Worst afl player you've seen (and why)

[Looney]

Steven Kolyniuk. He kicked a winning goal against the Pies by running around Graeme Wright on the mark, and he pretty much milked his entire career around that one flukey play.

I have quite a few Collingwood players as honourable mentions but I am too scared to list them as I might be branded as a traitor.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Steve Silvagni the most over rated anyway

 

[Steven Gank]

Levi Casboult

 

[eppo67]

Keegan Brooksby or Jarred Grant

 

[Benaly28]

Setanta.No further comment.

 

[Blue1980]

Steve Silvagni the most over rated anyway

Alex is best Silvagni

 

[Blue1980]

Steven Kolyniuk. He kicked a winning goal against the Pies by running around Graeme Wright on the mark, and he pretty much milked his entire career around that one flukey play.

I have quite a few Collingwood players as honourable mentions but I am too scared to list them as I might be branded as a traitor.

Jason Wild?

 

[Blue1980]

Setanta.No further comment.

Wouldn't make the 20 worst Carlton players I've seen

 

[Benaly28]

Wouldn't make the 20 worst Carlton players I've seen

Name me 10 or so.Curious.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Alex is best Silvagni

J bailey

 

[Blue1980]

Name me 10 or so.Curious.

Cain Ackland
Ben Sexton
Adrian Deluca
Tom Fields
Daniel Gorringe
Aaron Joseph
Luke Livingston
Murray Vance
Digby Morrell
Ricky Mott

Easy name more, or do you have a cut off of games they need to have played?

 

[pockets75]

Ty Esler

 

[Tales]

Sudjai cook, name says it all ,actually think his name was better than any resemblance of skill he had

 

[Power Raid]

View attachment 376481

Wtf?

Who is that? Who does that?

 

[Blue1980]

Wtf?

Who is that? Who does that?

He looks like he's 12

 

[Benaly28]

Cain Ackland
Ben Sexton
Adrian Deluca
Tom Fields
Daniel Gorringe
Aaron Joseph
Luke Livingston
Murray Vance
Digby Morrell
Ricky Mott

Easy name more, or do you have a cut off of games they need to have played?

Not bad how about Callan beasy,prendergast,mclaren give me some more.

 

[Blue1980]

Not bad how about Callan beasy,prendergast,mclaren give me some more.

Prenda wasn't that bad! The other 2 def were

Okay there is a fair few more

Glen Bowyer (shot when he came to us)
Kenna (vfl midget)
Clarke (from the cats)
Mick Mansfield (very good career at the cats was awful for us)
Stephen O'Reilly
Trent Sporn
Whiley
Josh Bootsma
Matthew Watson
Andrew Collins
Marcus Davies
Kane Lucas
Chris Johnson
David Ellard
Mark Austin
Sam Cranage

No wonder we have been shit most of this century

 

[Teflon Dons]

Wtf?

Who is that? Who does that?

Bootsma.

Was looking at the 2001 superdraft the other day. We ****ed that up big time. Shane Harvey at 14 and Simon o'keefe.....
Boy. Thats bad

 

[Benaly28]

Prenda wasn't that bad! The other 2 def were

Okay there is a fair few more

Glen Bowyer (shot when he came to us)
Kenna (vfl midget)
Clarke (from the cats)
Mick Mansfield (very good career at the cats was awful for us)
Stephen O'Reilly
Trent Sporn
Whiley
Josh Bootsma
Matthew Watson
Andrew Collins
Marcus Davies
Kane Lucas
Chris Johnson
David Ellard
Mark Austin
Sam Cranage

No wonder we have been shit most of this century

Who was the player from the saints we got back in the day pretty sure had blonde curly hair?

 

[Benaly28]

Callum chambers,Adrian deluca,Cameron croad,Troy Langmuir.

 

[Blue1980]

Who was the player from the saints we got back in the day pretty sure had blonde curly hair?

Craig Devonport

Played 1 game for us I think

 

[north_lad]

Cain Ackland
Ben Sexton
Adrian Deluca
Tom Fields
Daniel Gorringe
Aaron Joseph
Luke Livingston
Murray Vance
Digby Morrell
Ricky Mott

Easy name more, or do you have a cut off of games they need to have played?

Excuse me, as Digby Morrell's biggest fan I would like an immediate written apology

 

[Satan]

Barry Hall making HOF

 

[Blue1980]

Excuse me, as Digby Morrell's biggest fan I would like an immediate written apology

I refuse to retract.

His name alone screams bush footballer

 

[north_lad]

I refuse to retract.

His name alone screams bush footballer

I was so devvo when we traded him hahahaha to be fair I was still in high school. Was also the year I signed up to this board...