Remove this Banner Ad

Universal Love Wingard

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
TeeKray said:
You can't drop Neade, who visually works his ass off every week, before Chad, who visually looks like he doesn't want to be out there. Sends a terrible message.

inb4 whynotboth.jpg
Click to expand...

He has not kicked a single goal for four games!

Half the board is complaining about lack of standards, what happened to the real Port Adelaide, Ken's too soft yada yada yada and yet we're defending a bloke with 9.5 disposals ppg and 0 goals from his last four games. It's no wonder we're ****ed if this is how far our supporters' standards have dropped. I could go out there and try really hard and kick zero goals in four games, maybe I should take Wingard's spot.
 
TeeKray said:
You can't drop Neade, who visually works his ass off every week, before Chad, who visually looks like he doesn't want to be out there. Sends a terrible message.

inb4 whynotboth.jpg
Click to expand...

YES YOU CAN - JAKE NEADE IS SHIT !

Works his ass off ? Runs around out of position, runs over the ball, fumbles, has very little possessions and goes missing... Nearly cost us the showdown, almost cocked up one of Gray's goals where he nearly missed one of the easies handballs you'll ever see and ran over the ball which handed the Corws possession in the last few seconds had there been 5-10 more second the crows go inside 50 becouse Neade ran over the ball.

WE NEED NEADE OUT ASAP ! is simply not up to it.
 
TeeKray said:
You can't drop Neade, who visually works his ass off every week, before Chad, who visually looks like he doesn't want to be out there. Sends a terrible message.

inb4 whynotboth.jpg
Click to expand...
Nah at this point I’d take Lindsay Thomas at least you know even if he plays shit he’ll manage 10 touches and no goals
 
Schulzenfest said:
He has not kicked a single goal for four games!

Half the board is complaining about lack of standards, what happened to the real Port Adelaide, Ken's too soft yada yada yada and yet we're defending a bloke with 9.5 disposals ppg and 0 goals from his last four games. It's no wonder we're ****** if this is how far our supporters' standards have dropped. I could go out there and try really hard and kick zero goals in four games, maybe I should take Wingard's spot.
Click to expand...
Dropping Jake Neade will make Ken hard huh lol jeezus we've got our wires meshed on this but it's a typical soft option for Ken to drop him it sends a message to no one.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

JimmyBeerCans said:
Dropping Jake Neade will make Ken hard huh lol jeezus we've got our wires meshed on this but it's a typical soft option for Ken to drop him it sends a message to no one.
Click to expand...

It's not about looking hard or sending a message. It's just about getting him out of our side never to be seen again and replacing him with someone better, because he's not up to AFL football and he never will be.

Not everything has to be about sending messages or putting rockets up people. Sometimes you just drop a player because he's not much good.

PJ Power said:
I’d play Thomas over Neade.
Click to expand...

Forward depth chart for the last spot looks like this ATM:

1. Marshall
2. AJ
3. Thomas
4. Inanimate carbon rod
5. Neade
 
Schulzenfest said:
It's not about looking hard or sending a message. It's just about getting him out of our side never to be seen again and replacing him with someone better, because he's not up to AFL football and he never will be.
Click to expand...
That's fine if that's what you think we beg to differ I think he's an ok fringe player all clubs have them, I'm just expecting something as pedestrian and soft as

Out: Neade
In: Amon
 
Schulzenfest said:
It's not about looking hard or sending a message. It's just about getting him out of our side never to be seen again and replacing him with someone better, because he's not up to AFL football and he never will be.

Not everything has to be about sending messages or putting rockets up people. Sometimes you just drop a player because he's not much good.



Forward depth chart for the last spot looks like this ATM:

1. Marshall
2. AJ
3. Thomas
4. Inanimate carbon rod
5. Neade
Click to expand...

Alright then. I’d play Thomas over the inanimate carbon rod.
 
