Jack Viney part 2: The Appeal

[Heisenberg_]

With the appeal being only hours away and this being such a big issue coupled with the original thread getting way off topic we decided to re-boot it a bit.
Please stick to the topic people and play nice, we know it's a emotive issue but still it's no excuse to post what you want without consequences.

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

For the sake of football I hope he gets off.

That is my opinion on the situation.

 

[NSWCROW]

The vic media since monday

 

[Higgs Boson]

#FreeViney

 

[Heisenberg_]

The vic media since monday

None of this make believe vic media conspiracy theories please

 

[Bluelegs]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-05-08/viney-challenge-live

We're up and going

 

[NSWCROW]

None of this make believe vic media conspiracy theories please

Just sayin......


( cos NO ONE else will )
Can you HONESTLY say you think had the roles been reversed that THIS much hyperbole would've arisen ??

 

[ptrg]

nswcrow, if Viney gets it over turned, would you want to see Adelaide re-appeal? (Due to Lynch having a broken jaw)

 

[ptrg]

Appealing on behalf of all teams, supporters, lovers of AFL:

"It is being claimed the new rough conduct (high bumps) rule is being applied incorrectly in 2014"

 

[FISTO]

Viney should have kept Lynch's jaw after knocking it out of his face.

 

[wowlace]

This is a bump!

 

[NSWCROW]

nswcrow, if Viney gets it over turned, would you want to see Adelaide re-appeal? (Due to Lynch having a broken jaw)

Yep

But we won't

 

[ptrg]

Looks like it's only Adelaide fans (and the rare crazy) who are voting to have the suspension upheld.

6% of votes saying "NO" to setting Viney free, and 1/18 = 5.5555%

NSWCROW, jangofett et al must be getting tired from voting, refreshing cookies, rinse and repeating..

 

[ptrg]

Yep

But we won't

So you have just again said you want him suspended because he broke Lynch's jaw...

 

[NSWCROW]

So you have just again said you want him suspended because he broke Lynch's jaw...

i want him suspended because -

1 - he ELECTED to brace/bump
2 - said brace/bump hit Lynch HIGH
3 - Lynch received a broken jaw.


Pretty " black and white " in my eyes

" duty of care " and all that jazz

 

[Boxhead_31]

Well that's it they are doing frame by frame analysis Viney is screwed

 

[ptrg]

there is multiple posts, from you, saying that he elected to bump and not brace..?

 

[Heisenberg_]

Just sayin......


( cos NO ONE else will )
Can you HONESTLY say you think had the roles been reversed that THIS much hyperbole would've arisen ??

You can say it elsewhere then, because the majority couldn't care less and find it annoying.

 

[Boxhead_31]

i want him suspended because -

1 - he ELECTED to brace/bump
2 - said brace/bump hit Lynch HIGH
3 - Lynch received a broken jaw.


Pretty " black and white " in my eyes

" duty of care " and all that jazz

Why wasn't Lynch suspended for KOing Georgiou then?

 

[Engimal]

Well addressed response

It didn't even deserve a response. If you think a big deal is made because he's from a Victorian club, you're very misguided and making yourself look very silly.

 

[NSWCROW]

Why wasn't Lynch suspended for KOing Georgiou then?

That's just being silly

 

[Kickin_Goals]

With the appeal being only hours away and this being such a big issue coupled with the original thread getting way off topic we decided to re-boot it a bit.
Please stick to the topic people and play nice, we know it's a emotive issue but still it's no excuse to post what you want without consequences.

Why lock a thread that is relevant to current events however old it is.

 

[ptrg]

Just found this:

(Quoted from Article about Trengove's appeal against Tackle)

"But the three man AFL appeal panel -- chairman Peter O'Callagan, QC, Brian Collis, QC, and former Richmond ruckman Michael Green -- quickly announced that Trengove's guilty verdict and three-game suspension would stand."


Nathan Schmook: (Today)
"The Appeals Board consists of Brian Collis, Michael Green and Peter O'Callaghan (chairman)"

 

[iDon]

Why lock a thread that is relevant to current events however old it is.

It gives the thread a fresh start that this appeal needs. We know that depending on the result of the tribunal the thread will generate a lot of responses. It is often done on the MB .

 

[Boxhead_31]

That's just being silly

Why he chose to bump Viney as a result Georgiou was struck in the head by Lynch's head causing him to have to leave the field