Pretty much no love for forwards in general on that list.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Opinion Top 50 2012
- Thread starter eaglespremiers
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Pretty much no love for forwards in general on that list.
- Thread starter
- #602
I'm sorry. Who am I not considering?
- Thread starter
- #603
A few Crows notes.
Sloane should be ahead of Reilly.
Also how does Walker drop over 10 spots due to not playing on the weekend but Maric stays where he is?
Talia should be getting a look in soon. He was definitely higher than a 7 on the weekend. He pummelled Jeremy Cameron.
Sloane should be ahead of Reilly.
Also how does Walker drop over 10 spots due to not playing on the weekend but Maric stays where he is?
Talia should be getting a look in soon. He was definitely higher than a 7 on the weekend. He pummelled Jeremy Cameron.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Thread starter
- #605
Noted. It was difficult to decide between Reilly vs Sloane.
Put Reilly ahead because of recent form.
Walker dropped, but so should have Maric. I mistakenly left him in the same place.
I will have to go and review Talia's season because his form is out of the blue.
Can you tell me some of the guys he has played on over the course of this season?
- Thread starter
- #606
From Geel v Ess:
9 - Duncan
8 - Johnson, Hawkins
7 - Taylor, Kelly
6 - Watson
5 - Chapman, Howlett
4 - Selwood, Dempsey, Stanton
3 - Hooker
9 - Duncan
8 - Johnson, Hawkins
7 - Taylor, Kelly
6 - Watson
5 - Chapman, Howlett
4 - Selwood, Dempsey, Stanton
3 - Hooker
Sidebottom2Beams
Premiership Player
You are doing a great job and your list has been shaping beautifully keep doing what you are doing it destroys AG's horrible lists each year
That was a huge list of icons, however was never easy to gather data so I really must say that you really are an avid fan.One of my favourite threads was Aussie Gun's top 50 through-out the last couple of years.
As AG has surrendered this task I thought I would attempt to step in and continue it this year.
I found the top 50 discussions quite invigorating and look forward to your input as we travel through 2012.
Feel free to discuss and debate with me and others on this thread. I will take all on board.
The hope is that we will have an accurate top 50 by year's end.
Update: Round 16
- Thread starter
- #609
Although I don't really know what you are saying, I'm going to take this as a compliment.
- Thread starter
- #610
From Coll v Haw:
10 - Swan
9 - Beams, Lewis
8 - Pendlebury, Mitchell, Breust
7 - Sewell, Sidebottom
6 - Roughead, Birchall
5 - Jolly, Shaw
3 - Cloke
10 - Swan
9 - Beams, Lewis
8 - Pendlebury, Mitchell, Breust
7 - Sewell, Sidebottom
6 - Roughead, Birchall
5 - Jolly, Shaw
3 - Cloke
- Thread starter
- #611
From Adel v WCE:
10 - Dangerfield
9 - Vince, Gaff, Talia
8 - Sloane, Reilly
7 - Thompson, Kerr
6 - Naitanui
5 - Cox, Priddis
4 - Selwood, Jacobs
10 - Dangerfield
9 - Vince, Gaff, Talia
8 - Sloane, Reilly
7 - Thompson, Kerr
6 - Naitanui
5 - Cox, Priddis
4 - Selwood, Jacobs
Dwight Schrute
Club Legend
Swan doesn't deserve a 10, he butchered the ball quite a bit in the first half, and the amount of cheap possessions he got was unbelievable. I've seen him have better 30 disposal games.
- Jan 29, 2008
- 2,233
- 1,274
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yeah wouldn't give Swan a 10, he was good but not absolutely outstanding. 9 for him and Beams I'd say. Pendles wasn't that great either for the amount he got it, still a 7-8 though so fair enough.
Dwight Schrute
Club Legend
For me, I'd have
9 - Beams
8 - Swan, Pendles
Beams goes to 10 if the Pies had won.
hawkman
Hall of Famer
It was a hard game to rate, but Beams was easily Collingwood's best. I would give Swan no more than 8. Think Roughead should be a 7 as well
Sidebottom2Beams
Premiership Player
Beams had 34 possessions 4 goals and was much better than Swanny
The Prosecutor
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 13, 2011
- 12,513
- 20,520
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I think you're being overly harsh on Watson.
He still wound up with 29 disposals, 8 clearances and 7 tackles.
- Thread starter
- #619
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Thread starter
- #620
It's not the possession count that hurt it's that in the first half (when it counted most) he was very un-Watson like with his disposal.
Another great game from Betts. Two goals in the last plus an assist to Gibbs turning the game in our favour. 36 goals for the season puts him 8th over all currently, plus equal 1st in the league for goal assists.
Not sure how much more he has to do to be considered top 50, let alone an unlucky. Been one of Carlton's most consistent this season.
Not sure how much more he has to do to be considered top 50, let alone an unlucky. Been one of Carlton's most consistent this season.
- Thread starter
- #622
Will revise Bett's season this week.
- Thread starter
- #623
From GCS v Lions:
10 - Ablett
9 - Redden
8 - Rockliff
7 - Hanley
5 - Bennell
10 - Ablett
9 - Redden
8 - Rockliff
7 - Hanley
5 - Bennell
- Thread starter
- #624
From Melb v PA:
7 - Jones
7 - Jones
- Thread starter
- #625
From Dogs v Carl:
8 - Griffen
7 - Betts, Lake
5 - Boyd
8 - Griffen
7 - Betts, Lake
5 - Boyd
