Player X vs Y vs Z - 2016

[Keg on legs]

Barlow V Montagna V Dusty

Dusty for sure

 

[King_Steele]

Dusty for sure

No love for Joey keg?

I'm liking him this year. Dusty is a fav pick of mine also but gap between good & bad games is to big IMO, hopefully that will improve with another pre-season.

 

[Keg on legs]

No love for Joey keg?

I'm liking him this year. Dusty is a fav pick of mine also but gap between good & bad games is to big IMO, hopefully that will improve with another pre-season.

I like joey, just that I think dusty will have the bigger year. You're spot on about the gap between his best and worst, but I reckon that's closing. Wouldn't surprise me at all if he's the number 1 scoring fwd this year.

I may still sneak joey in as insurance though!

 

[King_Steele]

I like joey, just that I think dusty will have the bigger year. You're spot on about the gap between his best and worst, but I reckon that's closing. Wouldn't surprise me at all if he's the number 1 scoring fwd this year.

I may still sneak joey in as insurance though!

Agree 100%

Can't go wrong with either, so its a win-win

I'll probably get Chop-sticks in when it comes to round 1 lockout LOL

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I've gone for Wingard and Barlow. Reckon Barlow will have the biggest year of the three, and Wingard will total the same as Dahlhaus, so naturally have gone the cheaper option.

Shaw + B.Smith OR K.Simpson + Kolodjashnijhabsdjasd ?

Shaw and Smith.

 

[nameless]

I'm pretty set with my safe picks, but is interesting how a couple of changes can make things very different... eg.

Boyd, McVeigh, Fyfe and Rookie

OR

Rampe, Yeo, Sloane, Gibbs (M5, with Libba M6)

Option A basically has 3 top scorers from last year and then a 6th mid rookie.
With option B being just about trying to pick the breakouts/fallen premo's

I don't like having 5 mid rookies, but it's good to have the flexibility if we have a season where no rookies are looking good.

I may end up with a mix of the two.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Definitely option A for mine but a mix could potentially be good. I rate Yeo and Rampe quite highly

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Dangerfield + Buddy vs Shiel + Martin

 

[King_Steele]

Dangerfield + Buddy vs Shiel + Martin

Shiel & Dusty.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

 

[King_Steele]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

Tough one man.

If I had to choose I'd go the SuperCoach royalty route of Gaz & Pendles

 

[Unique Name]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

GAJ and Pendles.

I feel that's the safer option.

 

[Tang]

Dangerfield + Buddy vs Shiel + Martin

Martin shiel for me, but opinions may differ

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

Have to have gaz, would like to fit the other two in as well but if I had to pick one it would be pendles.
Just

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

KK v Jimmy ?

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

Gaz and Pendles. lock n load

 

[King_Steele]

KK v Jimmy ?

KK.

I rate him very highly & love the upside & ceiling of this bloke.

I actually started with KK & Laird last year as midpricers but get this traded them both out by round 6.

Both locked & loaded for 2016 LMAO

95+ avg easily for KK IMO.

 

[Samples]

Dangerfield + Buddy vs Shiel + Martin

Tough one. Danger and Buddy just

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

I'd take GAJ and Pendles

KK v Jimmy ?

Jimmy

 

[Me Myself and I]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles
You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

GAJ & Pendles

KK v Jimmy ?

Jimmy

 

[Me Myself and I]

Which ruc/mid pair?
Grundy & B. Crouch OR Martin & Hopper

 

[NinjaSwan]

KK v Jimmy ?

KK

 

[King_Steele]

Which ruc/mid pair?
Grundy & B. Crouch OR Martin & Hopper

Stefan & Hopper

 

[toxic]

Which ruc/mid pair?
Grundy & B. Crouch OR Martin & Hopper

Not Grundy
Not now
Not ever

 

[toxic]

GAJ , Fyfe , Pendles

You can only pick 2 and leave out 1, who goes?

Fyfe and GAJ

 

[Feerits Elf]

Not Grundy
Not now
Not ever

Why, what's wrong with Reg?

 

[toxic]

Why, what's wrong with Reg?

Not sc relevant

Wont be a top 10 ruck