Roast Who pooped the bed more in Round 23, 2023?

[Ice-Wolf]

Some truly terrible performances this round from teams with everything on the line.

Whose performance was worse?

Essendon with their finals chances on the line not only losing but getting pumped so hard they shed any chance of making finals next week against an injury riddled Collingwood side by ruining their percentage?

Western Bulldogs who lost at home to the worst side of the season with everyone having declared their victory not only fait accompli but one they would achieve by a significant margin as well.

The Goal Umpire from the Adelaide vs Sydney game who not only made a howler of a decision but double down by not even entertaining the idea of reviewing it closing the door on multiple sides finals chances and sending others into disarray?

 

[Ice-Wolf]

I think I'm going with Essendon purely because the Bulldogs have a chance to rectify their situation next week. Where as no matter what Essendon does they wont be able to make up enough percentage.

That Goal Umpire was a close 2nd though but the Bulldogs have alleviated my finals concerns as a St Kilda fan.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Some truly terrible performances this round from teams with everything on the line.

Who's performance was worse?

Essendon with their finals chances on the line not only losing but getting pumped so hard they shed any chance of making finals next week against an injury riddled Collingwood side by ruining their percentage?

Western Bulldogs who lost at home to the worst side of the season with everyone having assumed declared their victory not only fait accompli but one they would achieve by a significant margin as well.

The Goal Umpire from the Adelaide vs Sydney game who not only made a howler of a decision but double down by not even entertaining the idea of reviewing it closing the door on multiple sides finals chances and sending others into disarray?

Regardless of the incompetant goal umpire Adelaide dominated the 4th they had a remarkable 12 scoring shots to kick 4.8.

But were woeful in the first 3 quarters to what they have produced at home this season.

 

[GROTTO]

The Goal Umpire in the Crows game.

 

[Colonial]

Dogs. At least the Bombers were playing a team battling for finals.
The Eagles wanted to come last and still the Dogs couldn’t beat them at home.

 

[Ice-Wolf]

Dogs. At least the Bombers were playing a team battling for finals.
The Eagles wanted to come last and still the Dogs couldn’t beat them at home.

Yeah but 120+ point thumping when they needed a win, even if they still lost it needed to be much more competitive, they ruined any chances of scraping through with a good win against an undermanned Collingwood on Friday. Bulldogs still have a chance by beating Geelong.

 

[ThatsjustDappa]

Are you 12....?

 

[Ice-Wolf]

Are you 12....?

Cleaning up the language for the main board.

 

[Obeanie1]

Can we please have an option to vote for Eagles - losing the Harley Reid Cup.

Thanks

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Can we please have an option to vote for Eagles - losing the Harley Reid Cup.

Thanks

Were you definitely taking him at 1?

 

[HarryBeef]

Whose*

 

[windyhill]

GWS were clear favourites,anyone tipping Essendon probably has Stephen Dank on speed dial. As disgraceful as we were, I’m going that goal umpire.

 

[Hamingja]

Essendon with the Jimmy Amber Heard

Not even bother going to try to clean those sheets, straight in the bin

 

[HarryBeef]

GWS were clear favourites,anyone tipping Essendon probably has Stephen Dank on speed dial. As disgraceful as we were, I’m going that goal umpire.

There's clear favourites...and then there's losing by 120+ with finals in play.

 

[Ice-Wolf]

Can we please have an option to vote for Eagles - losing the Harley Reid Cup.

Thanks

Nah that was done 3 weeks ago by beating North Melbourne at home. Not tanking as well as North is not pooping the bed.

 

[Ice-Wolf]

Whose*

Who has* but Who is grammatically correct as well.

 

[windyhill]

There's clear favourites...and then there's losing by 120+ with finals in play.

Agreed there is that, but really H, the cue went in the rack a month ago.

 

[windyhill]

Essendon with the Jimmy Amber Heard

Not even bother going to try to clean those sheets, straight in the bin

Oh when The Saints.....

 

[Rich01]

The bulldogs with finals on the line is really hard to explain. A potential coach killer right there.

Well done to the eagles team by pushing hard and winning with the talent they had.

But surely this isn’t the result the club wanted long term.

Might be the win that saves Simpson for another season but denies them the ideal asset for their rebuild. Bit of a lose-lose right there.
The club needs a fresh start and some hope and Harley Reid and a fresh new coach would have given the fans some hope for next year.

There’s a real chance now the Eagles don’t get any of the top three talents in this draft now. Big, big cost to win a game at this time of year.

 

[PhatBoy]

The dogs of the teams listed but I’d like to throw us in there too.
St Kilda played a great game and you could attribute a lot of our poor footy to how good they were, but were pathetic as well.

 

[HarryBeef]

Who has* but Who is grammatically correct as well.

Not talking about the title

 

[My Tilly]

Essendon quite easily.
That was one of the worst performances by any club for over a decade. When you take into account what was at stake, they literally looked limp, uninspired and almost didn't want to compete.

 

[windyhill]

Essendon quite easily.
That was one of the worst performances by any club for over a decade. When you take into account what was at stake, they literally looked limp, uninspired and almost didn't want to compete.

Utterly disgusting from Essendon, you can’t defend that . But compare the lists Ess/Dogs. They are head and shoulders above us and we still pipped w.coast two weeks ago even with the umpire throwing the ball directly to us for the winning goal.

 

[Plugger35]

I would have the Dogs first losing to the last placed team at home, Essendon second for losing by over 100 points and Geelong rounding it out for third.

Geelong's performance didn't look all that bad on the scoreboard but we really should have beaten them by over 10 goals with all the chances we had.

I was expecting a much tougher game from the reigning premiers but only Stewart and Hawkins turned up, Dangerfield and Cameron were pathetic.

 

[PhatBoy]

I would have the Dogs first losing to the last placed team at home, Essendon second for losing by over 100 points and Geelong rounding it out for third.

Geelong's performance didn't look all that bad on the scoreboard but we really should have beaten them by over 10 goals with all the chances we had.

I was expecting a much tougher game from the reigning premiers but only Stewart and Hawkins turned up, Dangerfield and Cameron were pathetic.

Atkins.