Prediction Your Phantom Draft top 25

[Rors]

Those that are keen, feel free to add your phantom top 25

Here's mine:

Pick 1 - Ess - Andrew McGrath
Pick 2 - GWS - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 3 - GC - Jack Bowes (Brisbane bid)
Pick 4 - Bris - Hugh McCluggage
Pick 5 - Carl - Will Brodie
Pick 6 - GC - Tim Taranto
Pick 7 - Frem - Tim English
Pick 8 - GWS - Will Setterfield (Gold Coast bid)
Pick 9 - GC - Jack Scrimshaw
Pick 10 - Syd - Griffen Logue
Pick 11 - GC - Dan Venables
Pick 12 - GWS - Harry Perryman (Norf bid)
Pick 13 - NM - Jarrod Berry
Pick 14 - WCE - Sam Petrevski-Seton
Pick 15 - Adel - Will Hayward
Pick 16 - PA - Alex Witherden
Pick 17 - Bris - Jy Simpkin
Pick 18 - PA - Shai Bolton
Pick 19 - WB - Josh Rotham
Pick 20 - Syd - Sam Powell-Pepper
Pick 21 - Ess - Todd Marshall
Pick 22 - Bris - Luke Ryan
Pick 23 - Bris - Jordan Galluci
Pick 24 - STKILDA - OLIVER FLORENT
Pick 25 - GC - Brad Scheer (Geelong bid)

Anyway, there's my crack at it. Please feel free to use this OP as a template to do your own.

 

[Mav2Membrey]

Pick 1 - Ess - Andrew McGrath
Pick 2 - GWS - Hugh McCluggage
Pick 3 - GC - Jack Bowes (Brisbane bid)
Pick 4 - Bris - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 5 - Carl - Sam Petrevski-Seton
Pick 6 - GC - Tim English
Pick 7 - Frem - Will Brodie
Pick 8 - GC - Tim Taranto
Pick 9 - GWS Will Setterfield (Sydney bid)
Pick 10 - Syd - Griffen Logue
Pick 11 - GC - Jack Scrimshaw
Pick 12 - GWS - Harry Perryman (NM bid)
Pick 13 - NM - Oliver Florent
Pick 14 - WCE - Jarrod Berry
Pick 15 - Adel - Jack Graham
Pick 16 - PA - Will Hayward
Pick 17 - Bris - Dan Venables
Pick 18 - PA - Jordan Gallucci
Pick 19 - WB - Todd Marshall
Pick 20 - Syd - Josh Rotham
Pick 21 - Ess - Josh Battle
Pick 22 - Bris - Sam Powell-Pepper
Pick 23 - Bris - Alex Witherden
Pick 24 - STKILDA - Jy Simpkin
Pick 25 - Coll - Callum Brown (Geelong bid)

 

[Left_Billings]

Pick 1 - Ess - Andrew Mcgrath
Pick 2 - GWS - Hugh Mcluggage
Pick 3 - Bris - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 4 - GC - Tim Taranto
Pick 5 - GC - Jack Bowes(Carlton Bid)
Pick 6 - GWS - Will Setterfield(Carlton Bid)
Pick 7 - Carl - Will Brodie
Pick 8 - Frem - Tim English
Pick 9 - GC - Sam Petreski-Seton
Pick 10 - Syd - Griffen Logue
Pick 11 - GC - Jack Scrimshaw
Pick 12 - NM - Oliver Florent
Pick 13 - WC - Sam Powell-Pepper
Pick 14 - GWS -Harry Perryman (Adel Bid)
Pick 15 - Adel - Will Hayward
Pick 16 - PA - Dan Venebles
Pick 17 - Bris - Jarrod Berry
Pick 18 - PA - Jy Simpkin
Pick 19 - WB - Todd Marshall
Pick 20 - Syd - Shai Bolton
Pick 21 - GC - Brad Scheer (Ess Bid)
Pick 22 - Ess - Luke Ryan
Pick 23 - Bris - Jordan Galluci
Pick 24 - Bris - Josh Rotham
Pick 25 - Stk - Alex Witherden (Please)

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

This just backs up what Ghost mentioned in another thread. It is so even through the teens and 20's that we might not be sure who we will get with both 23 and 36. We'll have our board and our list and literally tick them off as we go through the count. It kind of makes it exciting I guess...

It wouldn't surprise me if we see a number of clubs take more time with their picks as they find players available who they might not have thought would be at their pick....

 

[Rors]

This just backs up what Ghost mentioned in another thread. It is so even through the teens and 20's that we might not be sure who we will get with both 23 and 36. We'll have our board and our list and literally tick them off as we go through the count. It kind of makes it exciting I guess...

It wouldn't surprise me if we see a number of clubs take more time with their picks as they find players available who they might not have thought would be at their pick....

Hopefully I can see 'the list' before it all starts

 

[Dr Spaceman]

Hopefully I can see 'the list' before it all starts

Tony's waiting on your call

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

Hopefully I can see 'the list' before it all starts

You had better or don't even think of showing your face around here!!

