- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,445
- 28,083
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Who would be in out of Bruce and Kennedy? Both are full forwards aren't they?
Which CHFs have been playing well?
Which CHFs have been playing well?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He flogged Hooker then played on Hurley for a quarter.. no curryBruce gave Hurley some curry yesterday...
Incorrect.Bruce gave Hurley some curry yesterday...
Bruce gave Hurley some curry yesterday...
Congratulations on watching 3 games this year, unfortunately that doesn't improve your standing in the slightest. Saying it "wouldn't surprise you" if he drops off suggests you had no idea of his consistency.The good old BigFooty catch phrase 'You don't watch x side' or 'You don't watch football'. Have watched 3 of the 5 Dogs games this year (Rich/Ade/Syd) and I did say Murphy would be in my side. He's a consistently good player sure, but Pendles is arguably top 3 in the AFL. This generally matters when AA captaincy is decided.
By the way, Darren Glass was the captain in 2012 and he wasn't even a top 30 player in the competition.
Tom Harley was vice-captain in 2008 and he wasn't even top 100.
You can argue all you want, but it's clear as daylight that if the AA Team was done now, Murphy would be the unanimous choice among selectors.
In contrast, Pendlebury has been playing against mostly rubbish opposition, and his leadership qualities aren't being pumped up anywhere near as much as Murphy's.
Murphy would be in the 22 atm, with Boyd, Stringer, Dahlhaus & Bonts there abouts for the squad of 40 at the moment. Long season though so hopefully we can get a representative with a couple in the 40 at the end of the year.
Congratulations on watching 3 games this year, unfortunately that doesn't improve your standing in the slightest. Saying it "wouldn't surprise you" if he drops off suggests you had no idea of his consistency.
By the way, Darren Glass was the captain in 2012 and he wasn't even a top 30 player in the competition.
Tom Harley was vice-captain in 2008 and he wasn't even top 100.
Firstly, being a first year captain (Judd 2008
Pendlebury has been playing against mostly rubbish opposition, and his leadership qualities aren't being pumped up anywhere near as much as Murphy's.
Pendles, Fyfe and Goldstein are the most likely so far.
The only two from WC I would consider would be Kennedy and Mcgovern. Amazing given McGovern has played less than 20 matches.
Yeah, McGovern is exceeding my expectations, given the lack of support and that his best is as a CHF. Yet to be beaten and alternated between Cameron and Mccarthy who scored 2 goals total.Kennedy would be in my team, McGovern close..
David Armitage has to be in the discussion, has been A grade this year.
Which CHFs have been playing well?
FB : Tom Mcdonald Jeremy McGovern Robert Murphy
HB: Jasper Pittard Michael Hurley Luke Hodge
C : Dylan Shiel Jordan Lewis Brad Ebert
HF: Josh Bruce Lance Franklin Mark Lecras
FF: Eddie Betts Josh Kennedy Jay Schulz
R: Todd Goldstein Scott Pendlebury Nat Fyfe
I: Bachar Houli David Mundy Robbie Gray Stephen Hill
Luke McPharlin has played on and beaten Schultz, Clark, Kennedy, Franklin & Hogan, 4 of them convincingly. Those players (excluding Schultz because of Rd1) had good lead up games having kicked 20 goals between them, Luke gave the 5 of them 7 goals.
Talk stats all you like but a list like that deserves recognition.