Which is better?

[Truetiger]

I was given this list of sides that would run and chase.
Which side is better

Side 1

White Schultz P.Bowden
Newman Polak Thursfield
Tivendale Bowden Howatt
Deledio Richardson Raines
Brown Kingsley Tambling
Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Hall Hartigan Tuck Polo
Emg: Moore,Hyde, Jackson,Krakouer, Pettifer




Side 2

Newman Thursfield P Bowden
Raines Polak Deledio
Tivendale J.Bowden Howatt
Brown Richo Tambling
Kingsley Schultz Polo
Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Hall Hartigan White Hyde
Emg: Moore, Jackson,Pattison,Pettifer, Tuck


Coburg: Gasper Unchanged.

Thoughts would be welcome.

 

[PLSC]

both teams suck

 

[Darth_Tiger]

lol plsc back in form i see

 

[PLSC]

team 1 is just awful

team 2 has a good backline thats about it

 

[Haggard H]

both teams suck

Hey P, have you been following the euthanasia debate going on at the moment? Get involved mate. You'll be doing all us Tiger supporters a favour, advancing the cause of dying with dignity, and getting yourself on the front page of the papers, all at the same time.

It's a win, win, win situation!

 

[itsintheblood]

Neither of those teams will prevent us finishing bottom 4 im afraid. 07 is almost a write off already!!!!

 

[Tambo]

Moore would have to be in the side

 

[Simche]

Why do you not rate Shane Tuck? He's probably one of our better extractors and more consistent mids and yet he's on the bench of team one and an emergency for team two I dare say he'd walk into the team ahead of Tivendale, White, Howat, Harttigan etc.

 

[sante]

Pettifer, Hyde and Tuck are certain starters, Krakouer will be too unless Jackson does something.

 

[tigerdan]

With Gaspar's inept performance last week I can't see Bowden playing in the centre (even thought you don't have Gaspar playing). Once again we'll have to use him as the link man out of defence. He has 2 AA's doing that anyway.

Schulz looks like a FF to me and that is the only place I would play him.

By the end of the year I hope Thursfield and Hughes are both playing in the seniors. I think Thursfield could be a modern CHB and Hughes a CHF. I think that Kingsley is there to prevent players such as Hughes from becoming another 'too much too early' casualty.

Is there a reason why you are being so harsh on Pettifer and Tuck? The days of 'Pettiphile' and 'Petticoat' are behind us. I think they are both walk-up starts.