VOTES rd 9

[NSWCROW]

POTY

5 - MATTNER ( Best game for the club )
4 - SHIRLEY ( See above )
3 - GOODY ( Like a fine wine )
2 - THOMMO
1 - KNIGHTS ( Worst kick in the AFL , but isn't he a magnet )


TTM

3 - SHIRLEY
2 - HUDDO
1 - TORNS

ROTY

2 - NEEDLES

 

[jasrocks]

poty:

5. Mattner (best game for Adelaide, commentators wanted him reported for kicking someone's shin )
4. Shirley (another great game, close to being his best)
3. Thompson (worked hard all day)
2. Goodwin
1. Knights

btm:

3. Hudson (rucked most of the game by himself)
2. Shirley
1. Mattner

roty:

Knights, Porps and Jericho were great, not sure who qualifies though

 

[bus24]

1 - KNIGHTS ( Worst kick in the AFL , but isn't he a magnet )

Very harsh. His disposal has been very good for most of the season so far.

 

[NSWCROW]

Very harsh. His disposal has been very good for most of the season so far.

Okay

 

[AdelUniCrowFan]

Both Porplyzia and Jericho are 22. I doubt they qualify for ROTY.

 

[bus24]

Okay

It has, disagree if you want to. But after the first couple of rounds, his disposal was 80-90 % efficiancy for the most part.

 

[ShearMagic9]

5 - Goodwin
4 - Mattner
3 - Thompson
2 - Knights
1 - Welsh

BTM:

3 - Shirley
2 - Hudson
1 - Mattner

ROTY:

I guess Knights is the only eligible?

 

[bus24]

5 - Thompson
4 - Reilly
3 - Goodwin
2 - Mattner
1 - Shirley

BTM

3 - Shirley
2 - Hudson
1 - Rutten

ROTY

2- Knights

 

[Alex99]

Best player’s vs. Carlton

5) Simon Goodwin
4) Marty Mattner
3) Scott Thompson
2) Brent Reilly
1) Luke Jericho

Best Team Man

3) Ben Hudson
2) Marty Mattner
1) Robert Shirley

Rookie of the year

Chris Knights

 

[turbo182]

POTY

5 - Marty Mattner
4 - Simon Goodwin
3 - Luke Jericho
2 - Scotty Welsh
1 - Chris Knights

BTM

3 - Ben Hudson
2 - Scotty Thompson
1 - Robert Shirley

ROTY

2 - Knight Rider

 

[macca23]

POTY

5. Thompson - Comfortably our best player today IMO. Hard at it all day in and around the packs and used the ball well to give us a lot of drive.

4. Shirley - Loved his game today. Just worked his arse off non-stop in the packs and tackled fiercely. Used the ball well even when under pressure.

3. Reilly - great comeback after injury, and ran the lines beautifully to open up scoring opportunities.

2. Goodwin - struggled with the Walker tag early, but wore him down in the end and played a big hand in our last quarter effort.

1. Knights - churning the good games out now like a sausage machine. Absolute ball magnet. Used it well again today.

Best Team Man

3. Mattner - just missed the best players today IMO. Got a lot of it bit was loose in defence at times. 100% for effort though.

2. Hudson Lion hearted effort by the big fella. Caned early but came back well after Griffin went down. Will be a tired boy tonight.

1. Shirley - see above

Rookie

2. Knights - a star in the making.

 

[Eggzoi]

POTY

5. Thompson - Comfortably our best player today IMO. Hard at it all day in and around the packs and used the ball well to give us a lot of drive.

4. Shirley - Loved his game today. Just worked his arse off non-stop in the packs and tackled fiercely. Used the ball well even when under pressure.

3. Reilly - great comeback after injury, and ran the lines beautifully to open up scoring opportunities.

2. Goodwin - struggled with the Walker tag early, but wore him down in the end and played a big hand in our last quarter effort.

1. Knights - churning the good games out now like a sausage machine. Absolute ball magnet. Used it well again today.

Best Team Man

3. Mattner - just missed the best players today IMO. Got a lot of it bit was loose in defence at times. 100% for effort though.

2. Hudson Lion hearted effort by the big fella. Caned early but came back well after Griffin went down. Will be a tired boy tonight.

