Worst pick 4 since 2000

[Daytripper]

Pick 4 has been somewhat of a poisoned chalice for a number of years.

Brisbane fans must be hoping that Leuenberger does not fall victim to the 'pick 4 curse.'

My vote goes to Josh Kennedy who looks even more hopeless than his predecessor at Carlton, Luke Livingston.

Am giving Walsh a chance due to his horrendous run with injuries.

 

[BedlamHawk]

I voted for Walsh coz I still can't remember who the hell this bloke was?

 

[Souup]

Leuenberger will turn out the best of his draft..

Anyone who has seem him play knows just how good he is

 

[Stifler's mom]

I voted for Josh Kennedy. I went to the G today thinking this guy was a dud and I think I over rated him!
On the subject of blues players who are duds, Paul Bower has nothing at all going for him as an AFL player.

 

[thebigboy]

I'll spare Walsh cause of his injuries, but apart from that its pretty hard to split them.

Kennedy looks average but he's only a 2nd year player so you'd give him a bit more time.

 

[HBK619]

Polak should not be on this list, he is a good player and will only keep getting better at the Tigers.

 

[legitimatic]

I can't believe Polak has a vote, I checked to see who had voted for him fully expecting it to be an Eagles fan, but it was a Freo supporter! Ridiculous.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Gotta be Livingstone, Kennedy could still turn out to be something.

 

[warney7]

Seriously, who is Tim Walsh?

I have never heard of him, so clearly he gets my vote!

 

[Silvagnis]

I voted for Josh Kennedy. I went to the G today thinking this guy was a dud and I think I over rated him!
On the subject of blues players who are duds, Paul Bower has nothing at all going for him as an AFL player.

He has more going for him than Toovey who makes Fisher look like a great kick and doing nothing more than tagging.

Bower was an AA CHB as a junior who was highly rated at the draft and it's far too early to make a statement as big as that about a developing tall defender.

Kade Simpson had doughnuts in his first three games.

Worry about the hacks Collingwood drafted ahead of Muston and Hughes.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

He has more going for him than Toovey who makes Fisher look like a great kick and doing nothing more than tagging.

Bower was an AA CHB as a junior who was highly rated at the draft and it's far too early to make a statement as big as that about a developing tall defender.

Kade Simpson had doughnuts in his first three games.

Worry about the hacks Collingwood drafted ahead of Muston and Hughes.

Which is what Walker was doing on Thomas, I noticed, at least we spend a rookie draft pick on taggers rather than our top 5 national draft choices.

You're kidding yourself if you think Bower's 3 games have been better than Toovey's. Did you see his 3 goals on debut? How about his mark in the last line of defence against Adelaide?

 

[pendles]

He has more going for him than Toovey who makes Fisher look like a great kick and doing nothing more than tagging.

Bower was an AA CHB as a junior who was highly rated at the draft and it's far too early to make a statement as big as that about a developing tall defender.

So it's too early to make statements about a 2005 second round pick but fine to write off a rookie in the same draft who was never meant to be anything but is performing better at senior level?

Kade Simpson had doughnuts in his first three games.

...and is still rubbish.

Worry about the hacks Collingwood drafted ahead of Muston and Hughes.

2005 National Draft update:

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=5&pid1=1611&tid2=4&pid2=1610

Nice avatar by the way. Couldn't find a pic of Fisher getting smashed by Pendlebury?