Where would Judd be??

[melo_15]

Rank your top 10 greatest players of the past 20 years, heres mine:

1 James Hird
2 Tony Lockett
3 Greg Williams
4 Robert Harvey
5 Wayne Carey
6 Chris Judd (not top five JUST yet)
7 Jason Dunstall
8 Gary Ablett Snr
9 Michael Voss
10 Steven Silvagni

 

[VINCANITY]

i rate 7-10 in that list all better then judd

 

[dukester95]

To early to put him that group, but will be no. 1 before his career is finished.






---------------------------------------------
Here come da Judd

 

[Kramer1]

Let's take our collective hands off it...

The guys played six years and we are trying to compare him to out and out champions. Let him be judged by the end of his career...I am sure if he maintiants his present impact on the game he will be ranked in this echelon.

And no Buckley on your list? Love him or loathe him he is an absolute champion footballer.

 

[HBF]

Not that high - yet.
Wait until his career has finished, and then we can start to rank him with the past champions of our great game.

 

[as0l0]

has a lot to do before he gets near that list.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

1. Jordan Bannister


.............. <waits>

 

[Pamam]

1. Jordan Bannister


.............. <waits>

ODN!!! i think you got it!!!

 

[I_was_there_in_87]

1. g williams
2. s silvagni
3. w. johnston
4. s. kernahan
5. m fitzpatrick
6. b doull
7. a koutifides
8. c bradley
9. b ratten
10. k hunter


give him a few years

 

[FieryNayta]

Rank your top 10 greatest players of the past 20 years, heres mine:

1 James Hird
2 Tony Lockett
3 Greg Williams
4 Robert Harvey
5 Wayne Carey
6 Chris Judd (not top five JUST yet)
7 Jason Dunstall
8 Gary Ablett Snr
9 Michael Voss
10 Steven Silvagni

I agree with you James Hird is the best player i've ever seen play the game. Followed very closely by Gablett Snr.

We'll have to see how Judd's career pans out though. I dont think 6 years of brilliance can rank him as an all time great.

 

[BluesRules]

Rank your top 10 greatest players of the past 20 years, heres mine:

1 James Hird
2 Tony Lockett
3 Greg Williams
4 Robert Harvey
5 Wayne Carey
6 Chris Judd (not top five JUST yet)
7 Jason Dunstall
8 Gary Ablett Snr
9 Michael Voss
10 Steven Silvagni

Just a quick list

1: Chris Judd (Unless he drops off)
2: Wayne Carey
3: Tony Lockett
4: Anothony Koutoufides
5: Greg Williams
6: James Hird
7: Gary Ablett Snr
8: Michael Voss
9: Mark Rucciuto
10: Nathan Buckley

 

[Monkey King]

I don't get it. I loved Diesel, he's one of my all time favourites, but I couldn't have him above Ablett on a best-of list.

 

[Faz 2000]

Blowing your wad way too early to have Judd on "best in last 20 years" lists.

He's awesome, and the number #1 in the game as recently as 12 months ago.

If he stays that way for another 5 years, wins another Brownlow and or Premiership, then he could look at this list.

 

[Beloved]

Probably around the 7-10 mark you'd think, at the maximum that is.

 

[Jeremias]

1. James Hird
2. Garry Ablett Snr
3. Wayne Carey
4. Michael Voss
5. Tony Lockett
6. Greg Williams
7. Nathan Buckley
8. Robert Harvey
9. Mark Ricciuto
10. Jason Dunstall

Stephen Kernahan unlucky to miss out.

They are the best 10 players that I have seen play. Keep in mind that I was born in 1989.

Judd isn't there, and rightly so. He's close, that's for sure, and at only 24/25 years of age, it wouldn't surprise me to see him there by the end of his career.

 

[bLuEbOy1984]

Wayne Carey
Greg Williams
James Hird
Tony Lockett
Robert Harvey
Steven Silvagni
Gary Ablett Snr
Jason Dunstall
Mark Riccuito
Michael Voss

a player i would love to put up their but never recognised as others, Gary Hocking

 

[Dima]

1. James Hird
2. Garry Ablett Snr
3. Wayne Carey
4. Michael Voss
5. Tony Lockett
6. Greg Williams
7. Nathan Buckley
8. Robert Harvey
9. Mark Ricciuto
10. Jason Dunstall

Stephen Kernahan unlucky to miss out.

They are the best 10 players that I have seen play. Keep in mind that I was born in 1989.

Judd isn't there, and rightly so. He's close, that's for sure, and at only 24/25 years of age, it wouldn't surprise me to see him there by the end of his career.

Considering you were born in 89, i'm surprised you remember that much of Dunstall, Ablett Snr and Lockett. Having said that, I think you're list is pretty much my top 10 over this period. If not for the knees, I have no doubt Kouta would have had the necessary credentials to make the middle of that list.

 

[wally funk]

Wayne Carey
Greg Williams
James Hird
Tony Lockett
Robert Harvey
Steven Silvagni
Gary Ablett Snr
Jason Dunstall
Mark Riccuito
Michael Voss

a player i would love to put up their but never recognised as others, Gary Hocking

this would be about my list, except that wayne carey's at the bottom, not the top, and probably switch williams and hird.
agree wholeheartedly regarding hocking - awesome player!