Your Team Vs Melbourne

[BILC]

Ill Get The Ball Rolling...

B: Mcguane Moore Rance
HB: Newman Thursfield Polo
C: Jackson Deledio Richo
HF: Morton Hughes Connors
FF: Brown Riewoldt White
Foll: Simmonds Foley Tuck
Int: Coughlan Collins Pattison Nahas
Emg: Bowden Graham Schulz

 

[Drunken Wookie]

B: Mcguane Thursfield Newman
HB: Rance Moore Polo
C: Jackson Deledio Richo
HF: Morton Riewoldt Connors
FF: Brown Hughes Collins
Foll: Simmonds Foley Tuck
Int: White Coughlan Graham Nahas
Emg: Thomson Pattison Schulz

Pretty similar thinking.

 

[Barnzy]

Pointless thread. No amount of posting the team that should play is going make it happen. We all know TW is going to bring in McMahon for King and that's about it.

 

[W. Smithers]

B: McGuane Thursfield Polo
HB: Rance Moore Newman
C: White Deledio Richo
HF: Morton Riewoldt Connors
FF: Nahas Post Collins
Foll: Vickery Foley Tuck
Int: JON Coughlan Graham Thomson
Emg: Gourdis Pattison Jackson

 

[Drunken Wookie]

Pointless thread. No amount of posting the team that should play is going make it happen. We all know TW is going to bring in McMahon for King and that's about it.

I don't think Wallace and Co. pay much attention to any of these threads mate. So in line with that thinking I guess they're all pointless.

 

[getthefooty]

^Exactly.

 

[nufan_tigers]

Ill Get The Ball Rolling...

B: Mcguane Moore Rance
HB: Newman Thursfield Polo
C: Jackson Deledio Richo
HF: Morton Hughes Connors
FF: Brown Riewoldt White
Foll: Simmonds Foley Tuck
Int: Coughlan Collins Pattison Nahas
Emg: Bowden Graham Schulz

Thursfield still probably still a few weeks in the ressies away, listened to a bit of the game from the VFL and didn't hear too much about him. Don't know who he would come in for either... probably have to be Rance or Bowden and I don't think either of them deserves to be dropped as Bowden was one of the few who's tackles were sticking and Rance has shown guts and talent.

Hughes would be a surprise inclusion for me, he played in the VFL reserves and only managed 2 goals, with Gourdis booting 5 in front of him. I think fitness is the issue for him, he will be back to the main Burgers line up this week and could get a gig against North should Schulz fail.

Connors Again I think fitness will be the issue for Connors, hasn't had enough game time to warrant a return to the seniors, Nahas will be more likely than him after his 5 goals, or Collins on a flank

Coughlin Love to see him in the side, didn't hear his name too often in the VFL but hear from other reports that he played well. Would be useful and no better team than Melbourne to give him a run against.

Collins Had a great game from all reports kicking 4 and goal kicking midfielders.. well goal kickers is what we need, should def get a game.

Pattison I am a big Graham fan and he did a servicible job in the Ruck but didn't do anything around the ground, so Patto should get the recall, he can be used up forward and is arguably better than Angus in the ruck.

Nahas He will come back in for bling i believe, puts in a big effort and when forward can kick goals.. needs to stay in the forward line for the big bomb in so he can be damaging.

Not a bad line up but a few i'd be surprised with. I could see McMahon getting a recall unfortunately after a decent game in the VFL and possbly JON who was best on ground with high kicking efficiency.

 

[Barnzy]

I don't think Wallace and Co. pay much attention to any of these threads mate. So in line with that thinking I guess they're all pointless.

Merely pointing out that TW has no clue and will just bring in McMahon (shit kick) for another which is not solving the problem. Don't take it so personal, Slick.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

B: Newman, Moore, Polo
HB: Bowden, McGuane, Rance
C: Deledio, Tuck, Collins
HF: Brown, Richardson, White
F: Morton, Schulz, Riewoldt
Foll: Simmonds, Tambling, Foley
Interchange: Jackson, Coughlan, Nahas, Pattison

IN: Pattison, Nahas, Coughlan, Collins
OUT: Graham, King, Hislop, Edwards

Thursty misses due to the Melbourne forward line not being very tall..

