We're watching you Mcpharlin

[Bojangles17]

Silvagni mark II this bloke, last year he held and tunneled Jack at every opportunity. Remember that clip replayed adnauseum where jack looked like he was thrown down the stars by a bouncer. What was lost , was clear case of tunneling by a past master. If the umpires that regularly read our forum could take note, it would be greatly appreciated.

 

[Dusty Cotch]

Silvagni mark II this bloke, last year he held and tunneled Jack at every opportunity. Remember that clip replayed adnauseum where jack looked like he was thrown down the stars by a bouncer. What was lost , was clear case of tunneling by a past master. If the umpires that regularly read our forum could take note, it would be greatly appreciated.

Jack wasn't the same after that tunnelling incident last year.Jack didnt even get a free kick for that!

 

[Bojangles17]

Jack wasn't the same after that tunnelling incident last year.Jack didnt even get a free kick for that!

i know, I still havent forgotten it

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

McPharlin is a dirty prick, very good at disguising cheap whacks on opponents during play to make it look like an accident, such as knees into the body while his opponents takes a mark on the ground.

 

[DerpWerls]

Am I the only one that thinks Luke McPharlin is a good honest player?

 

[Freomaniac]

McPharlin is a dirty prick, very good at disguising cheap whacks on opponents during play to make it look like an accident, such as knees into the body while his opponents takes a mark on the ground.

I disagree with McPharlin being a dog Player.

If you want Dirty players at Freo in the Past, Think of Jeff Farmer and Both Josh and Matt Carr. The only Dirty player on Freos list is Ballantyne.

 

[Heisenberg_]

I disagree with McPharlin being a dog Player.

If you want Dirty players at Freo in the Past, Think of Jeff Farmer and Both Josh and Matt Carr. The only Dirty player on Freos list is Ballantyne.

Stevie Morris will sort him out anyway, you can probably add Crowley to that list but hopefully his reprimand will have worked better on him then it has Jetta.

 

[_Wang_]

Am I the only one that thinks Luke McPharlin is a good honest player?

I dont mind him either..

 

[Freomaniac]

Stevie Morris will sort him out anyway, you can probably add Crowley to that list but hopefully his reprimand will have worked better on him then it has Jetta.

I got to Admit Crowley was stupid to try and stage a free kick after that shove. Morris Seemeds like a good player from last weeks performance.

Im Still suprised that some People think that McPharlin is a dirty player. I will watch this game to see what some of you guys are talking about.

As I said Jeff Farmer and the Carr boys were proven Dirty Players. Farmer got suspended for 7 weeks for eye gouging. Josh and Matt Carr are known for ganging up on players. I remember a few years back in 2006-7 Both Carr boys ganged up on Dainel Kerr in the Western Derby.

 

[Heisenberg_]

I'm surprised as well I wouldn't consider him as dirty either TBH

 

[PykeDream]

Don't think he's a 'dirty player' at all, but rather one of the better defenders in the league. Gave Tippett a bath last weekend. Crowley, Ballantyne and Clarke are the ones to watch.

 

[Freomaniac]

Don't think he's a 'dirty player' at all, but rather one of the better defenders in the league. Gave Tippett a bath last weekend. Crowley, Ballantyne and Clarke are the ones to watch.

My thoughts exactly. Defenders cant be dirty players unless they want to give their oppositions forwards a shot at goal 30-40 metres directly in front.

 

[JS#35]

Am I the only one that thinks Luke McPharlin is a good honest player?

He's a gun defender.

 

[Spluff]

He's a scragger, but most good defenders are.

 

[The Cotchin Supremacy]

I like Mcpharlaine but the real battle will be whether Cotch can break the crowley tag. Smashed Jones last week...

 

[Ancient Tiger]

The dirtiest player on their team is McPhee. He is an absolute thug. Dislocated one of Ben Griffiths shoulders 2 years ago intentionally and is always driving his knee or elbow into someone when they are on the ground!

A real dirty player!

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

The dirtiest player on their team is McPhee. He is an absolute thug. Dislocated one of Ben Griffiths shoulders 2 years ago intentionally and is always driving his knee or elbow into someone when they are on the ground!

A real dirty player!

Yup, I'd be watching McPhee & Balantyne.

McPharlin a dirty player? Really??

 

[Bojangles17]

i didnt go with dirty, moreso a scragger that gets away with way too much, tunnelling aint in the rules...umpires need to ajudicate accordingly, thats all I ask

 

[tugga]

Hardly McPharlin's fault if the umpires don't do anything about it.

 

[Bojangles17]

Hardly McPharlin's fault if the umpires don't do anything about it.

The theme of my post tugg was for the umps to adjudicate fairly, that is all

 

[Richo is God]

I like Mcpharlaine but the real battle will be whether Cotch can break the crowley tag. Smashed Jones last week...

Like we have been doing in the past, we will just plonk him at FF. Crowley will not be comfortable playing at FB (like all taggers)

 

[Richo is God]

Yup, I'd be watching McPhee & Balantyne.

McPharlin a dirty player? Really??

McPhee is shockingly dirty. Morris will be all over Ballantyne, expect him to take multiple dives during the game.

 

[Put a Lids on it]

Must be close to retirement seems to have been around for awhile.

 

[Kyusss]

The dirtiest player on their team is McPhee. He is an absolute thug. Dislocated one of Ben Griffiths shoulders 2 years ago intentionally and is always driving his knee or elbow into someone when they are on the ground!

A real dirty player!

In Fairness to old Skeletor Mcphee i dont think you could blame anyone for disclocating Ben Griffiths shoulders in the state they were in

 

[Ancient Tiger]

In Fairness to old Skeletor Mcphee i dont think you could blame anyone for disclocating Ben Griffiths shoulders in the state they were in

Saw private footage of the incident. Wasn't pretty at all.