Where would Caddy go in 2012

[FlyingV]

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/...1=2310&tid2=24&pid2=3453&type=A&fid1=O&fid2=O

Dangerfield vs Caddy at age 20
Pretty similar stats, and same amount of experience in the AFL. He is not as fast as Dangerfield, but will be a top player and has better skills than Danger, but maybe not as gamebreaking. Mind you can compare again in 50 odd games.

Totally different players i dont get the relevance at all, i guess Pearce is better then them both?
Surely GC would take pick eleven from carlton

 

[supernova_]

Totally different players i dont get the relevance at all, i guess Pearce is better then them both?
Surely GC would take pick eleven from carlton

Why do you think they are different players? I think they have similar attributes coming through.

 

[yaco55]

Robbo seems to have failed to grasp the fact that in trading, you start high and work down?

And you have failed to grasp the reality that few clubs have two first round picks up their sleeves - Who has two first round picks - GWS,will have no interest - Melb, Caddy has no interest - Bulldogs, Caddy has expressed no interest, Collingwood now has 17-18 - So in fact there are limited options,very limited options - So in fact the GC are trading with themselves - What am embarrassing effort from the GC !

 

[Sunny_]

And you have failed to grasp the reality that few clubs have two first round picks up their sleeves - Who has two first round picks - GWS,will have no interest - Melb, Caddy has no interest - Bulldogs, Caddy has expressed no interest, Collingwood now has 17-18 - So in fact there are limited options,very limited options - So in fact the GC are trading with themselves - What am embarrassing effort from the GC !

No need to be cheeky about it. If you will read what I said, you will see that I do not think the Suns will get two 1st rounders at all. Just posturing really. Cats are in the prime position with their compo being the key.

 

[Slattery_20]

Time for DawOfPromotion, Jab and Hard_to_Beat to join me in a rousing, soul-cleansing "he's shit anyway and I'm glad we didn't overpay"

Do it, guys.
It's worth it.

 

[bulletproof]

Time for DawOfPromotion, Jab and Hard_to_Beat to join me in a rousing, soul-cleansing "he's shit anyway and I'm glad we didn't overpay"

Do it, guys.
It's worth it.

It's probably true for North because they have young midfielders, Geelong, St Kilda and Essendon on the other hand....

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

Time for DawOfPromotion, Jab and Hard_to_Beat to join me in a rousing, soul-cleansing "he's shit anyway and I'm glad we didn't overpay"

Do it, guys.
It's worth it.

The kid has plenty of raw talent, but a single mid to late 1st round pick is his worth.

2 x 1sr round is overs.

13, 24 & 34 is overs.

 

[Slattery_20]

It's probably true for North because they have young midfielders, Geelong, St Kilda and Essendon on the other hand....

Awww... look who's pissed off that he's going to Carlton. Amazing that people can have so much joy from a game and still end up so dry & bitter.

 

[HARKER]

Awww... look who's pissed off that he's going to Carlton. Amazing that people can have so much joy from a game and still end up so dry & bitter.

I doubt that Carlton have back-flipped on their stance just yet.

It may have possibly made things a little more uncertain since Viney didn't go at #3, but we think that there is better in the draft and will probably go that way.

 

[Slattery_20]

I doubt that Carlton have back-flipped on their stance just yet.

It may have possibly made things a little more uncertain since Viney didn't go at #3, but we think that there is better in the draft and will probably go that way.

NB taking piss.

Clearly nothing decided yet.

'sif I'd ever join Teffticles for anything.

 

[Vtorians]

Drag it out GC for everyones sanity.

When this circus ends the real off-season deadshitfight begins.

 

[boncer34]

So which is it?

One part of the Hun is speculating or the other part is being kept in the dark?

He can't be going to Geelong because their pick is set and the deal would be done.

He's going to North despite their pick being set because the deal is still being debated.

Which is it?

 

[supernova_]

The kid has plenty of raw talent, but a single mid to late 1st round pick is his worth.

2 x 1sr round is overs.

13, 24 & 34 is overs.

the 3 draft picks are for 2 players you realise?

Josh Caddy + Tom Hickey.

Not to mention St Kilda doesn't even have pick 13 to trade YET, its only rumoured as to what they will receive. So this is a myth no doubt. Will have to wait till Oct 19th for this offer to actually eventuate.

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

the 3 draft picks are for 2 players you realise?

Josh Caddy + Tom Hickey.

Not to mention St Kilda doesn't even have pick 13 to trade YET, its only rumoured as to what they will receive. So this is a myth no doubt. Will have to wait till Oct 19th for this offer to actually eventuate.

Yeah I do.

It's still ridiculous.

 

[Tragic sainter]

Yeah I do.

It's still ridiculous.

Not really, in the long run I think hickey will be more valuable than caddy. Did you see his game against collingwood and again against us? I'm not to fussed if we miss out on caddy as midfielders are easy to find, I'm pumped at the prospect of getting hickey though.

 

[MaddAdam]

Time for DawOfPromotion, Jab and Hard_to_Beat to join me in a rousing, soul-cleansing "he's shit anyway and I'm glad we didn't overpay"

Do it, guys.
It's worth it.

Has he officially gone somewhere?

Nah, he's very good and exactly what we needed, happy to overpay.

If we've missed him, ah well, life goes on.

 

[Jab]

Time for DawOfPromotion, Jab and Hard_to_Beat to join me in a rousing, soul-cleansing "he's shit anyway and I'm glad we didn't overpay"

Do it, guys.
It's worth it.

Yeah, he's not worth what they were asking. Glad we dodged that bullet

/supporter who's club wasn't chosen

 

[Slattery_20]

Has he officially gone somewhere?

Nah, he's very good and exactly what we needed, happy to overpay.

If we've missed him, ah well, life goes on.

If you miss him, then your club is officially finished as a legion of 13 year old trolls who say they support a 14 minute old club will remind you day-in, day-out for a year.
Highly recommended.

 

[boncer34]

Yeah I do.

It's still ridiculous.

So Pick 14 plus a player or second rounder is perfect for Caddy.

But pick 13 + 2nd rounder x2 is to much for 2 players?

I think somebody is experiencing a post-tradethatwasneverhappening crash.

 

[Son_Of_God29]

So Pick 14 plus a player or second rounder is perfect for Caddy.

But pick 13 + 2nd rounder x2 is to much for 2 players?

I think somebody is experiencing a post-tradethatwasneverhappening crash.

Let him go into the Draft and Screw GC they have managed to screw with the rest of the comp since they came in

 

[supernova_]

Let him go into the Draft and Screw GC they have managed to screw with the rest of the comp since they came in

Nice nickname...still sour about Gaz heading north.

Caddy will get to Geelong, dont get your knickers in a knot...its barely been the 3rd day! There is still 12 more days to go, get used to it.

 

[Ari]

Let him go into the Draft and Screw GC they have managed to screw with the rest of the comp since they came in

haha what he said!

 

[aussierulesrules]

Are we there yet?

 

[Vtorians]

Too late! Other than Sunny we now all hate everything associated with the Suns. Enjoy

 

[saintsrfreak]

the 3 draft picks are for 2 players you realise?

Josh Caddy + Tom Hickey.

Not to mention St Kilda doesn't even have pick 13 to trade YET, its only rumoured as to what they will receive. So this is a myth no doubt. Will have to wait till Oct 19th for this offer to actually eventuate.

Yeah I've been saying this, we can't have offered pick 13 because it isn't even definite that we're getting it yet