Your favourite dud

[Leviathan Pie]

Sean Rusling, turned out a dud only because he couldn't stay on the park. I remember seeing so much hope right there.

Bad shoulders denying you what would have been an incredibly successful career, doesn't justify dud status.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Ryan Lonie kicked some of the most exciting goals in his first couple of seasons.

 

[TradeDraft]

Ryan Lonie kicked some of the most exciting goals in his first couple of seasons.

Sadly he was too Soft.

He had a Lovely Left Foot

 

[dirts]

Clinton King and Frankie Raso got me through some tough times.

 

[35Daicos]

Thought I might find something on Youtube about Tristen Walker. I remember him running through the centre and kicking a massive goal one day. Almost Buddy style. Could have been a praccy match even. I thought he had a bit of talent but alas, no. I was wrong. What he was though was a very nice kid. Made a big impression on my two little ones at training one day.

He didn't kick a lot of goals in his career (just 8) and I always remembered this one against the Bulldogs where he ran around a player and thumped it in from a long way out. Sadly he didn't have too many moments to match this one:

It's about 28.50 in - the picture's pretty ordinary, however.

 

[Pedro]

He didn't kick a lot of goals in his career (just 8) and I always remembered this one against the Bulldogs where he ran around a player and thumped it in from a long way out. Sadly he didn't have too many moments to match this one:

It's about 28.50 in - the picture's pretty ordinary, however.

Could have been the one I was thinking of. Thats some quality find BTW!

 

[TradeDraft]

Could have been the one I was thinking of. Thats some quality find BTW!

He showed some Flashes but Sadly never came as good as those Flashes Showed

 

[mocamagic]

Maybe king went Richmond Collingwood Richmond?
I remember orchard came back a better player from Sydney

Only for his first game back when he played a blinder. Struggled after that

 

[adammania9]

Kirk Ugle

 

[Earl Hickey]

As crazy as it sounds our 02/03 grand final teams were full of players that could meet the criteria. When you think about it, it was obviously a really special effort to get there in consecutive years with the list we had. Sure we had the solid players like Buckley, Burns, Tarrant, Rocca and Licuria but scattered through the team were players like Steinfort, Freeborn and McKee in 02 and then Lokan, Cole, Kinnear and Walker in 03. This is the sort of stuff that makes me proud to be a pies fan, not the best team on paper but full of guts and determination we almost pulled of an amazing victory in 02.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Horaceg]

Bad shoulders denying you what would have been an incredibly successful career, doesn't justify dud status.

I did qualify that

 

[TKiL]

Matthew Ryan in the late 80's.
Big dud.
ALso played with Swans and Bears. Even they did not want him.
When he came on the "seen" he promised so much, buy gee he was crap.

that is extremely "dud" / "crap" SPELLING - "scene" please - presume "buy" is an innocent typo..

 

[raymond35]

I was there the day Tranquilli kicked a bag - from memory most were kicked on Worsfold too.
One of the more bizarre days given how good the Eagles were at the time.

That would explain a lot. Worsfold was a VERY ordinary footballer.