Worst AA selection since 2000

[Kings Army]

Who is the worst selection from 2000. I went for Mooney last year. Still shake my head at how that rabbit was selected.

 

[ThePine]

I went for Bowden in 06 only because he was selected at CHB.

 

[ize_]

I went for Bowden in 06 only because he was selected at CHB.

That's where he played....

 

[jonesy86]

The worst omission was Russell Robertson from 2006... I still don't know what he did wrong.

 

[dutchy12]

The worst omission was Russell Robertson from 2006... I still don't know what he did wrong.

Lol that was the most rediculous thing of all time wasn't it?

And they selected Peter Everitt in the forward pocket instead? WTF

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

That's where he played....

Yeah, and Alwyn Davey is a ruckman Bowden CHB? You're having a laugh, the guy has never had an opponent in his whole career and you think he was lining up on players like Riewoldt, Pavlich, Tredrea, Brown & Lucas in 2006?

 

[Kyusss]

Yeah, and Alwyn Davey is a ruckman Bowden CHB? You're having a laugh, the guy has never had an opponent in his whole career and you think he was lining up on players like Riewoldt, Pavlich, Tredrea, Brown & Lucas in 2006?

he actually played on every player u just named that year

 

[Headless]

The worst omission was Russell Robertson from 2006... I still don't know what he did wrong.

I literally LOL'd at that decision, mainly from disbelief.

 

[Quinz]

Phil Matera kicked 62 goals in 03, he was fifth for goalkickers that year, and third for goals per game.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

where is the Judd 2008 option?

everyone knows he got in on reputation and nothing more.

Judd 2008 and Mooney 2007.

 

[ize_]

Yeah, and Alwyn Davey is a ruckman Bowden CHB? You're having a laugh, the guy has never had an opponent in his whole career and you think he was lining up on players like Riewoldt, Pavlich, Tredrea, Brown & Lucas in 2006?

he actually played on every player u just named that year

Yep, what he said. And he beat most of them. Killed Brown and Riewoldt. Short memory must have a...
Shor-or-ort memory...

 

[Kings Army]

Phil Matera kicked 62 goals in 03, he was fifth for goalkickers that year, and third for goals per game.

Thats maybe why he has no votes.

 

[iGNITER]

Cam Mooney 07

 

[tribey]

Harsh on Buddy Whitnall.

He was immense in 2000, booting 65 goals in the regular season and 70 total - also lead the league in marks and only turned 21 in August of that year.

Whoever votes for him knows nothing about footy really.

 

[TwisTz]

Mooney in 07.

Buddy should have had the spot way before him.

 

[Ant_]

Where is the Tom Harley selection for 08?

 

[4GIBBINS34]

Harsh on Buddy Whitnall.

He was immense in 2000, booting 65 goals in the regular season and 70 total - also lead the league in marks and only turned 21 in August of that year.

Whoever votes for him knows nothing about footy really.

Spot on. I'd like to know why he is even mentioned in the poll. Ridiculous.

 

[Tyler Durden007]

Who is the worst selection from 2000. I went for Mooney last year. Still shake my head at how that rabbit was selected.

Where's the Judd option from this year muppet?

and if you're still not sure about Mooney, I can burn you a copy of the QF from last year to help you understand.

 

[Kong]

Where's the Judd option from this year muppet?

and if you're still not sure about Mooney, I can burn you a copy of the QF from last year to help you understand.

so he got in on one game?

 

[tazhawk]

Mooney 2007 still staggers me.

As does Judd 2008.

 

[Johnny_Segment]

Where's the Judd option from this year muppet?

and if you're still not sure about Mooney, I can burn you a copy of the QF from last year to help you understand.

By the look of the voting, it seems as though everyone is already pretty sure about Mooney champ.

 

[Hilfy]

Where's the Judd option from this year muppet?

and if you're still not sure about Mooney, I can burn you a copy of the QF from last year to help you understand.

Didnt realise that you can get an AA berth with good matches in the finals...

 

[wheels4]

Yep, what he said. And he beat most of them. Killed Brown and Riewoldt. Short memory must have a...
Shor-or-ort memory...

Riewoldt vs Richmond in 06
in 2 matches (overall stats):

32 disposals
20 marks
4 goals 5 behinds

J.Brown vs Richmond in 06
1 match:

19 disposals
11 marks
2 goals 3 behind

if Bowden played on these 2 i would say he got beaten by both

get your facts right before you post buddy

 

[macca_2111]

Paul Williams 2003...absolute joke there was no Crawf that year

 

[Heisenberg_]

Yeah, and Alwyn Davey is a ruckman Bowden CHB? You're having a laugh, the guy has never had an opponent in his whole career and you think he was lining up on players like Riewoldt, Pavlich, Tredrea, Brown & Lucas in 2006?

Well actually he did.
Anybody that questions his inclusion has NFI