Traded Mabior Chol [Traded with #62 to Hawthorn for F2 (Bris)]

[Makeshift Park]

Chol has been raised as a strong trade possibility by Twomey twice over the past day (on Gettable and SEN).

A KPF/ruck hybrid would have to be one of the more sought after positional needs this off-season.

Only 26 years old, so still young enough to attract a long term offer.

He'll be behind King, Walter, Lukosius, and Casboult next year, so negligible chance of our getting an extended run at it in the seniors for the foreseeable future.

Besides, he's already been traded out of a Hardwick team once already.

On the flipside, the Suns' draft hand is already loaded with picks. So, what gets it done?

 

[AFDogs]

Dogs should ask the question. Could use him if Naughton leaves.

 

[Colonial]

Hmm if cheap. Possible.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Chol has been raised as a strong trade possibility by Twomey twice over the past day (on Gettable and SEN).

A KPF/ruck hybrid would have to be one of the more sought after positional needs this off-season.

Only 26 years old, so still young enough to attract a long term offer.

He'll be behind King, Walter, Lukosius, and Casboult next year, so negligible chance of our getting an extended run at it in the seniors for the foreseeable future.

Besides, he's already been traded out of a Hardwick team once already.

On the flipside, the Suns' draft hand is already loaded with picks. So, what gets it done?

Casboult is almost done, and Walter is a first year player. Chol is definitely needed. Would take overs for the Suns to let him go.

He was excellent last year filling in for King.

 

[Foxman98]

Dogs should ask the question. Could use him if Naughton leaves.

We already have Lobb who is a better forward and ruck as well as Darcy developing in the same role

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

We already have Lobb who is a better forward and ruck as well as Darcy developing in the same role

Agree, another tall doesn't seem a priority for the Dogs, especially with Croft added this year.

You guys should be more interested in Hollands.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Casboult is almost done, and Walter is a first year player. Chol is definitely needed. Would take overs for the Suns to let him go.

He was excellent last year filling in for King.

I think Chol's too good to be playing seconds all the time and Walter will be playing seniors for some of next year.

Casboult's career timeline dovetails perfectly with Walter.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I think Chol's too good to be playing seconds all the time and Walter will be playing seniors for some of next year.

Casboult's career timeline dovetails perfectly with Walter.

Agree about Chol, but he's one injury to King/Witts/Luko/Casboult away from playing regularly next year so the Suns would need some convincing to let him go.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Agree about Chol, but he's one injury to King/Witts/Luko/Casboult away from playing regularly next year so the Suns would need some convincing to let him go.

You got him for an end of 2nd round pick, and bearing in mind you're basically just keeping him as quality depth, how much convincing are you talking?

Guessing futures or pick consolidation/upgrade might be the preference?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

You got him for an end of 2nd round pick, and bearing in mind you're basically just keeping him as quality depth, how much convincing are you talking?

Guessing futures or pick consolidation/upgrade might be the preference?

Given he still has 2 years left I'd say keep him for at least one more year. Unless he and Dimma don't get on, but there is no suggestion on that and as far I'm aware he left Richmond on good terms.

 

[Iva Bigun]

You got him for an end of 2nd round pick, and bearing in mind you're basically just keeping him as quality depth, how much convincing are you talking?

Guessing futures or pick consolidation/upgrade might be the preference?

What we got him for and what he’s worth a two very different things, sellers market for key forwards. He had a career best year last year so has some runs on the board he didn’t have when he arrived, but was pushed out this year with kings return.

With two years on his contract, I can’t see him leaving, unless as has been already stated he doesn’t get along with Dimma.

 

[fargothegreat]

Dogs should ask the question. Could use him if Naughton leaves.

Naughton leaving? :O

 

[Golden_6]

Dogs should ask the question. Could use him if Naughton leaves.

Probably the least likely club to need him in the entire league.

 

[Tonythetiger]

What we got him for and what he’s worth a two very different things, sellers market for key forwards. He had a career best year last year so has some runs on the board he didn’t have when he arrived, but was pushed out this year with kings return.

With two years on his contract, I can’t see him leaving, unless as has been already stated he doesn’t get along with Dimma.

Years ago Dimma talked about having Dan Rioli live with their family and how they would have taken in Mabior if they had room. Nothing since then has indicated any sort of strained relationship but he just never quite took the next step with us and when he left Richmond it was all positive. He would fill a need with us now that Riewoldt has retired but I doubt it would eventuate.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Hawks maybe interested ?

 

[Colonial]

Casboult is almost done, and Walter is a first year player. Chol is definitely needed. Would take overs for the Suns to let him go.

He was excellent last year filling in for King.

Lol what? If your club is putting him out there then no not overs.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

It's a bit rough by The Suns shopping Chol around given he moved up there to be close to his family.

 

[Iva Bigun]

It's a bit rough by The Suns shopping Chol around given he moved up there to be close to his family.

That’s true if the report is correct, at this point is just some unreliable Victorian based journos

 

[Jirik13]

It's a bit rough by The Suns shopping Chol around given he moved up there to be close to his family.

Who said that Suns are shopping Chol? All Cal said that he could be a trade option for clubs seeking KPF due to limited market and lack of opportunity. I have little doubt clubs are interested but so far I did not hear that Chol wants to leave or Suns are shopping him.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

What coin is he on?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Lol what? If your club is putting him out there then no not overs.

Is it still "lol what" if it's not the club?

 

[Colonial]

Is it still "lol what" if it's not the club?

If the club is putting him out there, and yes it could just be media hence the “if”, then yes it is “lol what”.

 

[Colonial]

If the club is putting him out there, and yes it could just be media hence the “if”, then yes it is “lol what”.

Maybe Tomorrow no response other than a “laughter like”? Can’t hold a discussion?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Maybe Tomorrow no response other than a “laughter like”? Can’t hold a discussion?

You didn't answer the question

 

[Colonial]

You didn't answer the question

I literally did.