yaco55
Hall of Famer
They key word there is VFL level. Liam Jones is a gun at VFL level. You are going off VFL reports and a couple of flashes in a practice match. Until Hogan actually debuts he's shown nothing at AFL level. Boyd has shown very little but at least he's been able to physically cope with the demands of being in an AFL system.
I watch with my own eyes - Hogan has shown more ability to get up the ground at AFL level - My eyes tell me that Boyd is more dimensional.
Who would I prefer - Hogan !