 

[L_W_P]

Pick 1 - Ess - Hugh McLuggage
Pick 2 - GWS - Andy McGrath
Pick 3 - GC - Jack Bowes (Brisbane bid)
Pick 4 - Bris - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 5 - Carl - Will Brodie
Pick 6 - GC - Sam Petrovski-Seton
Pick 7 - Frem - Tim Taranto
Pick 8 - GC - Jack Scrimshaw
Pick 9 - GWS Will Setterfield (Sydney bid)
Pick 10 - Syd - Griffen Logue
Pick 11 - GC - Jarrod Berry
Pick 12 - GWS - Harry Perryman (NM bid)
Pick 13 - NM - Oliver Florent
Pick 14 - WCE - Sam Powell-Pepper
Pick 15 - Adel - Jy Simpkin
Pick 16 - PA - Will Hayward
Pick 17 - Bris - Brad Scheer (GC don't match)
Pick 18 - PA - Jordan Gallucci
Pick 19 - WB - Tim English
Pick 20 - Syd - Daniel Venables
Pick 21 - Ess - Lachlan Tiziani
Pick 22 - Bris - Todd Marshall
Pick 23 - Bris - Alex Witherden
Pick 24 - STKILDA - Josh Rotham
Pick 25 - Geel - Kobe Mutch (GWS don't match)


Tipping English to slide ala Brodie Grundy and for a few bids to be passed over early. Wanted something a little different in there

 

[StCicatriz]

Here's my wishlist preferences (not necessarily how i see it playing out though), positions are where I see them playing for us:
1) Will Brodie INSIDE MID
2) Sam Petrevski-Seton HFF
3) Jack Scrimshaw UTILITY
4) Griffin Logue KPD
5) Andrew McGrath OUTSIDE MID
6) Jy Simpkin OUTSIDE MID
7) Sam Powell-Pepper INSIDE MID/HFF
8) Shai Bolton OUTSIDE MID/HFF
9) Alex Witherden HBF
10) Zac Fisher OUTSIDE MID
11) Josh Battle KPF
12) Jordan Ridley KPD/UTILITY
13) Josh Rotham UTILITY/3rd TALL DEFENDER
14) Harrison McCreadie KPD
15) Brennan Cox KPD
16) Todd Marshall KPF
17) Hugh McCluggage INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
18) Harry Perryman* OUTSIDE MID
19) Jack Bowes* INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
20) Tim English RUCK
21) Will Setterfield* INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
22) Jarrod Berry INSIDE MID
23) Daniel Venables INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID/HFF
24) Will Hayward HFF
25) Jake Waterman KPF

 

[saintsrfreak]

Here's my wishlist preferences (not necessarily how i see it playing out though), positions are where I see them playing for us:
1) Will Brodie INSIDE MID
2) Sam Petrevski-Seton HFF
3) Jack Scrimshaw UTILITY
4) Griffin Logue KPD
5) Andrew McGrath OUTSIDE MID
6) Jy Simpkin OUTSIDE MID
7) Sam Powell-Pepper INSIDE MID/HFF
8) Shai Bolton OUTSIDE MID/HFF
9) Alex Witherden HBF
10) Zac Fisher OUTSIDE MID
11) Josh Battle KPF
12) Jordan Ridley KPD/UTILITY
13) Josh Rotham UTILITY/3rd TALL DEFENDER
14) Harrison McCreadie KPD
15) Brennan Cox KPD
16) Todd Marshall KPF
17) Hugh McCluggage INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
18) Harry Perryman* OUTSIDE MID
19) Jack Bowes* INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
20) Tim English RUCK
21) Will Setterfield* INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID
22) Jarrod Berry INSIDE MID
23) Daniel Venables INSIDE/OUTSIDE MID/HFF
24) Will Hayward HFF
25) Jake Waterman KPF

Jeez, really not keen on the McClug ey?

 

[StCicatriz]

Jeez, really not keen on the McClug ey?

nah, having said that i dont get to see any of the TAC Cup. so take my opinion with a grain of salt, i also love the WA Kids who i do get to see

but yeh not really fan

worst year to have the number 1 pick in a while i reckon

 

[JG22]

nah, having said that i dont get to see any of the TAC Cup. so take my opinion with a grain of salt, i also love the WA Kids who i do get to see

but yeh not really fan

worst year to have the number 1 pick in a while i reckon

Hilarious.
Kids a ****ing jet.

People just bored of him as he's been touted no1 for months.

 

[saintsrfreak]

nah, having said that i dont get to see any of the TAC Cup. so take my opinion with a grain of salt, i also love the WA Kids who i do get to see

but yeh not really fan

worst year to have the number 1 pick in a while i reckon

But hey, was watching Liam Ryan's video on the draft machine, you were right about him being a human highlight reel. Reminds me so much of Jurrah, just without a machete. You'd reckon he could end up being a bit better in the forward line than Minch or Wright, and should still be able to give us that manic pressure if he develops a decent tank.

