Worst player in the AFL currently regularly getting a game? (Formerly is Priddis the worst?)

[kaiserchief13]

No one actually mentions anyone but Priddis, Mitchell, Kennedy, Shuey and Gaff therefore the general consensus states he's a top 5 player at your club regardless what I think or you think. Whether that's your Facebook fans, the neck beards on Reddit, media people, commentators, people who attend matches regularly or people on here.

Edit sorry missed NN but top 6 still

That's because he got a lot of possessions in the past and won a Brownlow. Reason why he got lots of possessions = opposition didn't care he got the ball should say it all

 

[Scorpus]

 

[CakeEater]

No he isnt but you guys cant have Mitchell and Priddis in the same side.

Makes the eagles too one paced in the middle.

 

[kaiserchief13]

He gets dropped though so he doesn't count

 

[ep2018]

Brownlow gives him a free pass unfortunately.

And making the GF gave Simpson one too. Looking grim at West coast unfortunately.

 

[Deep]

That's because he got a lot of possessions in the past and won a Brownlow. Reason why he got lots of possessions = opposition didn't care he got the ball should say it all

Not disagreeing with your points but Suban, Stanley & Mackay get games regularly.

 

[Scorpus]

He gets dropped though so he doesn't count

He's played 12 of 15 games this season and has played at least 19 games a season for the past 5 seasons.

He's regularly getting a game

 

[kaiserchief13]

Not disagreeing with your points but Suban, Stanley & Mackay get games regularly.

They all get dropped

 

[Damon_3388]

I'm also struggling to see what Matt Rosa offers these days, to continue get a regular game for the Suns. Just chippy-chippy bullshit disposals, barely tackles, and hasn't kicked a goal this year.

 

[kaiserchief13]

I'm also struggling to see what Matt Rosa offers these days, to continue get a regular game for the Suns. Just chippy-chippy bullshit disposals, barely tackles, and hasn't kicked a goal this year.

Yeah he's no good. If you're gonna be an outside player you gotta have either speed, excellent disposal or stamina with above average disposal. Seems Rosa has none of those

 

[Deep]

Bring back Michael Braun

 

[The Joker]

Honestly he is so shit - can't run, can't kick, can't tackle which he could do in the past, can't win the ball which he also could do in the past.

He does not have 1 strength in his game anymore, yet still gets picked each game.

There has been ongoing discussion for years on the WC board about him, but now I ask other teams fans is he currently the worst player in the AFL regularly getting a game?

If not him then who?

According to some of you ****s he shouldnt have been in the side the year he won the Brownlow, so I don't know how to take anything from you guys!

Besides the guy you are searching for if Chris Masten!

 

[kaiserchief13]

According to some of you ****s he shouldnt have been in the side the year he won the Brownlow so I don't know how to take anything from you guys!

Besides the guy you are searching for if Chris Masten!

Well Masten is finally dropped now so he can't be in the discussion. Could've been in the past

 

[largebus]

OP clearly doesn't understand. He's the 2015 brownlow winner, he can play as long as he wants
Also Sam Butler is worse

 

[Damon_3388]

He gets dropped though so he doesn't count

He's played 12 of 15 games this season and has played at least 19 games a season for the past 5 seasons.

He's regularly getting a game

Got given a four-year contract when nobody was chasing him, just for being a good trainer and solid citizen with a sensible haircut. Still contracted until the end of 2018 too.

 

[calyam]

Josh Green by the length of the Tullamarine tarmac.

I want to defend him but this seems reasonable.

 

[coniglio_number1]

Swap ya sam Reid for him

 

[kaiserchief13]

Swap ya sam Reid for him

Where do I sign?

 

[Beutbrute]

Honestly he is so shit - can't run, can't kick, can't tackle which he could do in the past, can't win the ball which he also could do in the past.

He does not have 1 strength in his game anymore, yet still gets picked each game.

There has been ongoing discussion for years on the WC board about him, but now I ask other teams fans is he currently the worst player in the AFL regularly getting a game?

If not him then who?

It's a bit rich to say he can't tackle anymore considering he had the most tackles for any Eagles player today. He's averaging more disposals/Contested disposals per game this year than Viney, Cochin, Ziebell... they can't win the footy either?

He's not flashy and does most of his work at the coalface, so the casual observer might not realise his value.

His lack of pace is an issue but he's hardly the worst player in the afl getting a game. Probably should have kept this post for Priddis thread on our board

 

[Scorpus]

Got given a four-year contract when nobody was chasing him, just for being a good trainer and solid citizen with a sensible haircut. Still contracted until the end of 2018 too.

His contract is a source of outrage among Crows supporters. Just outrageous list management.

 

[Damon_3388]

I want to defend him but this seems reasonable.

Ticks all the boxes - Fat, lazy, and shit.

 

[Damon_3388]

His contract is a source of outrage among Crows supporters. Just outrageous list management.

If I didn't know better, going by his appearance (the term "twink" comes to mind), I would think he's somebody at the club's boy toy.

Seriously though, just sends a message that you accept mediocrity if that's the type of player you feel is necessary to lock in long-term.

 

[LeverPuller]

Sam Kerridge
Mitch Honeychurch
Scott Thompson
Dion Prestia

That's from this weekend off the top of my head

 

[kaiserchief13]

Sam Kerridge
Mitch Honeychurch
Scott Thompson
Dion Prestia

That's from this weekend off the top of my head

Only regular there is Prestia unless you're referring to North Thompson?

 

[Aussie_boy]

Archie Smith, close thread