JimmyBeerCans said:
That's fine if that's what you think we beg to differ I think he's an ok fringe player all clubs have them, I'm just expecting something as pedestrian and soft as

Out: Neade
In: Amon
Click to expand...

He's not, and they don't. Or if they do then they're stuck in the reserves where they belong.

Challenge: Find a player at another club who:

a) is a midfielder or a forward (i.e. primary role isn't to play as a stopper)
b) has played over 50 games (i.e. not a young kid finding his feet)
c) has averaged less than 10 disposals and has not kicked a goal over four consecutive games without being dropped.

If you can find a single one I'll eat Pappagallo's hat.
 
finbarr said:
I have it on very good authority he had strips torn off him by the coach in front of the entire group immediately after the Geelong loss for being too hungry in front of goal. Since then timid, look for an option Chad has been noticeable.
Click to expand...
Then Hinkley can go and f@#k himself and learn how to coach again. You don't take a player like Chad and do that to him, would Pyke do the same to Betts if he misses a couple from the pocket in a big game. No, he'd back his talents in. Something Ken clearly doesn't do with Chad at all based on this. No wonder he's handballing off shots he can kick or just centreing the ball when he is more then capable of kicking them. In a team where we struggle for goal kickers or match winners that coaching by Hinkley is downright disgusting and embarrassing.

I will say Chad's form is not good enough, but a few things I keep hearing are starting to show why.
 
finbarr said:
I have it on very good authority he had strips torn off him by the coach in front of the entire group immediately after the Geelong loss for being too hungry in front of goal. Since then timid, look for an option Chad has been noticeable.
Click to expand...
That explains a lot. Go **** yourself, Ken.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Schulzenfest said:
He's not, and they don't. Or if they do then they're stuck in the reserves where they belong.

Challenge: Find a player at another club who:

a) is a midfielder or a forward (i.e. primary role isn't to play as a stopper)
b) has played over 50 games (i.e. not a young kid finding his feet)
c) has averaged less than 10 disposals and has not kicked a goal over four consecutive games without being dropped.

If you can find a single one I'll eat Pappagallo's hat.
Click to expand...
Think I'll pass I might comb my pubes instead
 
Adam Marrett23 said:
Then Hinkley can go and f@#k himself and learn how to coach again. You don't take a player like Chad and do that to him, would Pyke do the same to Betts if he misses a couple from the pocket in a big game. No, he'd back his talents in. Something Ken clearly doesn't do with Chad at all based on this. No wonder he's handballing off shots he can kick or just centreing the ball when he is more then capable of kicking them. In a team where we struggle for goal kickers or match winners that coaching by Hinkley is downright disgusting and embarrassing.

I will say Chad's form is not good enough, but a few things I keep hearing are starting to show why.
Click to expand...
Nah Pyke takes em' on terror camps to make em' go backwards
 
All is not right with his mindstate on the field. There is no doubt about that. No good football club would let someone with the talent of Wingard be the player he has been for us the past 18 months.
 
If Wingard is any Eddie Murphy, right now it is Another 48 Hours Eddie Murphy

62cd77a9427b309a72ccabf014394f14.jpg
 
Don’t want to go hard at this bloke as you never know what is happening in a player’s personal life, but the bloke is is a shadow of his former self.

He is so far off being the player he looked like he was going to become, it is scary.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

QPower said:
Don’t want to go hard at this bloke as you never know what is happening in a player’s personal life, but the bloke is is a shadow of his former self.

He is so far off being the player he looked like he was going to become, it is scary.
Click to expand...

Agreed, there has to be a reason why a 2x All Australian has literally fallen off a cliff, a special talent like he had just doesn't evaporate, and it wasn't all that long ago that every other club in the comp would have given up plenty to get him.
 
Pt Augusta Power said:
cant see Chad with us beyond 2018. He'll be at Hawthorn for their 2nd draft pick.

cause that is what we do since 2004
Click to expand...
I doubt this. Too close to his family’
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom