I am saying Hodge inspires his team mates to get the most out of themselves...... Judd doesn't do this at Carlton!
Total waffle. I reckon if Hodge had come to Carlton instead of Judd, we wouldn't have even achieved what we have.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I am saying Hodge inspires his team mates to get the most out of themselves...... Judd doesn't do this at Carlton!
No. Not just footskills. I've already gone through it.I reckon you're stuck on the idea of foot skills here. Judd has his own skill set, which has contributed to him being the better player over the journey.
Hodge's skill level exceeds Judd's.
Judd's main skill is winning the inside ball and breaking away from a pack. He is a line breaker. He is not what I would describe as an overly great kick, he's not a particularly good mark, average 1 on 1, and not particularly versatile.
Not sure how, anyone could rate Judd as having a higher skill level than Hodge, considering his ability to play anywhere on the ground and be a dominant player.
Just stop Echols
Your embarrassing yourself mate!
Judd is an average one-on-one footballer? Are you serious?
That's all he does is beat his opponent and has done since his very first season of league football. He's also had a tag throughout most of his career and has still beaten them.
One of the all time greatest footballers and you've obviously missed most of his career for whatever personal reasons.
No. Not just footskills. I've already gone through it.
Hodge is a more skilled and versatile player than Judd, it's just that Judd's trick is a very good one(inside midfielder with breakaway pace).
You don't see Judd one out with an opponent to beat in the back half, ala Hodge.
No. Not just footskills. I've already gone through it.
Hodge is a more skilled and versatile player than Judd, it's just that Judd's trick is a very good one(inside midfielder with breakaway pace).
I doubt he'd care.Too bad for Hodge that Judd's 'trick' is in fact so good that it makes him a better player, despite Hodge being more skilful and more versatile, eh?
I doubt he'd care.
That's not what I was saying at all.Of course he wouldn't. I was simply calling you out on your amusingly conspicuous attempt to imply that Judd is one-dimensional.
One things for certainTotal waffle. I reckon if Hodge had come to Carlton instead of Judd, we wouldn't have even achieved what we have.
One things for certain
You'd be arguing for a different bloke
I think you just hate Luke Hodge mate., judging by the effort your putting in in every thread with his name in the title.I hate Judd and even more, I hate Carlton. With that said, I am genuinely embarrassed for those arguing that Hodge is better.
No, Judd is just a way better footballer.I think you just hate Luke Hodge mate., judging by the effort your putting in in every thread with his name in the title.
No, Judd is just a way better footballer.
7 years ago
Apparently if you don't think Hodge is better than Don Bradman you are a "hodge hater"I think you just hate Luke Hodge mate., judging by the effort your putting in in every thread with his name in the title.
No not really.Apparently if you don't think Hodge is better than Don Bradman you are a "hodge hater"
It's not obsessive considering that at the time of my posting the top 3 threads on the polls are Luke Hodge v X. It's also not obsessive to disagree with the view that Luke Hodge is better than Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell or Michael Voss. At the moment there are deluded Hawks supporters dominating this board, making anyone who thinks Hodge is not better than Mandela out to be criminals.No not really.
But if your not affiliated with Hawthorn or the comparison team, yet your in every Hodge thread obsessively and constantly comparing him to players clearly inferior then yeah, you are.
He's a HOF lock, so your biased efforts will be in vain.
Judd won a brownlow at carlton.Plus he has 2 norm smith's and 3 premiership medals around his neck. Not to mention a better looking wife .
What has Judd done since coming to Carlton ? I don't even see him doing Visy ambassadorial work these days.
So true. I might make a poll, hodge vs fyfe pendlebury ablett and selwood. The hawks supporters would still find some excuse as to why theyd have hodge over them.It's not obsessive considering that at the time of my posting the top 3 threads on the polls are Luke Hodge v X. It's also not obsessive to disagree with the view that Luke Hodge is better than Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell or Michael Voss. At the moment there are deluded Hawks supporters dominating this board, making anyone who thinks Hodge is not better than Mendella out to be criminals.
Also, I argue that Hodge is overrated because of the players he is compared to. I don't know how being a lock for HOF enters into this, to bring it up is absurd.
It's not obsessive considering that at the time of my posting the top 3 threads on the polls are Luke Hodge v X. It's also not obsessive to disagree with the view that Luke Hodge is better than Chris Judd, Sam Mitchell or Michael Voss. At the moment there are deluded Hawks supporters dominating this board, making anyone who thinks Hodge is not better than Mendella out to be criminals.
Also, I argue that Hodge is overrated because of the players he is compared to. I don't know how being a lock for HOF enters into this, to bring it up is absurd.