 

[StCicatriz]

But hey, was watching Liam Ryan's video on the draft machine, you were right about him being a human highlight reel. Reminds me so much of Jurrah, just without a machete. You'd reckon he could end up being a bit better in the forward line than Minch or Wright, and should still be able to give us that manic pressure if he develops a decent tank.

his leap is utterly insane. i cant remember seeing anything like it

he's basically gone from country footy to being in draft calculations inside 6 months. just insane.

he's also only 19!!!!

he's a natural fwd pocket. where as i think wright and minch are more midfield prospects that have ended up in a small fwd role

the issue with liam ryan is his size and ability to apply defencive pressure. he does offer something we dont have though

 

[StCicatriz]

Hilarious.
Kids a ******* jet.

People just bored of him as he's been touted no1 for months.

you're probably right and youve probably seen him a lot more than me...

but look at this way, we aren't going to get him, so wouldnt it be amazing if i'm right and we find a better prospect further down the draft order?

 

[JG22]

you're probably right and youve probably seen him a lot more than me...

but look at this way, we aren't going to get him, so wouldnt it be amazing if i'm right and we find a better prospect further down the draft order?

Just what people want to hear!
Not what's realistic

 

[StCicatriz]

Just what people want to hear!
Not what's realistic

i have said 3 times already that i havent seen him much so take it lightly... so to then question the realism of it, is a bit bizarre given I already stated its not realistic

given your reaction I would argue that people want to hear that McCluggage is a good player and a top 3 prospect, to argue against that probably isnt what people want to hear!

anyways like i said I wouldnt take what i posted too seriously

 

[BrianSpeaking]

This is as good a place to post as any so thought I you should know I had a chat to someone at the club who may have been a fish in his past life.

He tells me there is a distinct top 6 ish, then half a step down another 30 blokes who could go anywhere from 7 to 40 ish. We are more than confident we will get two players we rate 7-20 with our two first picks based on whispers and player manager feedback.

Depending on bids etc he also thinks we get a top 35 player with our third pick, so will be interesting to see how it pans out, he's very bullish on where we are positioned.

 

[StCicatriz]

This is as good a place to post as any so thought I you should know I had a chat to someone at the club who may have been a fish in his past life.

He tells me there is a distinct top 6 ish, then half a step down another 30 blokes who could go anywhere from 7 to 40 ish. We are more than confident we will get two players we rate 7-20 with our two first picks based on whispers and player manager feedback.

Depending on bids etc he also thinks we get a top 35 player with our third pick, so will be interesting to see how it pans out, he's very bullish on where we are positioned.

The trout is circling

 

[Highlander35]

Quack

 

[Mighty_sainter]

1.Essendon) Andrew McGrath

2Gws) Tim taranto

3Lions)Hugh mcclug

4Gold coast) Ben Ainsworth

5Carlton). Sam petrevski seton

6Gold coast) will Brodie

7Fremantle-griffin logue

8Gold coast) jack scrimshaw

9Sydney) Jy Simpkin

10Gc) jack bowes

11North) Oliver Florent

12WCE) Jarrod berry

13Adelaide) will hayward

14Port) Alex witherden

15gws) setterfield

16Lions) Venebals

17Port) Todd marshal

18Dogs) tim english

19Sydney) Jordan galluci

20Essendon) josh battle

21Lions) Ridley

22Lions) Sam Powell pepper

23Saints) shai bolton


My early phantom draft, what you guys think?

 

[Louis Slungpue]

Pick 1 Essendon - drew Petrie
Pick 2 GWS - andy McGrath
Pick 3 lions - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 4 gc - Bowes
Pick 5 Carlton - robin nahas
Pick 6 gc - Brodie
Pick 7 freo - pass
Pick 8 gc - scrimshaw
Pick 9 Syd - Simpkin
Pick 10 gc - berry
Pick 11 norf - venables
Pick 12 wce - witherden
Pick 13 Adelaide - battle
Pick 14 port - Marshall
Pick 15 gws - setterfield
Pick 16 lions - venables
Pick 17 port - English
Pick 18 dogs - Bolton
Pick 19 Syd - florent
Pick 20 Ess - burrito
Pick 21 lions - Kerr
Pick 22 lions - spp
Pick 23 St kilda - long

 

[Loyal Sainter]

Pick 1 Essendon - drew Petrie
Pick 2 GWS - andy McGrath
Pick 3 lions - Ben Ainsworth
Pick 4 gc - Bowes
Pick 5 Carlton - robin nahas
Pick 6 gc - Brodie
Pick 7 freo - pass
Pick 8 gc - scrimshaw
Pick 9 Syd - Simpkin
Pick 10 gc - berry
Pick 11 norf - venables
Pick 12 wce - witherden
Pick 13 Adelaide - battle
Pick 14 port - Marshall
Pick 15 gws - setterfield
Pick 16 lions - venables
Pick 17 port - English
Pick 18 dogs - Bolton
Pick 19 Syd - florent
Pick 20 Ess - burrito
Pick 21 lions - Kerr
Pick 22 lions - spp
Pick 23 St kilda - mcluggage

"Freo- pass" Hahahahaaaa Ahh Choom.. I mean Louis you funny bugger

 

[CALL ME SNAKE]

Well thats my 'Phantom Draft"

 

[Barrels]

View attachment 312912 View attachment 312913
Well thats my ''Phantom Draft"