Hughes doesn't deserve a game.

Conners isn't fit enough.

 

[hognogger]

Just grab 22 toothless drunks from the stands, throw a jumper on them, and be done with it.

 

[coke_zero]

Nahas He will come back in for bling i believe, puts in a big effort and when forward can kick goals.. needs to stay in the forward line for the big bomb in so he can be damaging.

we need nahas back, just so we have someone to crumb when the ball is bombed in forward, often we are out numberd and it's 2v3 and both our guys go up, and only one from the other team then the ball falls to ground and they just run away with it.

 

[The Cotch]

This would be an oppurtunistic time to release the Goo in my opinion. Coming off a five goal haul, give him a run at FF and see what he can do......

 

[rfctigerarmy]

He's a rookie though... would we be able to elevate him? I don't think so.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Ill Get The Ball Rolling...

B: Mcguane Moore Rance
HB: Newman Thursfield Polo
C: Jackson Deledio Richo
HF: Morton Hughes Connors
FF: Brown Riewoldt White
Foll: Simmonds Foley Tuck
Int: Coughlan Collins Pattison Nahas
Emg: Bowden Graham Schulz

i like the look of this team. There is not 1 single dud. Come on Terry listen to us. I'd have Thursty at FB and Rance at CHB and swap Moore with Newman. You probably need Newmans skill deep in defence and keep him close to goal for the kick ins

 

[The Cotch]

IN: Connors Collins Pattison Nahas Coughlan Thursfield Thomson
OUT: Bowden Edwards King Schulz Graham Hislop Tambling

FB: Newman Thursfield McGuane
HB: Moore Rance Polo
C: White Foley Collins
HF: Morton Richardson Connors
FF: Brown Riewoldt Nahas
R: Simmonds Deledio Coughlan
INT: Thomson Jackson Tuck Pattison

 

[beaver's army]

In: Nahas Patto Cogs Collins Thomson
Out: Tambling King Graham Hislop Edwards

 

[krustyman]

Team:
B: Newman, Moore, Polo
HB: Bowden, McGuane, Rance
C: Deledio, Tuck, White
HF: Brown, Richardson, Collins
F: Morton, Schulz, Riewoldt
Foll: Simmonds,Coughlan , Foley
Interchange: Jackson, Graham, King, Mcmahon

Emg. JON, Thursfield, Hislop
IN: Coughlan, Collins, Thursfield, Mcmahon, JON
OUT: Tambling, Hislop, Edwards

king - move to wing/forward out of backline, shows more heart than others, backline looked ok except for his turnovers
Collins - start up forward to ease him in
Mcmahon - used with brown in the midfield/HFF rotation
JON - emergency for next month or two. (then bring him in for dreamtime at the G game, Edwards & Tambling to miss out unless they show something)
Thursfield - probably not needed as demons dont have any decent forwards.
Hislop - emrg incase cogs has injury before the game

 

[_RT_]

B: Newman Thursfield Rance
HB: Moore McGuane Polo
C: White Deledio Richardson
HF: Riewoldt Pattison Morton
F: Brown Schulz Nahas
R: Simmonds Tuck Foley
I: Graham Jackson Coughlan Thomson

Ins - Coughlan Pattison Thomson Nahas Thursfield
Outs - Tambling Bowden Hislop Edwards King

 

[BILC]

Pointless thread. No amount of posting the team that should play is going make it happen. We all know TW is going to bring in McMahon for King and that's about it.

No1s forcing you to read this thread if you dont like it mate

 

[BILC]

Thursfield still probably still a few weeks in the ressies away, listened to a bit of the game from the VFL and didn't hear too much about him. Don't know who he would come in for either... probably have to be Rance or Bowden and I don't think either of them deserves to be dropped as Bowden was one of the few who's tackles were sticking and Rance has shown guts and talent.

