Votes Carlton v Brisbane

[Cruiser23]

5. Brendan Fevola
4. Chris Judd
3. Bryce Gibbs
2. Paul Bower
1. Aaron Joseph

 

[zeeCFC]

how good was armfield's run out of defense in the 3rd quater (i think)

5 - fev
4 - judd
3 - joseph
2- gibbs
1 - murph / bower

 

[ESKIE]

5. Judd
4. Fev
3. Murphy
2. AJ
1. Stevo

Special mention to Bower, Army & Thornton who did a super job early on Brown.

We were good tonight this was a seriously good win.

 

[Lance]

5. Judd
4. Fev
3. AJ
2. Bower
1. Armfield

Gibbs and Murphy very good but faded late.

I second this.

 

[Warsaw]

5. Fev
4. Judd
3. Gibbs
2. Bower
1. Simpson

 

[blue gunslinger]

Sorry, but Bower was shocking. Close to our worst

.

Just so very wrong

1 Judd- man such a professional
2 Fev- hopefully has turned it around
3 Bower-linchpin for the defence and played contolled footy
4 Scotland- man he has balls
5 Army/Garlett- Army nothing special but no mistakes and played well
G man stepped up and impressed with effort

 

[paulige]

Please don't put Fev above Judd. We had no backline, Fev should've kicked 12 with the delivery he was getting...

speaking of Delivery, how can you look past Judd? Outstanding against us as usual. Figured he'd take the instant 5 from all of you.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Please don't put Fev above Judd. We had no backline, Fev should've kicked 12 with the delivery he was getting...

speaking of Delivery, how can you look past Judd? Outstanding against us as usual. Figured he'd take the instant 5 from all of you.

which bit of number
1 Judd
did you not get clown?

 

[thylacine60]

Guns: dispensing quality 24/7.

 

[CJudd3Votes]

5. Judd
4. Fev
3. Bower
2. Simpson
1. Joseph

Special mention to Armfield.

 

[TheNumber4]

Great game by the Blues tonight. Very proud of them.

5. Fev - Love him or hate him this bloke is a star and we will never die wondering with him. You get the lot with Fev.
4. Judd - I love this guy so much. Thank god he came to our club and just lifts the rest of the team around him. That final quarter goal he was out on his feet and still willed himself to kick it. A great role model to our young boys.
3. Aaron Joseph - second time this year AJ has touched up Rhan Hooper. This kid sticks to his task like no one else. Great mental attitude and surely should be considered for A RISING STAR AWARD THIS WEEK PLEASE!!!
2. Murphy - Love it when a player takes on board some criticism (kicking) from last year and works his arse off to improve it. You can tell he has done this and I love him for it.
1. Army / Carazzo split - Armys' great dash from the backline was terrific. Great game Army and your best for the navy blues. Carrots it's great to have him back in the team and shut down Johnstone tonight. He straightens and hardens us up and was pivotal in the last quarter tonight.

Well done backline for backing each other up all night

I'm one happy girl

 

[Mentallo]

5.The judd
4.Fev
3.Joseph
2.Bower
1.Murph

So much more fun after a win.

 

[mediumsizered]

5. Fev - The big bloke is back in town.
4. Judd - Voss & Black are right, he is the best in the business.
3. Gibbs - 7 clearances among his 27 disposals.
2. Joseph - claimed yet another scalp. If this kid doesn't get a Rising Star nomination soon, then the whole concept of the award is flawed.
1. Armfield - his run from defence was very important tonight & much improved disposal.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Fev
Murphy
Bower
Gibbs
Armfield.

Sorry Juddy, but i have to say Judd was nearly in that lot.
Judd, Judd and Judd (to make up the Judd thingy).

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

Bower got towelled up early on.

He only started getting the ball when he was switched away from Brennan.

5 C.Judd
4 B.Thornton
3 B.Fevola
2 B.Gibbs
1 S.Browne/D.Armfield

 

[Aphrodite]

5 - Fevola
4 - Judd
3 - Gibbs
2 - Murphy
1 - Joseph

 

[Aphrodite]

Guns: dispensing quality 24/7.

Do I need a script for that T

 

[Hayashi_62]

5. Fev
4. Judd
3. Gibbs - best game I've seen from him in a few weeks but he still wasn't amazing yet.
2. Murph
1. Browne - best game so far I think. He was tough and disposal wasn't bad.

AJ was very unlucky, can't overlook the four stars though, and I was really impressed by brown so had to sneak him in there.

 

[Sublime]

which bit of number
1 Judd
did you not get clown?

Well in fairness also Guns, you did vote backwards compared to everyone else in here 5 for best and so on...

 

[buckleyssoft]

Please don't put Fev above Judd. We had no backline, Fev should've kicked 12 with the delivery he was getting...

speaking of Delivery, how can you look past Judd? Outstanding against us as usual. Figured he'd take the instant 5 from all of you.

Good point.
Rubbish backline and midfield.
Hard to split them. Both of them had a pretty easy day at the office.

 

[gandaal]

5. Fev- He was fantastic and anyone who doesn't give him five places too much expectation on the guy.
4. Judd- He was sublime when we needed him most. If it wasn't obvious before he's back to his brilliant best.
3. Murph- His kicking was just exceptional
2. Joseph- Tagged Hooper out of the game and got the ball himself
1. Browne- Best game I've seen him play by a mile. Great disposal under pressure.

 

[TheNumber4]

I'd also give a vote to Brett Ratten last night. Credit where credit is due people. Against Adelaide he got the game plan and match ups horribly wrong and copped flack for it (and rightly so) but the majoirty of match ups against the lions were fantastic.

You can't expect champs like Brown, Black and Power not to get the ball but his match ups on some of the lions younger key runners who have been very good lately like Sherman, Rich and Hooper were terrific. These blokes were cut out of the game for the majority of it.

Well done Ratts and coaching panel.

 

[djudd]

I'd also give a vote to Brett Ratten last night. Credit where credit is due people. Against Adelaide he got the game plan and match ups horribly wrong and copped flack for it (and rightly so) but the majoirty of match ups against the lions were fantastic.

You can't expect champs like Brown, Black and Power not to get the ball but his match ups on some of the lions younger key runners who have been very good lately like Sherman, Rich and Hooper were terrific. These blokes were cut out of the game for the majority of it.

Well done Ratts and coaching panel.

Yes i got stuck into ratts a few times and i agree with you he coached well tonight except when fev came off for 5 min when we were 4 goals up.
Well done ratts

 

[Abaddon]

5. B Fevola
4. C Judd
3. M Murphy
2. A Joseph
1. B Gibbs

 

[Mister Carlton]

Please don't put Fev above Judd. We had no backline, Fev should've kicked 12 with the delivery he was getting...

speaking of Delivery, how can you look past Judd? Outstanding against us as usual. Figured he'd take the instant 5 from all of you.

You had no forward-line either....Brown kicking was shocking....and it was even worse when it was on home turf. 4.5 and 2 outer bounds.