'm just going to say who, I think, in my 100% unbaised opinion, is the best school footballer.

Jordan Lisle.

There, I said it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom