- Aug 28, 2015
- 10,857
- 28,852
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #26
Gibson
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Gibson a slightly better party boy. Much more successful footballer
They're both top of the tree in this regard.
Gibson dated a pussycat doll. Puts him in front
Gibson dated a pussycat doll. Puts him in front
Saw Gibson get hit on by a cross dresser at Transport when he was still at North. Neg points.
Gibson clearly the better player and the better career.
I know the popular wisdom amongst Big Footy's resident geniuses is that premierships are "irrelevant" when discussing individuals, but I beg to differ. I'm a firm believer that Josh Gibson's starring role in three premierships would indicate that he's had a better career than Sam Fisher.
That's true. Hudghton was a good defender in his own right. He was a fair bit older though and was very much at the end of his career by the time the Saints were genuine contenders in 2007ish.
Seem to be a few people discounting the first half of their careers. Could argue Gibson has only been better for the last 4 years, and a lot of that has been a no contest with Fisher injured.
From 2005 to 2011 Saint Kilda were consistently among the best defensive teams and Fisher was their best defender. People forget very quickly.
Supercoach scores aren't everything, but they are decent indicator and he was miles ahead.
View attachment 214838
View attachment 214839
This a weird comment imo, Gibson has a much better record 1v1. Fisher when asked to bat above his weight has struggled consistently while Gibson is one of the premier kpb in the comp over the last few years. Against players fisher is more suitable on playing on 3rd tall ect it's much closer.Fisher is a slightly better defender than Gibson 1 on 1, Gibson is superior at the intercept and 3rd man up stuff though. Both guns.