Would Carlton accept?

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Would Carlton accept Harris and our first pick for Murphy and their second pick?

Carlton have plenty of mids, but could do with a genuine extractor like Harris.

Where do you people get this shit from?

Why would Carlton do that?

And Judd wins more contested possessions that any other player in the comp, so I reckon they've got a "genuine extractor" already.

 

[Jimthegreat]

Would Carlton accept Harris and our first pick for Murphy and their second pick?

Carlton have plenty of mids, but could do with a genuine extractor like Harris.

I think you take a lotto ticket. You'd have more chance.

 

[sinepari]

He is going to be a great player, but nothing special..

Huh? Which one?

A great player? Or nothing special?

Surely you can't be a 'nothing special great player'?

 

[Optus Penguin]

Huh? Which one?

A great player? Or nothing special?

Surely you can't be a 'nothing special great player'?

 

[bluebagger]

Would Carlton accept Harris and our first pick for Murphy and their second pick?

Carlton have plenty of mids, but could do with a genuine extractor like Harris.

Erm, short answer, no. Not a chance in hell. There's no point even speculating what we'd be prepared to trade Murph for, because we simply wouldn't trade him. He's 21, a former no. 1 pick, our leading possession winner and second in the B&F in his third year of footy, and he's only going to get better. Untradeable.

Daniel Harris is a good player, and I've heard he doesn't get along with Laidley and wants out...and we'd be happy to have him down at the club, but I doubt we'd be prepared to offer much for him, let alone Murph.

 

[WCE2012]

would carlton accept C Benjamin for Hacksen + 52??

 

[bluebagger]

If you mean Hansen, absolutely. We are severely lacking in key forward options, so even though Hansen's not a great player, providing a contest from CHF and taking some of the focus off Fev would be enough. WC wouldn't do that deal though

 

[Bluebear]

Would Carlton accept Harris and our first pick for Murphy and their second pick?

Carlton have plenty of mids, but could do with a genuine extractor like Harris.

We have a genuine extractor........several actually.

Why would we give a first rate extractor and our second pick for a dud and your first pick?

 

[ArdentEagle]

If you mean Hansen, absolutely. We are severely lacking in key forward options, so even though Hansen's not a great player, providing a contest from CHF and taking some of the focus off Fev would be enough. WC wouldn't do that deal though

I would, shame I cant do anything about it