Top 5

[Snickers]

Who has been your top 5 Saint Players over the years?

Mine would be (in no order)
1. Winmar
2. Lockett
3. Hayes
4. Harvey
5. Riewoldt

 

[Kildonan]

Trevor Barker
Tony Lockett
Daryl Baldock
Jeff Dunne
Robert Harvey

 

[m.diddy]

it all depnds on age.

From what i've seen it would be
Harvey
Lockett
Riewoldt
Burke
Loewe
(sorry to Winmar)

All time it is
Ian Stewart
Harvey
Baldock
Barker
Lockett

 

[Snickers]

it all depnds on age.

From what i've seen it would be
Harvey
Lockett
Riewoldt
Burke
Loewe
(sorry to Winmar)

All time it is
Ian Stewart
Harvey
Baldock
Barker
Lockett

How could you leave him out?!

 

[bsk2002]

1. Robert Harvey
2. Stewie Loewe
3. Nicky Winnmar
4. The G
5. ROo

 

[m.diddy]

How could you leave him out?!

I njust reckon loewe and burke were a little more consistent and also were better leaders

 

[Snickers]

I njust reckon loewe and burke were a little more consistent and also were better leaders

He was my favourite player of years.

My 5 all time greatest favourite players were
Winmar- Number 7
Hayes- Number 7
Lockett Number 14, 4
Harvey- Number 35
Riewoldt- Number 12.

So with Lenny taking Nicky's number i didnt have to change the number on my back.

 

[m.diddy]

I reckon hayes has a long way to go before i consider him in the top 5 i've seen. Snickers you can't seriously have him above loewe and burkey can you?

 

[Snickers]

I reckon hayes has a long way to go before i consider him in the top 5 i've seen. Snickers you can't seriously have him above loewe and burkey can you?

I think the way he plays, and the way he goes about his footy, I classify that as a excellent.

Top 5 IMO doesnt neccisarilly mean that the Top 5 players have to be the best skilled.

Lenny tackles hard, and does alot of the 1%ers, which sometimes go unnoticed. And thats what i classify as Top 5.

 

[Bentleigh]

Who has been your top 5 Saint Players over the years?

Mine would be (in no order)
1. Winmar
2. Lockett
3. Hayes
4. Harvey
5. Riewoldt

Hayes > Harvey
Hayes > Ian Stewart

No idea what so ever.

 

[IDGAF]

Mick Malthouse
Russel Greene
Morty Domberg
Alex Jesalenko
Mark Jackson

 

[Snickers]

Hayes > Harvey
Hayes > Ian Stewart

No idea what so ever.

What would you know Bentleigh.

You wouldnt have a clue.

Lenny Hayes has a fantastic work ethis and IMO he is in MY Top 5 players.

 

[Kildonan]

Hayes > Harvey
Hayes > Ian Stewart

No idea what so ever.

Bentley, the thread asks for the poster's top 5, the thread is not about anticipating Bentleigh's top 5 (as who would give a toss).

Now stop your small-minded vendatta against Snickers as it is so childish, if you have anything valuable to add, then do so just don't be such a dill.

 

[Bentleigh]

Bentley, the thread asks for the poster's top 5, the thread is not about anticipating Bentleigh's top 5 (as who would give a toss).

Now stop your small-minded vendatta against Snickers as it is so childish, if you have anything valuable to add, then do so just don't be such a dill.

Any who reckons Hayes is in 3rd best player at St Kilda in its proud history is a moron.

 

[Snickers]

Any who reckons Hayes is in 3rd best player at St Kilda in its proud history is a moron.

Can you read, or a you retarted.

Look at my first post........
Who has been your top 5 Saint Players over the years?

Mine would be (in no order)
1. Winmar
2. Lockett
3. Hayes
4. Harvey
5. Riewoldt

Thats what i said......... I specifically said "in no order"

And i just judged it on the players i have seen, and the contribution the make to the team.

So get a life, you boring, stupid, pathetic child and crawl back down the toilet you came from you stupid moron.

You are so pathetic Bentleigh, I have never known come across or even spoken to someone who is so pathetic, immature and completley and utterly obsessed with me.

 

[Bentleigh]

Anyone who reckons Hayes is in Saints top 5 ever players is a moron.

 

[Snickers]

Anyone who reckons Hayes is in Saints top 5 ever players is a moron.

Anyone who stalks me around the footy website BIGFOOTY is a moron.

 

[Kildonan]

Trevor Barker
Tony Lockett
Daryl Baldock
Jeff Dunne
Robert Harvey

Bentleigh, I picked Jeff Dunne as one of my top 5 players.

I do not believe that JD is one of the 5 best players to have ever proudly worn the Red, White and Black, but he is in my top 5 because of the amount of pleasure I had watching this bearded marvel rebound the ball from the back pocket again, again and again. The guy had so much heart, he never gave in and he did this despite playing for St Kilda in an era where success was a rare luxury (much as it is now for Richmond).

Any who reckons Hayes is in 3rd best player at St Kilda in its proud history is a moron.

Snickers is entitled to his opinion, as I am to mine. Hayes is a remarkable player, a Captain of our great club in an era of success and one of the most respected footballers playing today.

Get a life. You have no point.

 

[m.diddy]

I think the way he plays, and the way he goes about his footy, I classify that as a excellent.

Top 5 IMO doesnt neccisarilly mean that the Top 5 players have to be the best skilled.

Lenny tackles hard, and does alot of the 1%ers, which sometimes go unnoticed. And thats what i classify as Top 5.

thats probably why i put burkey ahead of winmar

 

[sainter12riewoldt]

it all depnds on age.

From what i've seen it would be
Harvey
Lockett
Riewoldt
Burke
Loewe
(sorry to Winmar)

All time it is
Ian Stewart
Harvey
Baldock
Barker
Lockett

I think it is:
Baldock (just)
Ian Stewart
Barker
Harvey
Riewoldt

 

[mad dog muir]

My top 5 would be as follows
1.Robert Harvey
2.Tony Lockett
3.Stewie Loewe
4.Nicky Winmar
5.Nathan Burke & Nick Riewoldt
I know thats six but i cant split Burkey or Roo

 

[bozza1980]

Top 5 players I have seen play live

1. Harvey
2. Lockett
3. Winmar
4. Riewoldt
5. Loewe

Top 5 All time (from conversations with my dad, videos, anecdotes etc)

1. Baldock
2. Stewart
3. Harvey
4. Barker
5. Lockett

Ofcourse everyone has their own thoughts but thats my two cents

 

[m.diddy]

there is also breen, cowboy neale, ditterich etc