Autopsy v dees

[The King!]

good win, poor timeslot

j mac should have played more in 2020 rather than others who get a go

dees pathetic. but our pressure and team defence won it

 

[Troystenvic]

Getting in early Kingy.

Solid Win. Hope the group continues to develop because we will be pretty ok in 2 or so seasons

 

[Punts]

Young fella should never been dropped

Mccartin is a chb imo

Fox most improved

Clarke deserves credit tonight

Florent not enough again imo

 

[The King!]

ill give credit to Clarke, dont think be belongs in a decent side, but always works hard and his defence tonight was good, plus made some good decisioms, dees pressure was woeful, but you can only beat who you play

mclean was quite good for a late in


florent is letting me down a bit though

i admire that we dont tank even slightly, they always try

 

[caesar88]

Our 2018 draft = Hello

Second half a more accurate idea of where we are. But good that we made things a bit harder for ourselves. First half just a training drill.

Good to see underdogs like McLean, Clarke, Taylor all go well.

 

[swanssince2002]

McInerney is going places with us imo. Some of his kicks were sublime, works hard.

Our 2018 draft crop not looking too bad at the moment. Very promising.

 

[The King!]

maybe we should stick to these rotating home grounds too

 

[melbournehammer]

Young fella should never been dropped

Mccartin is a chb imo

Fox most improved

Clarke deserves credit tonight

Florent not enough again imo

i agree with all except the last line

 

[JustaBattler]

Well done to the BLOODS

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

Sinkers did well vs Maxy

 

[Punts]

Very solid defensively tonight

 

[wills2g]

great work by the boys

if l.taylor gets fit over the preseason, in a few years time we might be talking about another bargain success story

if mcinerney and clarke keep improving, i have doubts about last years draft selection for stephens...

fox going to be next rampe? completely beat his opponent (weideman?)

next week, in: mills and out: aliir

 

[wills2g]

oh yeah, parker and kennedy are still inside bulls..

when our outside players are on, we look blooody good

 

[Chaisa]

Fantastic performance all round, especially in the first half. McInerney's best game yet, we've got a weapon on our hands. Underdogs like Clarke, McLean and Taylor doing well. Taylor especially I strongly questioned why he was getting a callup but looked lively all game. Kennedy and Parker turning back the clock.

Only real negative was a bit too much Hollywood play late in the game, but given the game was effectively iced meh.

 

[RW]

We did it for Sam Reid

 

[Millky95]

Very solid defensively tonight

Without arguably our 2 best backs as well

 

[Donza]

There were quite a few maligned players who played very well...

 

[msb77]

LOL who would support Melbourne! What a joke had everything to play for. Great win, just so impressed with the young guys having a crack. Mcinerney impressive as was the defence.

 

[bedford]

good win, poor timeslot

j mac should have played more in 2020 rather than others who get a go

dees pathetic. but our pressure and team defence won it

Great but strange timeslot , but who cares WE WON

 

[bedford]

maybe we should stick to these rotating home grounds too

Love the SCG , but get back to ANZ

 

[BarneyBent]

Florent moves so incredibly well, it's sublime. It's a real shame he's struggling so much to find it and use it well.

He's still going ok, when he goes by hand he's bringing others in and he gets us out of tricky situations, but he's a C-grader who should, by his attributes, be pushing for A-grader status - even with his kicking.

Clarke was great - he'll never be a great user by foot but he was a decisive, one-touch player who made very good decisions tonight. And he went onto Langdon in the last quarter and curbed his influence as well.

I really like what Wicks brings. Not a star but his physicality is brilliant, and he's good enough to take his chances in front of goal. Just what you want from a defensive forward.

Taylor was very good in the first half, ordinary in the second up until he got his goal. Had a few more good moments after that. Does seem to be a confidence player and I'd like to see him stay in for the rest of the year.

McCartin is our CHB for mine. Rotate him forward for impact if we need it, but keep him back in general.

Melican was mixed. Had some really good moments and was pretty good overall, but also had some real Melican moments. I still can't decide if I think he'll make it.

More broadly our whole defensive unit was very effective. Thurlow looks very much at home rotating between HB and wing. Fox has found his groove as an undersized KPD. Operating well.

 

[caesar88]

There were quite a few maligned players who played very well...

That's because the game for the most part was reserves level pressure. Loved the effort of the team but not gonna take much out of that form-wise.

 

[tombomb]

Media will go into meltdown about Melbourne over the next 48 hours.

Reality is they just aren't very good. B grade midfield, okay backline, absolutely terrible forward line.

 

[Tesla Tenet]

great work by the boys

if l.taylor gets fit over the preseason, in a few years time we might be talking about another bargain success story

if mcinerney and clarke keep improving, i have doubts about last years draft selection for stephens...

fox going to be next rampe? completely beat his opponent (weideman?)

next week, in: mills and out: aliir

What, Stephens got worse without playing?

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[Punts]

Have to agree that florent is c grade level atm and we should be expecting much more from him