We're going to play a game...

[GoTheSwannies]

Want to see if you guys can figure out the players behind the silhouettes. I'm particularly interested which swans players are on the list.

Goodesie was an easy pick, pretty surprised with how high he was.

I think I spotted Buddy & Kennedy.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/features/players-top-50

over to you guys...

 

[RUNVS]

Global thermonuclear war?

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Global thermonuclear war?

que?

 

[replicant]

Global thermonuclear war?

Tic Tac Toe

 

[GoTheSwannies]

noone? lol

guess it was just me

 

[vonn]

Buddy looks a bit like 7 or 6. Or Roughead.

 

[grimlock]

Want to see if you guys can figure out the players behind the silhouettes. I'm particularly interested which swans players are on the list.

Goodesie was an easy pick, pretty surprised with how high he was.

I think I spotted Buddy & Kennedy.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/features/players-top-50

over to you guys...

Number 8 really looks like Goodes, but I can't believe he'd be that high!

 

[Superstar swan]

Goodes has to be 8..surprised he would be that high though.

7 lools like buddy but i would have thought the players would have had him higher

 

[Superstar swan]

6 looks like mglynn celebrating a goal but no way would he be there

 

[grimlock]

Non Swans

13 is Hawkins lock it in Eddie
14 looks like Jaeger O'Meara but surely not this early?
17 Gunston?
19 could have been Tippett but don't think his back hair is that long.

Edit: Crap Hawkins is 23 already.

 

[SBD Gonzalez]

11 is that guy with a beard.

 

[Superstar swan]

Non Swans

13 is Hawkins lock it in Eddie
14 looks like Jaeger O'Meara but surely not this early?
17 Gunston?
19 could have been Tippett but don't think his back hair is that long.

Edit: Crap Hawkins is 23 already.

14 is cotchin

 

[Dan87]

Really tough. Harder than when I remember doing it last year. Here's a crack.

20 J Cameron
19 K Jack
18 J Gibson
17 Nicky Dal
16 S Motlop?
15 S Johnson
14. Cotchin
13. Watson ? who the hell is 13...
12. Liberatore
11. K Simpson
10 Roughead ?
9 T Boak
8 Goodes
7 S Mitchell
6 Franklin
5 Dangerfield
4 Looks like B Lake ?? Must be Pendles...maybe Hodge
3 Selwood
2 Fyfe
1 Ablett

Couldn't find Kennedy or Luke Hodge

 

[dangle]

The silhouettes obviously don't match the players that will actually be revealed at that number.

For example the silhouette at no. 10 is clearly McVeigh but he has already been revealed at 35.

 

[Dan87]

Right on. Wasted part of my morning for nothing.

Last year had the actual silhouettes.

Disappointing.

 

[RUNVS]

Tic Tac Toe

How about a nice game of chess?

 

[grimlock]

It's not the same pic. In the silhouette you can see the person's right ear but in McVeigh's pic you can't.

Also look at the ripple patterns that outline the Guernsey. Not the same.

 

[grimlock]

Although it would explain why 13 looks like Hawkins, 8 Goodes and 11 Wingard even though they've either been selected or unlikely to be selected that high

 

[alanlau34]

4 looks like Lake, which is cray cray.

13 is Ramp's - look at dat hair and guns...

 

[RainMachine]

Kennedy at 11, couple spots early imo. So Kieren Jack.... Top 10 or hasn't made the list?

 

[grimlock]

I have 11 names that I think wouldn't be out of place in the Top 10. But obviously someone has to miss out and it'd probably be Gray because last year was the first elite season he's had

• Gary Ablett
• Joel Selwood
• Patrick Dangerfield
• Scott Pendlebury
• Nathan Fyfe
• Lance Franklin
• Jarryd Roughead
• Luke Hodge
• Travis Boak
• Kieren Jack
• Robbie Gray

 

[swansfan51]

I have 11 names that I think wouldn't be out of place in the Top 10. But obviously someone has to miss out and it'd probably be Gray because last year was the first elite season he's had

• Gary Ablett
• Joel Selwood
• Patrick Dangerfield
• Scott Pendlebury
• Nathan Fyfe
• Lance Franklin
• Jarryd Roughead
• Luke Hodge
• Travis Boak
• Kieren Jack
• Robbie Gray

Jack will miss out of those names. There's no way players would have him above Kennedy

 

[dangle]

It's not the same pic. In the silhouette you can see the person's right ear but in McVeigh's pic you can't.

Also look at the ripple patterns that outline the Guernsey. Not the same.

Same person, same moment....different photo from a slightly different angle. If you think that is anyone other than McVeigh in 2012 grand final...you're wrong.