Trade or keep our 2 first rd picks?

[feher]

since i have being on this site, i have yet to see a poll on our forum, so why not make one.

basically with our 2 first round picks what would you like us to do?

My vote keep both.

 

[bring on draft]

since i have being on this site, i have yet to see a poll on our forum, so why not make one.

basically with our 2 first round picks what would you like us to do?

My vote keep both.

There is no way Hawthorn would even think about trading either pick as no club would offer anything in the vacinity of what we'd be after! It's too high a risk for both parties!

GO HAWKS!!

 

[feher]

There is no way Hawthorn would even think about trading either pick as no club would offer anything in the vacinity of what we'd be after! It's too high a risk for both parties!

GO HAWKS!!

i hope your right, not convidence myself, especially if they are looking to land judd in a trade, possibly even ball in a trade.

 

[rgauci]

What about Polak. Just a question from a keen dockers supporter. THough i doubt this will happen. Very much doubt. Because Polak would have to agree to the trade. BEcause its his 1st year in a new contract. He would have to approve the trade.

 

[lasher]

we should not trade any draft picks ...none at all...
if we finish bottom we will have the oppurtunity to pick up two of the best young talent in the country + the best uncontraced player...we would be nutcases to give that up...
does anyone know who may be available choices for the pre-season draft...i dont want to hear judd,i'm sick of hearing about judd,yes he's good but he's locked..i think ball will sign with the saints so i dont want to hear his name either...same goes for ottens...so who else is there...?
national draft if we finish bottom we should go with deledio and either roughead or willitts..both of who'm could be our answer at CHF..yes they are young but i think they'll be better than holland or barker put together...
if we finish 15th then forget about deledio and think of roughead,willitts or griffin as a KPP and pick up a midfielder like tambling...with our next higher pick we should be looking at the best available young ruck thats left for the taking...forget about franklin as a pick,i think he has " i wanna go home " written all over him and we'd lose him in a couple of years...we need young blood from vic who we can look at keeping at the club for a number of years...
i know tambling is from the NT but its different with him as there is no team for him to go home to...i think griffin is from SA, ( correct me if i'm wrong ) but we've had some good service from there before, ie jarman and the legendary rat so i think we could hold him longer..WA players have a history of crying to go home and we've had most of them...

i think we should look at trading,
dixon
lekkas
picioane
clarke
cambell
greene
smith ( but only if he wants out )
tallis
cox
ries

holland,barker and mccabe should retire...maybe graham aswell...

we should see a completely new look hawk outfit next year and hopefully a new coach can bring out some more from players who need to lift...

 

[bring on draft]

we should not trade any draft picks ...none at all...
if we finish bottom we will have the oppurtunity to pick up two of the best young talent in the country + the best uncontraced player...we would be nutcases to give that up...
does anyone know who may be available choices for the pre-season draft...i dont want to hear judd,i'm sick of hearing about judd,yes he's good but he's locked..i think ball will sign with the saints so i dont want to hear his name either...same goes for ottens...so who else is there...?
national draft if we finish bottom we should go with deledio and either roughead or willitts..both of who'm could be our answer at CHF..yes they are young but i think they'll be better than holland or barker put together...
if we finish 15th then forget about deledio and think of roughead,willitts or griffin as a KPP and pick up a midfielder like tambling...with our next higher pick we should be looking at the best available young ruck thats left for the taking...forget about franklin as a pick,i think he has " i wanna go home " written all over him and we'd lose him in a couple of years...we need young blood from vic who we can look at keeping at the club for a number of years...
i know tambling is from the NT but its different with him as there is no team for him to go home to...i think griffin is from SA, ( correct me if i'm wrong ) but we've had some good service from there before, ie jarman and the legendary rat so i think we could hold him longer..WA players have a history of crying to go home and we've had most of them...

i think we should look at trading,
dixon
lekkas
picioane
clarke
cambell
greene
smith ( but only if he wants out )
tallis
cox
ries

holland,barker and mccabe should retire...maybe graham aswell...

we should see a completely new look hawk outfit next year and hopefully a new coach can bring out some more from players who need to lift...

Agree totally with everything you just said! Perhaps Jarman was a bad example though!!! Good work mate!!

GO HAWKS!!

 

[Hawk71]

does anyone know who may be available choices for the pre-season draft...i dont want to hear judd,i'm sick of hearing about judd,yes he's good but he's locked..i think ball will sign with the saints so i dont want to hear his name either...same goes for ottens...so who else is there...?

List of uncontracted players appeared in the Herald Sun

Adelaide:- Tyson Stenglein, Matthew Clarke, Mark Stevens
Brisbane:- Blake Caracella, Richard Hadley, Ashley McGrath, Alistair Lynch, Tim Notting, Martin Pike, Clark Keating
Carlton:- Brad Fisher, Cory McGrath, Bret Thornton, Trent Sporn, Ian Pendergrast
Collingwood:- Guy Richards, Ryan Lonie, Paul Licuria, Andrew Williams, Bo Nixon, Luke Shackleton
Essendon:- Adam Ramanauskas, Damian Cupido, Mark mcVeigh, Joe Misiti
Fremantle:- Troy Simmonds, Matthew Carr, Shaun McManus
Geelong:- Ben Graham, Cameron Mooney, David Spriggs, Peter Riccardi, James Rahilly
Hawthorn:- Chance Bateman, Joel Smith, Nathan Lonie, Nick Ries
N Melbourne:- David King, Glen Archer, Anthony Stevens, Hamish McIntosh
Melbourne:- Clint Bizzell, Jared Rivers, Russell Robertson, Cameron Bruce, Scott Thompson
P Adelaide:- Stuart Dew, Josh Carr, Damon White
Richmond:- Chris Newman, Brad Ottens, Kayne Pettifer, Ty Zantuck, Greg Stafford
St.Kilda:- Luke Ball, Heath Black, Brendan Goddard, Robert Harvey, Andrew Thompson
Sydney:- Jude Bolton, Andrew Schauble, Luke Ablett
West Coast:- Andrew McDougall, Dean Cox, Ashley Hansen, Josh Wooden, Damien Adkins
Footscray:- Daniel Bandy, Matthew Robbins, Patrick Bowden, Ben Harrison, Matthew Boyd

I'd be interested in Notting , Bolton , Cupido , Williams , Simmonds , Dew , Thompson , just to name a few possibilities!

 

[Grendel]

List of uncontracted players appeared in the Herald Sun



I'd be interested in Notting Yes , Bolton No, CupidoHmm maybe but ... , Williams No , Simmonds NO, Dew Hmm maybe (kick outs he'd be handy for at least) , Thompson No, just to name a few possibilities!

Probably Notting be my pick of that lot. Bolton I rate but he's a negative mid-fielder and we have enough of them (not in his class though) already. Williams I just don't rate. Couldn't handle trading for yet ANOTHER (Simmons) ruck from somewhere else (One JUST ONE of our own PLEASE GOD ONE!!) the others.. ??

Some decent enough players though that could be around. Another reason that finishing last isn't as bad as it once was.

 

[Rough_Edges]

Trade both

 

[Grendel]

Trade both

Reiwoldt and Magurie.. deal!

 

[Johnson#26]

Keep both. We all saw the way the Saints built a side, maybe the Hawks should do it as well. Anyway, you guys have got plenty of interesting trade bait.