Werewolf Werewolf - Dr. Wolf

[Broken]

Because the vampires can convert. And for all we know at the moment the 2 vampires are a seer and a juggilante.

By giving them everyone's role, we hand them the victory. What don't you understand about this? It's not rocket science.

Exactly. We outnumber evil by a large number. Revealing roles now can only hurt and give evil a clearer path to the end. There is a time and place to reveal if it means we win out over evil. Now is not the time.

 

[timtamWB]

Now here comes the question: why is LA so incessant about finding out every single persons role?

 

[akkaps]

I'll make some major changes to the Vamp role for next game. In the discussion thread please list what you'd like to see as part of the vamp role and I'll do my best to incorporate it in.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Because the vampires can convert. And for all we know at the moment the 2 vampires are a seer and a juggilante.

By giving them everyone's role, we hand them the victory. What don't you understand about this? It's not rocket science.

We have 3 players with unidentified roles.

At minimum, 2 of these are evil.

If the last good comes out and is undisputed, there we go, 2 confirmed evil who will both be dead by Day 5.

We have 2 juggilantes and 2 seers.

Absolute minimum 2 of these are still good by tomorrow morning.

Likelihood with the given information is that either the Godfather or 1 vampire will be dead by tomorrow morning.

If we all come out now, that will leave 1, MAYBE 2 evil by tomorrow night

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Now here comes the question: why is LA so incessant about finding out every single persons role?

Has worked in the past will likely work again

 

[timtamWB]

We have 3 players with unidentified roles.

At minimum, 2 of these are evil.

If the last good comes out and is undisputed, there we go, 2 confirmed evil who will both be dead by Day 5.

We have 2 juggilantes and 2 seers.

Absolute minimum 2 of these are still good by tomorrow morning.

Likelihood with the given information is that either the Godfather or 1 vampire will be dead by tomorrow morning.

If we all come out now, that will leave 1, MAYBE 2 evil by tomorrow night

And if we all come out, then the vamps know exactly who to convert and how to kill. They'll end up with the guardian, a juggilante, and a seer.

Vampires are the huge threat right now.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

And if we all come out, then the vamps know exactly who to convert and how to kill. They'll end up with the guardian, a juggilante, and a seer.

Vampires are the huge threat right now.

And we'll know exactly who to vote out

 

[pantskyle]

I have no idea whether he is or isn't. The only person I believe so far is pantskyle, because his Seerings were all shown to be true. He outed himself for whatever reason as one of evil's main targets, and I wouldn't expect him to survive the night because the Guardian cannot protect him twice in a row.
You might like to know my role. It will become clear over the next few days, I guess, but for now, I shall inform you that I am on the side of good.

If evil are smart they know who the two juggs are now and that only one will be protected.

I'd be a stupid target for them.

 

[Brown Bottle]

If evil are smart they know who the two juggs are now and that only one will be protected.

I'd be a stupid target for them.

They probably think that they know

 

[Millky95]

... someone dead yet?

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

... someone dead yet?

akkaps maybe?

I wonder if his doctors appointment was a life/death situation

 

[Footypie32]

****, just realised Footypie32 was a lover

How much leg do I need to show!!!

 

[Ant Bear]

Carn..

 

[akkaps]

Sorry for the delay, came back from the doctors abit late, then had to do some other stuff around BigFooty before some compulsory family time with my mum. :|

Due to the time, I'll just post the tl;dr version

Brown Bottle (Juggilante / Wise Guy Sampire) - killed by hit men
timtamWB (Chief Guardian) - killed by juggilante
LicoriceAllsorts (KillerBeez) - killed by juggilante
Broken (Wise Guy Sampire) - killed by KillerBeez

 

[timtamWB]

Damn you brown bottle. I know it was you. It's always you.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

juggs

 

[Freight Train]

So what evil roles are left that we know of now, guys? Surely there's not many left...

 

[Golumless]

Just mafia it seems unless vampires converted one.

 

[Wosh]

Killed
Frankston Rover - villager
fitzroybulldog - villager
beez - villager
The Filth Wizard - villager
brahj - villager

Noobz0r - Alpha wereboncer
Close Contest - wereboncer
RU_ - wereboncer

Mooch - hitmen
Footypie32 - hitmen/WGS/lover
Marlowe - WGS
Broken - WGS
Brown Bottle - Juggilante/WGS

Wacky Tiger - The Filth Witch/lover
timtamWB - Chief Guardian
Licorice Allsorts - killerBeez

Remaining players
BigJoeD - claims to be killerbeez
tigland
Wooshette - claims to be villager
The_Reaper - claims to be Jobe
pantskyle - claims to be Mobbenseer
SM - claims to be flog
Hatchy1992 - claims to be villager
matty6
Golumless - claims to be flog
Ant Bear
Millky95
TheFreightTrain - claims to be Juggilante

Remaining Roles
Villager x 2
Godfather
Juggilante
Mobbenseer x 2
WGS - can still recruit?
Jobe
Flogs x 3
Killerbeez x 1

Can we flush out a liar or 2 for voting today?

 

[pantskyle]

Killed
Frankston Rover - villager
fitzroybulldog - villager
beez - villager
The Filth Wizard - villager
brahj - villager

Noobz0r - Alpha wereboncer
Close Contest - wereboncer
RU_ - wereboncer

Mooch - hitmen
Footypie32 - hitmen/WGS/lover
Marlowe - WGS
Broken - WGS
Brown Bottle - Juggilante/WGS

Wacky Tiger - The Filth Witch/lover
timtamWB - Chief Guardian
Licorice Allsorts - killerBeez

Remaining players
BigJoeD - claims to be killerbeez
tigland
Wooshette - claims to be villager
The_Reaper - claims to be Jobe
pantskyle - claims to be Mobbenseer
SM - claims to be flog
Hatchy1992 - claims to be villager
matty6
Golumless - claims to be flog
Ant Bear
Millky95
TheFreightTrain - claims to be Juggilante

Remaining Roles
Villager x 2
Godfather
Juggilante
Mobbenseer x 2
WGS - can still recruit?
Jobe
Flogs x 3
Killerbeez x 1

Can we flush out a liar or 2 for voting today?

Think millky was also mentioned as being a flog.

Think Ant Bear is the odd one out today.

 

[Wosh]

Think millky was also mentioned as being a flog.

Think Ant Bear is the odd one out today.

Yea I couldn't see where Millky himself confirmed or denied it so I left it out

 

[pantskyle]

Yea I couldn't see where Millky himself confirmed or denied it so I left it out

I seered a flog last night and it was one mentioned as a flog in this thread so I'm all for believing.

 

[Brown Bottle]

Damn. Thanks for the game guys.

 

[Wosh]

Think millky was also mentioned as being a flog.

Think Ant Bear is the odd one out today.

Just finished searching and reading all Ant Bears posts, he seems quite cluey as to the workings for a brand new player, which makes me think he is in a group that can talk and has had help and guidance, so if he's not a flog that leaves the Vampires or Godfather. I've played a few games but the vamps still confuse me yet AB is chatting quite easily about their workings.
If he's good (as he claimed) and everyone else is who they claim they are, he is a Mobbenseer

 

[Broken]