Prediction Dockers Brownlow Votes

[Palmervich]

Mayne might have had a more consistent game, but I'm sure the umpires would have noticed what Fyfe was doing for his moments in the middel and flying up all over the ground. History says the top votes will go the midfielder over a forward, unless it was Mayne kicking 6-7 goals and winning the game for us.

You wouldn't get an argument from me if the umpires gave the votes to Mayne, in fact I would much prefer the umpires to notice those sort of games, the selfless players who do all the hard work to make the players around them look good, like you say though, history shows they don't! Personally I think Fyfes game was probably more important, or more influential to the result, but I can see why others would swing the other way!

 

[beetz]

What's the record for most Brownlow votes in a season?

Surely Fyfe is well on his way to smashing it. Should all things continue to go swimmingly, of course.

 

[Bender571]

What's the record for most Brownlow votes in a season?

Surely Fyfe is well on his way to smashing it. Should all things continue to go swimmingly, of course.

Some seasons didn't use the 3-2-1 system, but for the seasons that did Swan's 34 votes in 2011 is the record.

 

[freo84]

Some seasons didn't use the 3-2-1 system, but for the seasons that did Swan's 34 votes in 2011 is the record.

Fyfe will be past that in 11 games

 

[Seppo]

Maybe just 1 vote for Fyfey this week.

Had Lachie and Clancee ahead of him. Anyone think he might miss out completely?

 

[clivenator26]

Clancee Lachie Pav all in the mix, Goddard could scrape a vote, thought he was pretty good for them.

 

[Lach72]

Ken Judge gave Fyfe the 3 arguing greatest impact. If he kicked the two goals he gets them easily.

 

[Scham]

Ken Judge gave Fyfe the 3 arguing greatest impact. If he kicked the two goals he gets them easily.

I agree with Ken but I highly doubt that the umps would be thinking that way. They need someone to stand out and tonight that was Neale and Goddard and to a lesser extent Mundy. I don't think Fyfe will get a vote.

 

[Palmervich]

Yeah I think he misses, had more impact on the result than most, but Lachie, Clancey and probibly Goddard take the votes!

 

[gaskin]

He gets 2 from me this week. Lachie gets the 3 with one of Clancee or Mundy getting 1.

 

[elsleevador]

Neale 3
Fyfe 2
Pav 1

 

[youmewe]

WA TAB is giving money away.

They have a market for the Brownlow Medal leader after round 5.

Fyfe is paying $1.75. Get on.

 

[Bulldocker]

WA TAB is giving money away.

They have a market for the Brownlow Medal leader after round 5.

Fyfe is paying $1.75. Get on.

Really? That is generous.
Only ones I can think of that may be remotely close to him are Pendles, Shiel and Mundy. But my guess is that not even the sum of their votes by round five would be ahead of the Fyfernator. Unbelievable odds actually.

 

[Wizard]

3. Neale
2. Pavlich
1. Fyfe

No Essendon player should be getting votes, reality is that it was a 10 goal game.

 

[FreoRicci]

Neale and Mundy really will be stealing a fair few votes. We got so many stars. Right now see Fyfe on at 10 votes, with Neale 6 and Mundy 7. Wouldn't be surprised if Danyle gets a few early too, has been influential kicking it forward as well as Hill.

 

[Belnakor]

Some seasons didn't use the 3-2-1 system, but for the seasons that did Swan's 34 votes in 2011 is the record.

34 is an incredible amount means he was BOG for half the games he played that season. That will definitely take some beating.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

Maybe just 1 vote for Fyfey this week.

Had Lachie and Clancee ahead of him. Anyone think he might miss out completely?

Perhaps one vote.
3./ Lachie
2./ Goddard/Fyfe
1./ Fyfe/Goddard

Peter Bell said Nat will probably poll in the game but he personally wouldn't have given him votes.
I think such is the wave of sentiment now he will probably get a vote when he otherwise wouldn't.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

34 is an incredible amount means he was BOG for half the games he played that season. That will definitely take some beating.

Nah, six or seven BOGS and a pile of two's would do it.
By comparison Nat is possibly on 5 bogs now.

 

[gaskin]

There is no way Goddard gets votes Fred. 3/2/1 will be all Freo players.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

There is no way Goddard gets votes Fred. 3/2/1 will be all Freo players.

Would like to think so but goddard was their best IMO.
( maybe one vote )

 

[gaskin]

In a game that we largely dominated until we took our foot off there is no way you can give a vote to any Essendon player.

 

[Mezz]

In both of the two Sunday footy shows, their 3,2,1 votes had Natty with one vote each, and Goddard with the two votes. But I forgot who got the three votes

 

[Seppo]

Fyfe 3, Pav 2 and 1 for Dickson or Johno?

 

[gaskin]

I reckon they'll give Dickson 1 but I'd like to see Johno get it.

 

[Seppo]

I reckon they'll give Dickson 1 but I'd like to see Johno get it.

7 goals is a fair effort from Tory, but Johno was immense down back. I know which way Leigh Fisher will be voting...