Hughes would be a surprise inclusion for me, he played in the VFL reserves and only managed 2 goals, with Gourdis booting 5 in front of him. I think fitness is the issue for him, he will be back to the main Burgers line up this week and could get a gig against North should Schulz fail.

Connors Again I think fitness will be the issue for Connors, hasn't had enough game time to warrant a return to the seniors, Nahas will be more likely than him after his 5 goals, or Collins on a flank

Coughlin Love to see him in the side, didn't hear his name too often in the VFL but hear from other reports that he played well. Would be useful and no better team than Melbourne to give him a run against.

Collins Had a great game from all reports kicking 4 and goal kicking midfielders.. well goal kickers is what we need, should def get a game.

Pattison I am a big Graham fan and he did a servicible job in the Ruck but didn't do anything around the ground, so Patto should get the recall, he can be used up forward and is arguably better than Angus in the ruck.

Nahas He will come back in for bling i believe, puts in a big effort and when forward can kick goals.. needs to stay in the forward line for the big bomb in so he can be damaging.

Not a bad line up but a few i'd be surprised with. I could see McMahon getting a recall unfortunately after a decent game in the VFL and possbly JON who was best on ground with high kicking efficiency.

id love gourdis to be in ahead of cleve but hes a rookie

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Please lets start looking to the future :

- Nahas is to small to lay tackles on reasonably sized players, maybe we need to start looking at a White to fill this position as he won't get a gig in the mid-field if and when Cousins, Cotch and Coghlan return yet does have reasonable speed and tackling ability.
- Vickery appears a long way off.
- Hughes played 2's in the VFL over the weekend and wasn't our 2's best forward.
- Graham has shown the most promise as a possible ruckman and has improved in the past two weeks, its about time the club looked to the developement of players.
- Connors : the report coming out of the weekends game is that his attitude is a long way off what is needed to play AFL, the club doesn't need another who needs work between their ears representing its senior side.

 

[one eyedtiger]

Ins: Coughlan, Collins, Patto, Hughes, Thomson and Nahas.
Out: King, Tambling, Hislop, Gus, Schulz and Edwards.

B: Newman McGuane Rance
HB: Polo Moore Bowden
C: Richo Tuck Jackson
HF: White Riewoldt Morton
FF: Brown Hughes Nahas
R: Simmonds Deledio Foley
I: Coughlan, Collins, Pattison, Thomson
Emerg: Thursfield, JON, Connors.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

B - Newman Moore Thurstfield
HB - Polo McGaunne Schulz
C - Richardson Tuck Rance
HF - Brown Reiwoldt White
F - Collins Pattison Morton

Foll - Simmonds Lids Foley

Bench - Graham Coghlan Thompson Jackson

Out -
King - When you actually hit 50% or better of your targets in the centre corridor you will be considered.
Tambling - When you actually win 12 possesions per game for 3 weeks in a row, that are in dispute, you will be considered, start running through packs rather than around them. 4 tackles per game minimum
Hislop - Re - King
Bowden - Re - Bling
Edwards - Re Bling

In - Collins, Thompson, Coghlan, Pattison, Thurstfield

 

[Darth_Tiger]

B - Newman Moore Rance
HB - Polo McGaunne Hislop
C - Richardson Tuck White
HF - Brown Reiwoldt Bowden
F - Collins Oakley-Nichols Morton

Foll - Simmonds Lids Foley

Bench - Pattison Coghlan Jackson Tambling

Out -
King - his omission alone should make us good for 3 or 4 goals against less than if he was playing. Out - forever.
Graham - ruck comes in ruck goes out bad luck.
Edwards - find some form son
Schulz - times up, did not perform in the first three weeks so back to the burgers.
In - Collins, Coghlan, Pattison, Oakley-Nichols (but we all know mcmahon will likely play in place of cogs).
i wouldnt make more than four changes, if you change the team too much it can have a negative effect.