Where's the consistency?

[Look2Me4Guidance]

The Match Review Panel.

We all know it's a roulette affair when you get charged.

However it seems more often than not the Saints cop the rough end of the stick.

Comparing Kosi's jumper punch to that of Didak's on Slattery from the weekend is my bone of contention here.

Kosi was stupid for doing it, no argument there.

Please tell me though how Didak's was any less of an offence? The Match Review Panel has deemed it wasn't forceful enough contact. What a joke. Not even a reprimand.

I realise Kosi's was only worth a reprimand but got a suspension due to carry over points.

Compare what Lynden Dunn did to Brent Harvey and what Fiora did to Osborne. These received reprimands and yet Didak gets off scott free.

I know most fans feel like this but I sometimes can't help but think we are constantly harshly dealt with when it comes to the Match Review Panel.

What do you all think?

 

[beejay]

yeh seems a bit of injustice but i do believe reading something that kozi got his due to carry over points and bad record or something and didak had no points like kozi so that seems it woulda helped him - but his was thrown out wasnt it? at least a few points to go his way!

 

[Signd Sealed Saint]

I heard the match review panel's explanation on SEN and all i can say is BULLSHIT. Theres no doubt we would've won the Eagles game with Kosi, Gardiner was a liablility and without Kosi we were too Rooey conscious. **** you match review panel, it's made up of blind old ****ers. I'm absolutely furious with the AFL.

 

[Sainters66]

The system is a joke.

 

[ChrisFooty]

Both of those incidents should have been cleared by the tribunal. Both were nothing.

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

joke

 

[Otiman]

It's about as consistent as our form at present.

 

[Persevering Saint]

It's about as consistent as our form at present.

I have to admit, that's what I thought this thread would be about when I read the title!!

 

[gilbert the best]

do you think the st kilda footy club does enough for there players when fronting the tribunal I.E. Baker,he would never been charged had the saints handled it correctly and gagged him,he got found guilty on his own evidence and would have got off due to no video evidence. Who knows with a different result he might have been playing all year