Top 50- Season 24

Remove this Banner Ad

Lingsface

Premiership Player
May 9, 2005
4,508
2,579
perth
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
geelong
This is my top 50 off the top of my head for 2024- It will come with large criticism but fair enough! Please post yours as well.

1- M Bontompelli
2- C Petracca
3- N Daicos
4- T Greene
5- J Cameron
6- L Neale
7- C Rozee
8- S Taylor
9- Z Butters
10- E Gulden
11- T Stewart
12- C Curnow
13-Z Merrett
14- P Cripps
15- T English
16- N Anderson
17- C Serong
18- S Walsh
19- A Brayshaw (Fre)
20- M Gawn
21- J Dawson
22- J Sicily
23- N Larkey
24- C Oliver
25- S Bolton
26- J Weitering
27- O Allen
28- T Walker
29- C Cameron
30- J Degoey
31- S May
32- D Moore
33- J Daicos
34- J Daniher
35- J Sinclair
36- J Daicos
37- T Liberatore
38- S Bolton
39- J Kelly
40- D Martin
41-R Marshall
42- T Kelly
43- I Heeney
44- C Warner
45- T Hawkins
46- J Dunkley
47- M Rowell
48- M King
49- M Lewis
50- S Coniglio
 
Last edited:
Good to see Jake Kelly get a bit of recognition but not sure he's top 50.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Not bad

take out J Daicos and S Bolton twin entries and T Hawkins, change C Sinclair to J, add any 3 of the following

Taranto, B Crouch, Laird, Green, Viney, Cerra, Parker
 
This is my top 50 off the top of my head for 2024- It will come with large criticism but fair enough! Please post yours as well.

1- M Bontompelli
2- C Petracca
3- N Daicos
4- T Greene
5- J Cameron
6- L Neale
7- C Rozee
8- S Taylor
9- Z Butters
10- E Gulden
11- T Stewart
12- C Curnow
13-Z Merrett
14- P Cripps
15- T English
16- N Anderson
17- C Serong
18- S Walsh
19- A Brayshaw (Fre)
20- M Gawn
21- J Dawson
22- J Sicily
23- N Larkey
24- C Oliver
25- S Bolton
26- J Weitering
27- O Allen
28- T Walker
29- C Cameron
30- J Degoey
31- S May
32- D Moore
33- J Daicos
34- J Daniher
35- J Sinclair
36- J Daicos
37- T Liberatore
38- S Bolton
39- J Kelly
40- D Martin
41-R Marshall
42- T Kelly
43- I Heeney
44- C Warner
45- T Hawkins
46- J Dunkley
47- M Rowell
48- M King
49- M Lewis
50- S Coniglio

Good effort from a Hawthorn players perspective.

Sicily @ 22 is our only "must have" and is about right.
Lewis @ 49 is appropriate and really only dependent on him playing a full season.

No one else from Hawthorn that demands selection, although Jai Newcombe could be considered a little unlucky given he is a young player that is significantly improving each year and just made the AA squad and finished top 20 in the Brownlow and the coaches votes. Still, just outside the 50 is still an appropriate prediction (or maybe he can replace one of the two Shai Boltons? ;)).
 
Good effort from a Hawthorn players perspective.

Sicily @ 22 is our only "must have" and is about right.
Lewis @ 49 is appropriate and really only dependent on him playing a full season.

No one else from Hawthorn that demands selection, although Jai Newcombe could be considered a little unlucky given he is a young player that is significantly improving each year and just made the AA squad and finished top 20 in the Brownlow and the coaches votes. Still, just outside the 50 is still an appropriate prediction (or maybe he can replace one of the two Shai Boltons? ;)).
Thanks he is definitely pushing for a spot!
Lewis is largely based on potential because every time he’s on the field he is as good kpp as I can see anywhere in the competition.
 
I’m expecting to see U Nicorn in everyone’s top 50 by the end of the year.
You have to shoot the lights out as an anchor to get in/ high on peoples top 50.
Maybe it’s exposure
Neale won bnf in 16,18 runner up in 17 lead the league for disposals got donuts
Went to lions got 2 brownlows playing the same game
Serong in 2023 won
Bnf
AA honours
herald sun player of the year
Christian medal
Glen denning medal
22u22
Yet some goose on SEN would pick him up @ 37 for the 2024 season.
Dustin Martin still top 20
It’s not 2017
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Good effort from a Hawthorn players perspective.

Sicily @ 22 is our only "must have" and is about right.
Lewis @ 49 is appropriate and really only dependent on him playing a full season.

No one else from Hawthorn that demands selection, although Jai Newcombe could be considered a little unlucky given he is a young player that is significantly improving each year and just made the AA squad and finished top 20 in the Brownlow and the coaches votes. Still, just outside the 50 is still an appropriate prediction (or maybe he can replace one of the two Shai Boltons? ;)).
WIL DAY????????
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top