Coach What would it take for you to be okay with Harvey being appointed coach next year?

[greening22]

For me; I think if we keep this attacking style consistent for the next three weeks and maybe one more win in that time, I wouldn't be opposed to Harvey getting a sniff at the full time gig to be honest. I'm LOVING the attacking balls out style. I'm LOVING the passion of the team that has been missing for a while. I'm LOVING the kids being played and bringing so much passion and emotion into it. I'm LOVING the risk, my biggest issue with Buckley was it felt like there was 0 risk in the gameplan, I love high risk, high reward.

Seems like the team is really up and about feeling refreshed under Harvey to be honest.

You are joking!

 

[Toecrusher]

What would it take?
Free membership wouldn't be enough, perhaps paying me the same a the senior coach might bring me around.

 

[unplugged]

Yeah, nah.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

In response to the question posed by the op: a traumatic brain injury

 

[stormskye]

 

[Horaceg]

It wouldn’t take much to convince me…..



………….as long it’s Carlton appointing him

 

[legendstatus]

For me not to be walking the Earth.

 

[Rorzza]

Looks like he has similar ideas to Bucks,.select as many defenders as.humanly possible. Then neglect the midfield which gets smashed against good sides.
No from me...

 

[magpiewarrior]

A flag first year, nothing else would be enough.

 

[MyManLynch]

Supposedly there is a stat that says 27 of the last 33 AFL Premierships have been won by first time coaches.
I heard that on ABC radio so I can only assume it is correct.

The balance 6 ?
Mathews 3 at Brisbane (2001-3)
Malthouse 1 at Collingwood (2010)
Parkin 1 at Carlton (1995)
Who is the other?

 

[MyManLynch]

The balance 6 ?
Mathews 3 at Brisbane (2001-3)
Malthouse 1 at Collingwood (2010)
Parkin 1 at Carlton (1995)
Who is the other?

Allan Jeans (1989)
What about Malthouse 1992 & 94? He had already coached Footscray

 

[jmac70]

Thanks for holding the fort Robert, good luck at your next club.

 

[Gabbo64]

2 mars bars and a jam donut. Oh....no...that was for something else!

 

[Go Woods]

https://www.afl.com.au/news/666998

I’d be happy with Harv’s hanging around as assistant to the new coach, but I don’t think it will be the case. Best of luck this weekend & lets stuff the Bombers finals chances.

 

[Kawenda]

For me; I think if we keep this attacking style consistent for the next three weeks and maybe one more win in that time, I wouldn't be opposed to Harvey getting a sniff at the full time gig to be honest. I'm LOVING the attacking balls out style. I'm LOVING the passion of the team that has been missing for a while. I'm LOVING the kids being played and bringing so much passion and emotion into it. I'm LOVING the risk, my biggest issue with Buckley was it felt like there was 0 risk in the gameplan, I love high risk, high reward.

Seems like the team is really up and about feeling refreshed under Harvey to be honest.

I would require a lobotomy to be ok with Harvey as our head coach

 

[HFF]

Today it finally ends...one of the last few pieces of the Nathan era.
Clean air awaits

 

[magpies42]

The end of the world

 

[Apples]

For me to accept Harvey as coach in 2022? A lobotomy.

 

[barrackers]

2021

Under Buckley:
Opposition - 140g 120b (ave 10.8g 9.5b)
Collingwood - 130g 130b (ave 10.0g 10.0b)


Under Harvey:
Opposition - 121g 80b (ave 13.4g 8.9b) *
Collingwood - 95g 77b (10.6g 8.6b)


* Including Hawthorn 15.7, Brisbane 22.10, Essendon 16.6 in his last 3 weeks.

Taking these three matches out it's:

Opposition 68g 57b (ave 11.3g 9.5b)
Collingwood 66g 25b (ave 11.0g 8.7b)




Basically despite the media hype of quicker footy under Harvey it equated to a similar amount of scoring shots and kicking straighter by 1 goal. Ignoring the last 3 games the opposition had one more scoring shot being a goal. The last three weeks however our structure fell away and we were opened up significantly.

 

[Anzacday]

For me to accept Harvey as coach in 2022? A lobotomy.

I’ve had lots of bottles in front of me during his coaching and it’s a no from me

 

[Capital Magpie]

2021

Under Buckley:
Opposition - 140g 120b (ave 10.8g 9.5b)
Collingwood - 130g 130b (ave 10.0g 10.0b)


Under Harvey:
Opposition - 121g 80b (ave 13.4g 8.9b) *
Collingwood - 95g 77b (10.6g 8.6b)


* Including Hawthorn 15.7, Brisbane 22.10, Essendon 16.6 in his last 3 weeks.

Taking these three matches out it's:

Opposition 68g 57b (ave 11.3g 9.5b)
Collingwood 66g 25b (ave 11.0g 8.7b)




Basically despite the media hype of quicker footy under Harvey it equated to a similar amount of scoring shots and kicking straighter by 1 goal. Ignoring the last 3 games the opposition had one more scoring shot being a goal. The last three weeks however our structure fell away and we were opened up significantly.

Interesting stats, although I have to admit when I first read your post, I thought you were comparing the average body weights of our players under Bucks and under Banger, i.e. Oppo - 140 grams; 120 lbs, C'wood - 130 grams; 130 lbs

 

[Rebuilder]

It's the cattle, not the coach. Leigh Matthews.