1. Shirley - see above

Rookie

2. Knights - a star in the making.

I'm going to go with that, sounds perfect. Was super impressed with Shirley today. Really killed em. Reilly coming back from injury looked brilliant.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What no mention of Perries sacrificial game

 

[McLeodMagic]

POTY:

5 - Thompson
4 - Mattner
3 - Reilly
2 - Goodwin
1 - Jericho

BTM:

3 - Shirley
2 - Hudson
1 - Mattner

ROTY:

2 - Knights

 

[AAMI]

POTY

5. Thompson - Comfortably our best player today IMO. Hard at it all day in and around the packs and used the ball well to give us a lot of drive.

4. Shirley - Loved his game today. Just worked his arse off non-stop in the packs and tackled fiercely. Used the ball well even when under pressure.

3. Reilly - great comeback after injury, and ran the lines beautifully to open up scoring opportunities.

2. Goodwin - struggled with the Walker tag early, but wore him down in the end and played a big hand in our last quarter effort.

1. Knights - churning the good games out now like a sausage machine. Absolute ball magnet. Used it well again today.

Best Team Man

3. Mattner - just missed the best players today IMO. Got a lot of it bit was loose in defence at times. 100% for effort though.

2. Hudson Lion hearted effort by the big fella. Caned early but came back well after Griffin went down. Will be a tired boy tonight.

1. Shirley - see above

Rookie

2. Knights - a star in the making.

Macca23, not that he had to be in the top 5 today (even though some would say he deserved it) but what would it take for you to put Jericho in there?

 

[Stiffy_18]

Macca23, not that he had to be in the top 5 today (even though some would say he deserved it) but what would it take for you to put Jericho in there?

A miracle?!

To be fair, Jericho was a burst player as was Welsh and the player he has in his votes have been consistent performers today from quarter to quarter.

 

[macca23]

Macca23, not that he had to be in the top 5 today (even though some would say he deserved it) but what would it take for you to put Jericho in there?

A game worthy of being in the top 5.

 

[- PC -]

POTY

5. Thompson
4. Shirley
3. Goodwin
2. Knights
1. Mattner

 

[tribey]

23 touches (10 contested), 6 tackles and a goal. Anyone who doesn't have Roberto Shirlos in their top 5 POTY is kidding themselves.

POTY

5. THOMPSON, Scottsbert - Inside, outside, everywhere.
4. SHIRLEY, Robertang - Blood and guts, plays old skool football in a post-modern era.
3. GOODWIN, Simondale - Real drive through the middle all day.
2. MATTNER, Martington - Electric performance down back and through the lines. Was refreshing to see him not get caught for once.
1. REILLY, Brentmond - Solid return, will obviously improve further.

BTM

3. SHIRLEY - See above.
2. HUDSON, Bennigal - In the absence of Griff toiled all day.
1. BASSETT, Nathanister - For better or worse, was fearless in defence, throwing himself at contest after contest.

Rookie

1. KNIGHTS, Christopographer - Just give him the award now.

 

[Drummond]

POTY:

5. Thompson- Brilliant in close. Take this guy out of the midfield and we would be in strife.
4. Shirley- Best game I’ve ever seen him play.
3. Goodwin- Huge second half, great in the packs.
2. Mattner- Took some terrific marks deep in defence.
1. Reilly- Welcome back. 2 goals, superb foot skills and hard running.

BTM:

3. Hudson
2. Shirley
1. Thompson

ROTY:

2. Knights

 

[jenny61_99]

POTY:

5 Thommo
4 Porplyzia
3 Reilly
2 Jericho
1 Shirley

BTM:

3 Perrie
2 Huddo
1 Shirley

ROTY:

Knights (if he's eligible)

 

[Damp Squarie]

POTY:

5 Goodwin
4 Thompson
3 Porplyzia
2 Jericho
1 Reilly


BTM:

3 Shirley
2 Doughty
1 Welsh

ROTY:

Knights

That was sooo hard to pick!!

 

[Markthirtytwo]

POTY:

5 Thompson
4 Reilly
3 Goodwin
2 Shirley
1 Mattner

BTM:

3 Shirley
2 Hudson
1 van Berlo

ROTY:

Knights

PS Would have loved to have included the Pez in there but didn't inforce my own 24 hour rule to think clearly about it.

 

[Stiffy_18]

5. THOMPSON, Scottsbert - Inside, outside, everywhere.

That just sound wrong on so many levels

 

[ams4crows]

POTY:

5. Thompson
4. Shirley
3. Goodwin
2. Mattner
1. Reilly

BTM:

3. Hudson
2. Shirley
1. Porplyzia

ROTY:

2. Knights