Votes vs. Pies

[kretchy]

3 - Bowden
2 - Johnson
1 - Zantuck

 

[SaveFeriss]

3-Bowden
2-Johnson
1-Krakour

 

[Wrenny]

3. Bowden
2. Johnson
1. Rodan

Mention to newman, hartigan, hall, campbell, krakouer

 

[sante]

3 - Johnson
2 - Bowden
1 - Rodan

UNLUCKY

Richo
Krakouer
Zantuck
Hall
Campbell
Hyde

 

[sante]

i also thought Gaspar was reasonable at Full Back

 

[rfctigerarmy]

3: Bowden
2: Johnson
1: Rodan

Krakouer has all the skills.. just gets it in doses which is a real shame.

 

[froars]

3 - Bowden
2 - Johnson
1 - Campbell

 

[CJH]

3. Bowden
2. Johnson
1. Zantuck

 

[Fishfinger]

3 - Bowden
2 - Johnson
1 - Zantuck

 

[Darth_Tiger]

3. Bowden
2. Johnson
1. Rodan

 

[Tigers_07]

My Votes Go To...........

3) Kane Johnson
2) Joel Bowden
1) Andy Krakeour

Mentions To:

David Rodan
Ty Zantuck
Ray Hall
Brent Hartigan
Wayne Campbell

 

[Cuneyt]

1. Billy Bowden
2. Rodan ( 2 good games in a row )
3. Johnson...again and again

 

[peejay]

3 Bowden
2 roden
1 richo

 

[GhostofJimJess]

3 Bowden
2 Johnno
1 Krak

 

[Richmondfan#1]

Along with many others:
3. Bowden
2. Johnson
1. Zantuck

First game in ages I've been able to see the whole thing. Damn it was close.

 

[mellowyellow]

3. Bowden... Clearly the standout
2. Johnson
1. Rodan

 

[mighty tiges]

Same as MY

3. Bowden
2. Johnson
1. Rodan

 

[Showbag]

3. Bowden
2. Rodan
1. Johnson

Congratulations to Zantuck, Chaffey and Krak for giving their all.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

3-Johnson
2-Bowden
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v

1-Zantuck.


cheers!

 

[Crumden]

3 Bowden
2 Johnson
1 Campbell

 

[kretchy]

Final Votes vs. Collingwood
5 - Joel Bowden - 54
4 - Kane Johnson - 37
3 - David Rodan - 12
2 - Ty Zantuck - 5
1 - Andrew Krakouer - 3
Wayne Campbell - 2
Matthew Richardson - 1

Joel Bowden is the new leader by 1 vote after his best on ground performance against the pies.

Leaderboard
Joel Bowden - 44
Nathan Brown - 43
Kane Johnson - 36.5
Matthew Richardson - 32
Andrew Krakouer - 19.5
Wayne Campbell - 17.5
Greg Tivendale - 11.5
Brad Ottens - 10
Kayne Pettifer - 9
David Rodan - 8
Tim Fleming - 7
Jay Schulz - 6
Chris Hyde - 5
Ty Zantuck - 4
Ray Hall - 3
Andrew Kellaway - 3
Tom Roach - 2
Brent Hartigan - 2
Mark Chaffey - 2
Chris Newman - 2
Daniel Jackson - 1
Aaron Fiora - 0.5
Greg Stafford - 0.5

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Whilst I reckon on the whole, that the above leaderboard is a pretty fair reflection of who's done what so far this season, there is one glaring "error" in our voting. Maybe it's probably more due to the voting system itself than any oversight on behalf of us the voters, but it always seems to happen in the Brownlow too, which is far more flawed.

Chris Newman - 2 votes

That's less than Mark Chaffey, Brent Hartigan, Tom Roach, Andrew Kellaway, Ty Zantuck, Chris Hyde, Jay Schulz, Tim Fleming, David Rodan, Kayne Pettifer and almost SIX TIMES less than Greg Tivendale, all of whom, I think, Have had FAR inferior seasons than Chris.

He has also had nearly NINE TIMES less votes than Wayne Campbell.

Now, Chris Newman is certainly no champion. He probably shouldn't be in our top 5 or 6 players this season, and would have struggled to be considered our B.O.G. in any individual game. But he has been, however, as honest as the day is long, super consistent, super persistent, has done some really good jobs on some excellent opposition, and has a "Clanger" rate far less than, and a "Contested Possession" rate far better than a vast proprtion of those above him in the voting.

Equal 17th simply doesn't do him justice in my opinion. He'd be one of the few Tiger players that can finish in 4 weeks fairly satisfied with his individual performance in 2004.

 

[CJH]

Newman is probably overlooked because of the type of role he is required to play for the team - always the tagger and rarely allowed the freedom to attack in his own right.

Oddly enough, last year when he was playing as a small defender, he was given more opportunity to run and attack.

Maybe next year will see him with a chance to play a more influential role?