Votes vs Eagles

[Darealrath]

3. Hille - nearly always plays his best games against the best ruckman
2. Lloyd - Champion. Infuriates me how people have written him off.
1. McPhee - Another very good game.

 

[rines]

3. Hille (showed exactly what he can do, its when he learns to do this everyweek that he will become top 3 ruckman in the league)

2. lloyd (still waiting for some apologies from some on this board.. was awesome, finally had some support from lucas, neagle and the resting ruckman)

1. Reimers (a little bit of an aggressive nut.. i love it)

unlucky:
welsh (best game i've seen this year from him)
longerGUN (another in and under player to support jobe)
fletcher (... )

 

[Mervyn Beasley]

I know it's against an opponent far from their best, but stuff it - here goes
3) Hille - fantastic game all round - congratulations mate
2.999) Lloyd - has hopefully shut a lot of mouths, including on this board
2.998) Fletcher - superb efforts and second efforts all match
2.997) McPhee - was there anywhere on the ground he wasn't?
2.996) McVeigh - so effective getting it inside 50

2) Lucas- Back in full flight. Great to see
1.999) Reimers - those stupid boots always seemed to be in the play
1.998) Stanton - very impressive midfield engine tonight
1.997) Neagle - lots to get excited about with the young fella
1.996) Monfries - closest he's come to a complete game for some time

1) Rama - Really is a confidence player, lifts when we're going well
0.999) Lovett-Murray - pressure non-stop in defense
0.998) Welsh - good, thinking footy with his disposals
0.997) Ryder - plenty of good spoils

Hell, we've waited three months for an effort like that

McPhee. Was there anywhere on the ground where he didnt make a critical error??
13 Clangers. The guy has a big engine and is strong and athletic but he is not a very good footballer. Trade him while you can as he costs too much money that does not correlate with output.

 

[Spikey]

McPhee. Was there anywhere on the ground where he didnt make a critical error??
13 Clangers. The guy has a big engine and is strong and athletic but he is not a very good footballer. Trade him while you can as he costs too much money that does not correlate with output.

Psst. I think this guy doesn't like McPhee.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

McPhee. Was there anywhere on the ground where he didnt make a critical error??
13 Clangers. The guy has a big engine and is strong and athletic but he is not a very good footballer. Trade him while you can as he costs too much money that does not correlate with output.

How about looking in your own backyard.

Franklin, McGlyn and Lewis lead the comp in clangers and errors.

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/player_rankings?yr=2008&sp=SE&rt=LA&fc=E10

 

[Rack Watts]

Well done Kelvin! HAHA!

 

[Phat Toni]

3 - Hille
2 - Lloyd - What a Mark!
1 - Reimers - Great at ground level.

Is Reimers the second coming of Akar?

I know, I know very early to make a call comparing him to a Brownlow medalist but looks like a bit of a larrikin and plays a little like him.

 

[Mervyn Beasley]

How about looking in your own backyard.

Franklin, McGlyn and Lewis lead the comp in clangers and errors.

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/player_rankings?yr=2008&sp=SE&rt=LA&fc=E10

They can afford to!

 

[daffo]

3 - Hille * his best game i have seen
2 - Longergun * simply because he is a gun
1 - Lloyd * showed great leadership, shame it took a couple of weeks in the back paper to make him show it on field.